Open 81 - The New C9 - Game Over

[roflcopter]

blakadder is an acceptable deadline lynch but i would really rather more people come to the realization that muerrto is scum and help me lynch him.

[Muerrto]

i would really rather more people come to the realization that muerrto is scum and help me lynch him.

Can you post some evidence? Some quotes? You're a mason dude, you have no power but the ability to PM. Stating you know who scum is period is retarded. arrogant, and the reason why you got on my nerves before I even posted.

[StrangerCoug]

OK, roflcopter, now that you're here, answer my #592:

Can you list his actions? I thought he was scummy because he HAD NO actions. That doesn't quite apply to me.

sure thing pal, here goes

argh i dont want to be on rofl's side

unvote

this is scummy

vote:forbidden light

i agree with the others points

this is scummy

I also get the whole deal with Vamp. Seems really opprotunistic given his poting history.

FoS Vamp

.

More later.

lol i keep screwing myself over

this is scummy

Explain all of the above.

I like the Vig directing actually but I'd like it on IM because:

A. He's lurking as bad as Vamp and not contributing anything.

B. I wanna test the masons.

this is so scummy.
it says "my predecessor and this claimed mason are guilty of the same infraction. shoot him!"

One dead mason instead of the Vig possibly accidently hitting a power role randomly is a good trade

this is especially scummy, since instead of accidentally hitting a power role you'd like the vig to purposefully hit a power role

It's a good a use of the Vig as any

except, you know, not shooting a mason

@muerrto: please respond to this point against your theory...

scum claiming masons wouldn't be so dumb if there weren't a serial killer in this open setup.

and this new one against your plan...
announcing in thread which mason you want vigged is a great way to let the scum know which one they won't be wasting a kill on (ie the other one) and convincing the vig to kill a mason is like the biggest gift you could possibly give the scum.

I understand Muerrto replaced Vamparific, but your case is lopsided toward the replacee as opposed to the original player. This tells me nothing about why you thought Vamp was scummy for those posts before he was replaced. Is Muerrto scummier to you than Vamparific, as illogical as this question sounds?

[roflcopter]

i agree with this guy called chamber whose custom title is "cases are scummy"

[strife220]

Haven't posted here in a few days. Not a lot has happened, BlakAdder is still a good lynch. Deadline's in a week and everybody should be looking more seriously at the vote count and contributing to the upcoming lynch. Right now BlakAdder and GreasySpot are the top two, with several people at 1 vote each.

[armlx]

i agree with this guy called chamber whose custom title is "cases are scummy"

*facepalm*

[Korts]

i agree with this guy called chamber whose custom title is "cases are scummy"

*facepalm*

armlx is now officially down from my Inexplicably Scum-list.

[Korts]

On other news, BlakAdder is obviously the lynched-to-be.

unvote, vote: BlakAdder

[armlx]

L-2, claim and/or die etc etc.

[StrangerCoug]

i agree with this guy called chamber whose custom title is "cases are scummy"

Well, chamber is not in this game, so stop dodging my question and give a real answer. You and I are already NK bait, and the fewer reasons you give all of us to off you, the better.

[Korts]

i agree with this guy called chamber whose custom title is "cases are scummy"

Well, chamber is not in this game, so stop dodging my question and give a real answer. You and I are already NK bait, and the fewer reasons you give all of us to off you, the better.

Leave him, I think you should. And don't even think about offing him.

[StrangerCoug]

i agree with this guy called chamber whose custom title is "cases are scummy"

Well, chamber is not in this game, so stop dodging my question and give a real answer. You and I are already NK bait, and the fewer reasons you give all of us to off you, the better.

Leave him, I think you should. And don't even think about offing him.

I'm not saying I'm going to vig him; I'm saying that there are enough reasons as to why he probably won't live until tomorrow already (his claiming mason way too early, his being of little help to us, etc.) and his imminent death doesn't need to be sped up.

[The Fonz]

Again, Muerrto's game theory opinions are not a scumtell.

[Korts]

The fact that he's being of little help to us and you (the vig, or so you say) don't vig him isn't going to get him NK'ed, since there's no other pro-town killing role. I don't understand your logic unless you're actually the SK.

[Korts]

EBWOP

in reply to SC, obv

by the by, I agree with Fonz.

[Muerrto]

I'm not saying I'm going to vig him; I'm saying that there are enough reasons as to why he probably won't live until tomorrow already (his claiming mason way too early, his being of little help to us, etc.) and his imminent death doesn't need to be sped up.

Was going to post a response to this but decided it'd help the scum too much. Can we stop discussing who's gonna get NK'd?

[StrangerCoug]

The fact that he's being of little help to us and you (the vig, or so you say) don't vig him isn't going to get him NK'ed, since there's no other pro-town killing role. I don't understand your logic unless you're actually the SK.

As I said, I have no intent to kill him. Although I attacked the mason claim for a good while and he's acting generally anti-town, I see no reason why I specifically should get rid of him. He and I both have only a very small chance of making it past tonight assuming neither of us gets lynched, and I'm more likely to be NK'd than he is.

Also, SK claiming vigilante makes less sense than you'd think because it's suicide. If I really am the serial killer, my goal is to be the last person standing, and fakeclaiming vigilante, whether there's a counterclaim to it or not, is essentially throwing in the towel since I get killed by the Mafia thinking I'm really the vig. I don't need to give them any more advantage in killing me than they already do.

[armlx]

The fact that he's being of little help to us and you (the vig, or so you say) don't vig him isn't going to get him NK'ed, since there's no other pro-town killing role. I don't understand your logic unless you're actually the SK.

That line of discussion gets us nowhere and only sets up for poor decisions. SC's alignment will be discovered tonight regardless of him living or dying, end of story.

[The Fonz]

Just to make clear: I do not think the Blakadder lynch is optimal, but it's fine as a deadline lynch. There is some case against him.

[Lowell]

It's better than "fine." BlakAdder is sitting back and hoping the pressure dies. I can't tell you how many times I've done that.

[armlx]

He hasn't posted on site in a week, which is probably worth a

Prod Blakadder

.

[Sun Tzu]

I still think silence is a good lynch but BlakAdder is ok if that's not going to happen.

Muerrto's bad thinking is probably legitimate bad thinking and not a scum tell.

[JordanA24]

He hasn't posted on site in a week, which is probably worth a

Prod Blakadder

.

Agreed, if he turns out to claim a believable power role, then the longer he takes to claim will leave us less time to form another bandwagon.

[Rogueben]

BlakAdder has been prodded. Greasy Spot has requested replacement, I will try and get one today.

[StrangerCoug]

Mod: What is the vote count?