Open 84 - Fire and Ice Mafia - Game Over!

[Eldritch Lord]

This would be a good argument, but there's two scum groups. It's easy to see a situation where Chubbs is Ice and joubert is Fire.

joubert is not the only person trying to keep the attention on chubbs. you and alabaska are equally guilty of this. far too many people are investing way to much in keeping chubbs at the forefront.

Catching a JCS reference earns you +25 cool points.



No further comment on the proceedings, still waiting to hear from Joubert--which oddly enough I can only imagine being pronounced JOO-bert and looking a lot like the popular Dilbert comic character.

---

ChubbsMcLubbs (4): Snix, Alabaska J, Geddingsworth, somestrangeflea
Joubert (4): roflcopter, forbiddanlight, orangepenguin, mik5
roflcopter (1): Joubert
armlx (1): Scigatt
No Lynch (1): ChubbsMcLubbs

Not Voting (3): armlx, Eldritch Lord, Sun Tzu

[roflcopter]

that was an easy one to catch - i played caiaphas in JCS my sophomore year of high school

[Alabaska J]

that was an easy one to catch - i played caiaphas in JCS my sophomore year of high school

sweet.

I soooooo wish I could one day be as good as the actor who played Judas in the movie…can't think of his name…he died a few years ago too :'(

[Eldritch Lord]

that was an easy one to catch - i played caiaphas in JCS my sophomore year of high school

sweet.

I soooooo wish I could one day be as good as the actor who played Judas in the movie…can't think of his name…he died a few years ago too :'(

Carl Anderson, RIP, greatest Judas ever.

I've been pushing my music teacher to do JCS for our musical, but she is an old, worthless bat who refuses to do anything with the slightest bit of class. Okay, that may be a tad harsh.

[Alabaska J]

that was an easy one to catch - i played caiaphas in JCS my sophomore year of high school

sweet.

I soooooo wish I could one day be as good as the actor who played Judas in the movie…can't think of his name…he died a few years ago too :'(

Carl Anderson, RIP, greatest Judas ever.

I've been pushing my music teacher to do JCS for our musical, but she is an old, worthless bat who refuses to do anything with the slightest bit of class. Okay, that may be a tad harsh.

If you've got someone with the vocal range to sing Jesus, I say go for it.

[Alabaska J]

way to not respond to my point about being joubert's partner, alabaska. instead you just tried to put a little distance between the two of you by talking about how you're possibly willing to lynch him. and yet you still prefer the chubbs lynch.

I've already said I think chubbs' actions are more indicative of noobscum than noobtown.

Also,

mod prod chubbs

I don't think he's posted for quite some time.

[roflcopter]

please

prod: armlx

too while you're at it, he hasn't posted since confirmation.

[armlx]

Forgot to watch topic this one. I'm here.

I need to re-examine the wagons so far at a less sleeping time.

[Scigatt]

Taking a look over this game so far...

I never thought Chubbs was scummy. To me, his posts indicate the classic symptoms of acute newbieitis(as opposed to chronic newbieitis, but that's off-topic). I can't see anything otherwise that points to scum.

Joubert's post #64 is super-scummy. He's definitely on my scum shortlist at the moment. I'd like to see at least one more post from him before I decide whether to jump on the bandwagon, though.

I suspect that Alabaska is BS'ing us when he says that Chubb's play is more noobscum, but it's just a hunch. Alabaska, do you have any solid reasons for believing this?

rofl, I agree with your suspicions on ssf, but Geddingsworth seems like town to me right now. While IMO he is being too hard on Chubbs, I don't see anything that he's done so far that is scummy. Can you elaborate?

P.S.:Snix, look at Open 62

[somestrangeflea]

The problem with playing with an inexperienced player is that some people will jump on every "newbie" action as a genuine scumtell, and votevotevote. Others will dismiss absolutely every scummy thing they do as a nulltell.

The problem here is finding the point where newbishness stops and scumminess begins. Everyone has their different ideas of where the line is, which is what makes it so frustratingly difficult to determine whether or not they're scum. More importantly, because of this, it's even more difficult to use that player's connections to everyone else to work out which of

them

might be scum!

I, personally, stand by my vote, and am more compelled to hold it considering that Chubbs completely vanished when his wagon began to pick up votes.

[Snix]

Both of thier disappearances are annoying me. While I understand the case against Chubbs, joubert's attempt to set up multiple lynches based on a town flip just screams for more attention.

unvote, Vote: joubert

[Eldritch Lord]

Vote: Joubert

Come out, come out, wherever you are.

[forbiddanlight]

What is Joubert at anyway?

Mod, can I has votecount?

Well, why not.
---

Joubert (6): roflcopter, forbiddanlight, orangepenguin, mik5, Snix, Eldritch Lord
ChubbsMcLubbs (3): Alabaska J, Geddingsworth, somestrangeflea
roflcopter (1): Joubert
armlx (1): Scigatt
No Lynch (1): ChubbsMcLubbs

Not Voting (2): armlx, Sun Tzu

[roflcopter]

I don't see anything that he's done so far that is scummy. Can you elaborate?

the timing and manner of ged's chubbs vote were both very summy to me. he slid in as the wagon was gaining some serious steam, and added nothing at all. looking at this posts again in isolation i notice that he too seems to have a seriously vested interest in keeping the focus on chubbs and off joubert.

but then, ssf just did the same thing again in his most recent post that caught my attention when he voted chubbs, which is calling out another tell that can be either newbie or scum and pushing it hard, namely disappearing under pressure. this time though he simultaneously totally ignores the fact that joubert has pulled the same exact stunt, and keeps his vote on the chubbs wagon, which at this point is rather importent.

[ChubbsMcLubbs]

I'm still here.

Just been busy lately cause of work. sorry guys

[roflcopter]

he lives!

[Alabaska J]

now all we need is joubert…

[Scigatt]

now all we need is joubert…

Got any answers for me?

[mik5]

I would also like to hear what Sun Tzu and Orange Penguin think. New perspectives will be helpful.

[orangepenguin]

Perspectives about what? Joubert or Chubbs? Or just my thoughts in general?

(But it's 3 AM, so I'm gonna sleep for the night)

[mik5]

Sorry, I wasn't specific. I was talking more about the vote split between Joubert and Chubbs? Who do you think is more scummy and why?

[Eldritch Lord]

Woah, woah, Mik5. Settle down, Orange, I'd like your impressions in general.

Both Chubbs and Joubert have acted scummy, but lets not tunnelvision here.

[armlx]

Something is up with this Joubert wagon.

[roflcopter]

Something is up with this Joubert wagon.

you're kidding right?

otherwise, please explain what exactly you think is "up," pronto.

[mik5]

@ Eldrictch, how am I being Tunnelvisioned? The last several pages have primarily been about Joubert and Chubbs, so discussing those two specifically doesn't seem too ridiculous.

@ Armlx: very insightful =)