Open 81 - The New C9 - Game Over

[BlakAdder]

vote:roflcopter

. Just seems like everything he's said so far is kinda pointing towards scum.

[BlakAdder]

Why would we want potential masons to claim now, especially with no doc.

That's not necessarily true. There could be another doctor.

[BlakAdder]

True. I guess I was being a little reckless there.

[BlakAdder]

Wow. I get caught up in work for a day and come back to claims on Page 3.

...

Anyway, anyone suggesting roflcopter for today's lynch, under the circumstances and given his claim, should be hit in the head with a baseball bat.

vote:roflcopter. Just seems like everything he's said so far is kinda pointing towards scum.

Would you care to elaborate on your thought process behind this post, please, BlakAdder? Cause, frankly, it's textbook bandwagoning.

That was before he claimed mason, and I just thought that his behavior was kind of suspicious. Making assumptions is part of a game of mafia, after all.

unvote

[BlakAdder]

Could you elaborate on what you mean when you say "making assumptions" is part of the game of mafia and what exactly you were making assumptions about?

Pretty simple, really. If everyone waited until they were totally sure that someone was scum, deadline would roll around before we reached a majority. Also, my assumption was voting for roflcopter, obviously.
Also, I don't think I need to justify my intuition, but whatever.

[BlakAdder]

Also, I don't think I need to justify my intuition, but whatever.

But you do. Intuition is not valid reasoning.

Okay, good point. Guess I just kinda get used to going by my gut and I forget that not everyone thinks like that.

- Edited to fix tags. Mod.

[BlakAdder]

I agree with Bystand. I want to vote Vamp, but I'll give him a chance to give some particular defensive evidence against himself first. But for now,

FOS: Vamp

[BlakAdder]

@ rofl:
I understand why you're thinking this way, but you're reading a bit too much into what I say. First, this is just how my thought processes work. Second, by the time that I got back to the thread, looked over the posts that were made in my absence, and found someone scummy, everyone else had already said what I thought was suspicious of the other players. I didn't think it would give me much credibility if I just quoted everybody.

[BlakAdder]

Hey, regarding rofl's comment

I'm not normally a fan of the long analysis posts that look at everyone in brief. It's a good scum tactic to post a summary of the game's action to look active as well as to paint people's actions in a scummy light in the hopes that others will start a wagon.

However, forbiddanlight is asking her own questions and actively prompting specific people, so I don't count it against her in this case.

[BlakAdder]

EBWOP: Finally breached the massive wall of text. Great job there, Forbiddan. This just made scumhunting loads easier.
In regards to the content itself, you did a good job of keeping neutral, not painting anyone in a good or negative light.
I'll have finished going over my own notes in a minute, and I'll have a more game-related post.

[BlakAdder]

Hey, I'm not scum with Tin. I just wanted to point out a minor mistake that rofl had made in his post. It's not that I'm supporting Tin or anything, I just don't like false accusations.

[BlakAdder]

Hey, I'm not scum with Tin. I just wanted to point out a minor mistake that rofl had made in his post. It's not that I'm supporting Tin or anything, I just don't like false accusations.

It wasn't even a major accusation. Why did you feel you had to answer? Couldn't you wait for Tin to speak for himself?

I don't know. I speak (or, rather, post) without thinking a lot.

[BlakAdder]

Okay, I've been away for a while, but I should have no problems getting ahold of a computer now. I've reread and I'm finding StrangerCoug somewhat suspicious.

I'll

FOS GS

for tunnel vision.

Explain, even if you just spit out post numbers.

Where have you been for the last ten pages or so? He's been OMGUSing Username repeatedly without good reason.

HoS: Lowell

for calling a powerful pro-town power role useless.

Wtf. That's all I have to say.

That, and all the bandwagoning and votehopping, not getting off of rofl's back even after he claimed mason, and everything else that's been brought up already.

Vote: StrangerCoug

[BlakAdder]

Could we get a vote count, please?

[BlakAdder]

@lowell: wtf. starting a bandwagon without any reason = bad idea

@ rofl: I don't see much reasoning behind voting Armix or IAUN. I also disagree with your point against me, for obvious reasons.

@Korts: My name has no C in it.

@ Sun Tzu: Reasoning, please. This is the exact same reason people started voting me.

[BlakAdder]

in summary: discussion about directing the vig is important for the first few comments, but after it starts taking up pages of posts, it becomes unhelpful and distracting.

QFT

[BlakAdder]

bump
Come on, people, let's see some more posting.

[BlakAdder]

Oh come on. Give it 24 hours,

THEN

bump it!

But yeah, discussion here has really died down.

I'm an impatient person, in case you can't tell.

[BlakAdder]

unvote

Crap, what is that, four claims on Day one, now?

[BlakAdder]

Now that I think about it, I don't know if it's accurate to say that Iron Man claimed, since it was about the only thing he could do in that situation.
But I don't want to get off-topic.

[BlakAdder]

It certainly makes for some creative strategizing, I'll give it that. But if this keeps up, the game could get really weird.

[BlakAdder]

Why are we still debating on who we should lynch? Has anybody other than me read #507?

Something tells me this wasn't serious. Why would the Godfather out himself? If you think he was serious, Coug, just vig him tonight, and we can try to hit a goon today.

Also, while I'm at it,

vote: Lowell

for:
A. Demanding that the Masons claim
2. Lots of meaningless posts
D. Randomly trying to force a bandwagon on Sun Tzu
There are probably other reasons, but I'm kinda busy right now, and I'll list them later if I get the chance.

[BlakAdder]

Wow, Coug, way to overreact.

[BlakAdder]

im new so idk wat 2 do

How about posting in coherent english for starters?
Seriously though, do you mean new to the sight, or new to Mafia in general?

[BlakAdder]

To be honest, it's not much of a case right now, the main point against him is gut feeling.

Isn't going by my gut the reason people originally tried to start a wagon against me?

[BlakAdder]

EBWOP: You, included?

[BlakAdder]

@FL: We get it. You're voting Tin, but you think Korts and I are scummy. You can quit including that in every post you make now.
@IAUN: Just because I'm not broadcasting my thoughts to everyone (including the scum) doesn't mean I'm scum. Also, you're reading way too much into what I say. Trying to turn "That's four claims on day one, right?" into a scum tell just screams desperation.
@Korts: I see.

[BlakAdder]

Don't count me out yet, FL. I got back just a little while ago, and I've reread everything.
I hate to give another claim during Day One, but I'll do it anyway.

I am a vanilla townie.

No, I'm not a power role, sorry to say. Right now, my vote stands as is, though.

[BlakAdder]

Whatever. Obviously, the only result is me getting lynched, so I better just speed up the process.

unvote, Vote BlakAdder

Just gives me the chance to say I told you so sooner.

[BlakAdder]

I probably would have had more fun if I wasn't lynched Day one. But good game, anyway.