Mini #618 - Farside of the moon - over!

[OhGodMyLife]

Dangit.

[farside22]

A few of you are still a little tired from the long day in front of you. Not many have place a vote:

vote count

Cephrir 1 vote: (IcemanE)

Not voting:

Greasy Spot
thinktank
Rogue Shenanigans
Sibelius
Cephrir
Gatekeeper
Doktor Per
Light-Kun

[Light-kun]

Damn it, this is very bad news. What are the odds Dcorbe shot? Or that there is another vigilante . . . ?

Current thought process:

It seems that we have lost three players with possibility of four anti town players? Assuming this is the case, and just one of the anti town groups kill tonight, it is miss lynch to lose, huh?

Honestly, my immediate suspicion would have been on dcorbe for hammering a person who really had no business being a L-1 anyway. So, I decided to go back and look at who first diverted attention to StrangerCoug, aside from the deceased OGML and dcorbe. And that person is Greasy Spot. Greasy Spot voted StrangerCoug after completely thrashing dcorbe's argument and defending Doktor Per, who I highly think is scum. He also continued to defend Doktor Per on the semi cop claim incident. Also, his only reason for voting StrangerCoug is because he thought Stranger was putting too much pressure on Doktor. In this retaliation(page 6, 149), he managed to get several people to believe that StrangerCoug is mafia.

Including people who knew him to be a weaker novice. However, Cephir, unlike OGML, believed the argument Greasy Spot wrote despite the fact that it did little to actually make Stranger appear guilty. Doktor also found it to be happy to join, but as a new player, I can't say he isn't just being new. While other people were involved, the others who voted for him actually added some thought before voting. Stranger, just to note, did not actually go back to the GS argument, attacking Rogue Shenanigans. Nevertheless, these events, combined with last night's kills, I have decided that the following people are probably mafia:

Greasy Spot
Doktor Per (Who I always suspected...)
Cephir
and possibily: Rogue Shenanigans

Since I am without any kind of report or other material for today. I will stay with my earlier suspicion of Doktor Per until someone is able to tip my suspicion into their unfortunate favor.

Vote: Doktor Per

[Cephrir]

Including people who knew him to be a weaker novice. However, Cephir, unlike OGML, believed the argument Greasy Spot wrote despite the fact that it did little to actually make Stranger appear guilty. Doktor also found it to be happy to join, but as a new player, I can't say he isn't just being new. While other people were involved, the others who voted for him actually added some thought before voting. Stranger, just to note, did not actually go back to the GS argument, attacking Rogue Shenanigans. Nevertheless, these events, combined with last night's kills, I have decided that the following people are probably mafia:

Massively disagree. StrangerCoug was extremely scummy, and I don't think it was neccessarily GS's case that turned the tide on him. It definitely wasn't what caused my vote. I was already harboring doubts because of SC's coaching of DP; his behavior around the DP wagon and his arbitrary singling out of Rogue Shenanigans, and refusal to try to dig himself out of that hole, etc. all made him scummier than DP, who I was starting to believe, to me. However, I think DP is a good lynch today as I said and his death will provide us with plenty of information on who to go after next.

Vote Dokter Per

Sibelius, thinktank and RS need to start contributing. Light-kun, you need to post more so I can figure out why I have this funny gut feeling on you.

[icemanE]

However, I think DP is a good lynch today as I said and his death will provide us with plenty of information on who to go after next.

What info do you think we'll get? Dcorbe is dead and flipped town - I thought a Dok lynch would give us info on Dcorbe, but I don't see what we'll get out of it today.

[Cephrir]

Every player in this game has had some sort of reaction to that wagon, and we'd get a lot of info based on who pushed the wagon, who stretched too far defending him, etc. A lot of the game has been talking about that wagon, and we can't draw many conclusions from, like, 5 pages of the thread unless we know his alignment.

[farside22]

Prodded Doktor and Rogue. Let me know if I forgot about anyone.

[Gatekeeper]

Vote: Doktor Per

Going back to the first person that seemed odd. [/b]

[Rogue Shenanigans]

On flavour text alone I think it is pretty clear we have an SK and Mafia group.

I think DP might be our best bet for today, and probably the only thats gonna happen. I was as behind it as most others, but the quickness to the shift on SC stinks.

Vote:Doktor Per

[Gatekeeper]

Hmm with 9 left that is 5 to lynch, DP is at 4 votes.

[Light-kun]

Unvote

As much as I want to see him lynched, the speed with which this is happening is potentially bad. I am going to at least hear what he has to say in defense for today. Unless, he is being bussed to make others look innocent. Hm, I cannot wait to see how this turns out.

[Doktor Per]

The quickness to the railroading on DP stinks.

Fixed that for you, jerk. You are a violent, militant little guy, scummier than the moon.

Every vote I give will be read as scum tell, so I won't even bother.

[Cephrir]

Ugh, having second thoughts about DP again and the way Gatekeeper and RS hopped on seems scummy to me. And like Light said, that was just too fast.

Unvote

for now.

[farside22]

Sibelius has not picked up his two prod. Killa Seven is now replacing him.

[killa seven]

what up people.

[Greasy Spot]

Oh great.

[icemanE]

Ugh, having second thoughts about DP again and the way Gatekeeper and RS hopped on seems scummy to me. And like Light said, that was just too fast.

Unvote

for now.

Yup, I agree. I'm not feeling too good about Gatekeeper currently. My suspicion of Ceph is lowered - and I doubt he and Dok are scum partners, my vote on Ceph was to make sure of that. I think Dok just plays this game incredibly strangely.

unvote - vote: Gatekeeper

[Light-kun]

I still strongly believe Dok is mafia, but due to our standings today, we need to be VERY careful on deciding who we kill.

*Thinks*

Icemane, why are you voting Gatekeeper...? (He never got on my radar so, care to elaborate for the rest of the class, aka, me.)

[icemanE]

Icemane, why are you voting Gatekeeper...?

Ah, oops. I thought he was the one who said this:

I think DP might be our best bet for today, and probably the only thats gonna happen. I was as behind it as most others, but the quickness to the shift on SC stinks.

^ He's using a point that equally applicable to himself against Dok.

The post I responded to confused me:

Ugh, having second thoughts about DP again and the way Gatekeeper and RS hopped on seems scummy to me.

I just did a reread of Gatekeeper since I had a minute and I didn't notice anything very suspicious.

unvote - vote: RS

[Doktor Per]

Good, some kind of consensus. Then I can vote without silly OMGUS hysteria.

Vote: Rogue Shenanigans

[Light-kun]

*sighs*
I can see rogue as guilty, but Dok's vote is making me a tad edgy. It could just be bussing though. I am going to wait for Rogue to defend himself there. Also, Dok, care to defend against accusation today, or do you plan on simply ignoring the fact you were at L-1 in four consecutive posts.

[Doktor Per]

The only accusation that's been pushed against me is that I seem scummier than a duck, there is nothing to defend against except the, I don't know you, you don't know me, let's take things from there, I'm no master of Mafia seeing as the only other game I ever played was a Doctor Dethy where we (town) lost. Also the fact that I can't even vote without everything going haywire is stupid.

[Cephrir]

You could scumhunt, that might help.

RS wagon seems good to me. If nothing else, he could use a little pressure.

Vote: RS

[farside22]

With votes coming fast a furious the vote count stands as of now.

vote count

Doktor Per 3 votes: (Light-Kun, Gatekeeper, Rogue Shenanigans)
Rogue Shanigans 3 votes: (icemaneE, Doktor Per, Cephrir)

Not voting:
Greasy Spot
thinktank
Killa Seven

[farside22]

Just bumping due to the games being locked out.