okay well I got home too late last night to do a proper one and I don't wanna keep people waiting
so I'm just gonna do a really shitty tier list with some thoughts real quick here since I can't seem to find proper time to devote to mafia this week ;_;
[Something_Smart/Duunstral]
[the_worst/Firebringer/Gamma Emerald]
=====
[MariaR/Menalque/Pinkball]
I'm sort of here-ish give or take.
In my 360 no-scope I-want-some-spicy-credit-after-the-game solve I had [Mena/PB/Ico/Ceph] but I think I'd like to replace Mena with MariaR. I still struggle to see where like, any of Menalque's thought processes came from earlier on in the game. I've liked his posting today a lot more though including his more recent pushes. Doesn't look like scum pushing a mislynch. MariaR on the other hand I know is pushing a mislynch and I'd expect her to town read me here given my play being pretty similar here to the game we just finished together. I struggle to find anyone who hard town reads Cephrir and hard scum reads me off our 1v1 as having genuine reads. (another reason I scum read Ico) It feels like a forced political read that MariaR can get away with because she got that "I know better than you also I'm good at this game" tone that everyone wants to town read and sheep. And like that may be true, but occam's razor tells me she's more likely to be scum this game.
PB I just think reevaluates me at some point? Like it's fine that he wants to town read me but uhhhhh why has the wagon on me not forced him to at the very least ask me a few questions, especially given my absence. It's weird because in the same way I find MariaR's read on me political, I feel the same way about PB's town read on me. I don't understand why it's there given what PB has used to justify it. But idk, maybe he just has a soul read on me and he
has
been townier than the other slots.
I'm depending on Duck to take up the reigns of tunneling Iconeum when I'm gone. None of what he says makes sense coming from town imo. Just reading what he's said about me—which is mostly all I've been able to skim this day phase—75% of the time he's hedging and 25% of the time he's justifying a scum read on me for bad reasons. Which is really really really weird. Because most of the consensus scum read or what have you on me currently is for pushing Iconeum in a lazy way, and yet Iconeum didn't think I was scummy off that. In fact at the time, he argued I could be town off that. Now he's switching that around and finding reasons for me to be scum? Like my 1v1 with Krazy? That's not a town read progression.
Cephrir slot I've said enough on. I think Cephrir has come in with some "better" posting that has saved his slot for the time being but um... It's not anything particularly towny. I also think coming around to a town read on me now makes perfect sense from a scum!him perspective. He wants to look better when I flip. Because when I flip his slot is almost assuredly next. So yeah, uh... Don't forget that Krazy used to be this slot?
And that's all folks
I'll flesh out my reads in a stylish Q&A or AMA fashion since that's easier to do via phone
