Penalty Box Mafia - Eagles. Game over. Scum wins (0-1)

[Flameaxe]

Flameaxe, if we don't lynch you, we have no idea whether or not you are scum, and we only get one more chance to find scum.

Clearly someone hasn't read up on the mechanics enough.

[Flameaxe]

Didn't the other team make a decision, meaning we're deadlined? Isn't there a way of deciding what actions take place at deadline here - either no-lynch cause we didn't reach a majority, or a lynch because Flameaxe has 4 Votes while nobody else has any?

Someone else does.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Flameaxe, if we don't lynch you, we have no idea whether or not you are scum, and we only get one more chance to find scum.

Clearly someone hasn't read up on the mechanics enough.

You aren't the only one off the ice.

[ZeekLTK]

Just for something to discuss...

I don't really see why a lynch is even necessary... I mean, the other team scored a goal before even lynching any scum. If I am truly scum as you say, keeping me on the bench would allow the team to be better. But if I'm town (like I am), and nothing changes, you don't have that risk of losing a townie.

Because at this point we are not going to score 2 goals in 2 days (considering we have scored 0 in 7 days).

Considering how hard it is to score, the best we can hope for is to score 1 goal and tie it up.

The tiebreaker is "first team to lynch all their scum", so we NEED to lynch our last scum if we hope to have any chance of winning. We won't lynch scum unless we lynch SOMEONE, and we have to start somewhere. You are, by the numbers, the most likely candidate to be the scum.

Also the other team scored a goal because we had 3 scum on the ice (one of them was our goalie). The other team obviously isn't going to do this so we clearly can't count on that as to how we're going to score. The only thing we can hope for is that we get rid of ALL of our scum, have a total pro-town roster (including the bench) and hope that they put their only scum on the ice AND that is somehow enough to give us a goal...

[Lowell]

^^^^ agree with this.

Also, *bump*

[Foolster41]

I don't want to wait any longer.
Flameaxe is lynched. I'll handle end of night soon.

[Flameaxe]

Bah, go town.

[Mastermind of Sin]

crap.

[Foolster41]

Sorry I totaly forgot, and this computer has outdated notes. I'll have to do it tomarrow morning. it's too late now. Again, sorry.

[Foolster41]

A note is found in Flameaxe's locker. It says "DF Left/Persuader." Looks like he was playing for your team after all.

The hawks get the puck take the shot and oh! barely misses!

it is now pre-day 9. THIS IS THE FINAL DAY OF THE FINAL PERIOD.

[strife220]

Anybody want to take the initiative to make a big chart with everyone's claimed positions, when they were on the ice, and flavor of how that period played out?

[ZeekLTK]

Eagles

Goalie: Capricious
Right Defence: Shanba/MoS
Left Defence: Flameaxe
Center: TVZ/Jdodge
Right Forward: None
Left Forward: Lowell/ZeekLTK

Hawks

Goalies: Farside22, swetapantsninja
Centers: Hackerhuck
Right Defense: ckillor, hasdfgas
Right Forward: Hjallti, isuquinndog
Left Defense: Lloyd, JordanA24
Left Forward: ThAdmiral, Iammars

And these were the lineups:

Scum

Correct position

Similar position (offense or defense)

Similar side (right or left)

Wrong position & side

Day 1

Hawks' possession = Hawks Score

--------------

Creampuffeater

--------------
---------

Flameaxe

---------

Oman

-----------
--

TheVenerableZorg

---

MoS

---

Shanba

--


------

Rob

-----

N9V

------

JordanA24

--------
--------

YogurtBandit

---------

Aimee

-------
-----------------------

IH

---------------------

Day 2

Eagles' possession = Shot Saved

------------------

Lowell

----------------------
---------

ZeekLTK

--------

TVZ

-----------------
------

Shanba

------

CPE

------

Jdodge

-------

-------

Hjallti

-----

Unright

------

ckillor

---------
---------

hasdgfas

-------

ThAdmiral

--------
-----------------------

IH

------------------------

Day 3

Hawks' possession = Miss Wide

------------------

Lowell

----------------------
---------

ZeekLTK

--------

TVZ

-----------------
------

Shanba

------

CPE

------

Jdodge

-------

---

Iammars

---

HackerHuck

------

hjallti

----
-------------

Lloyd

----------

hasdgfas

--------
-------------------

farside22

------------------

Day 4

Eagles' possession = Miss Wide

-------------------

Killerbob

-------------------
-----------

MoS

--------

Flameaxe

-------------
-----

ZeekLTK

-----

Jdodge

------

Lowell

-----

---

ThAdmiral

---

HackerHuck

-----

hjallti

----
-------------

Lloyd

----------

hasdgfas

--------
---------------------

TSPN

----------------------

Day 5

--------------------

Capricious

----------------------
----------------

MoS

-----------

Flameaxe

-----------
----------

JDodge-

----

TVZ

----

ZeekLTK

------------

-------------

TSPN

-----

Hacker

-----

Hjalliti

---------
-------------

Lloyd

------------

hasdgfas

------------
----------------------

farside22

---------------------

[ZeekLTK]

That was from what I posted earlier in the thread, I never updated it after Day 5. Maybe I'll do that later. I gotta go now though.

[ZeekLTK]

Oh, and Iammars came up as scum for the other team, I need to edit that in too.

[Mastermind of Sin]

I say we use this lineup:

Right Back: Shanba
Left Back: MoS
Centre: JDodge
Right Forward: Lowell
Left Forward: Zeetlk

This was yesterday's lineup:

Right Back: MoS
Left Back: Shanba
Centre: TVZ
Right Forward: Zeetlk
Left Forward: Lowell

[strife220]

I assume that if a player is playing out of position, it doesn't matter if they're defense, offense, or whatever. Switching around the two backs and the two fronts shouldn't make any difference. I think Shanba or MOS should be lynched, since we've already tried switching JDodge and TVZ around with no luck (I think..)

[Bogre]

I'm center forward, if thats still applicable.

This game is crazy.

[Mastermind of Sin]

I believe TVZ, or whoever replaced him, I have no idea who it is, is our last scum. Since the Hawks got the defense but didn't score, that makes me fairly sure our defense is all protown. That means someone in our offense is scum, and TVZ was the one on the ice instead of JDodge last time.

strife, your reasoning doesn't make any sense, because both Shanba and myself have ALSO been switched around with no luck. I already outlined earlier why the JDodge/TVZ pair should contain our last scum if Flameaxe wasn't scum.

[Lowell]

MoS- if this is true, why don't we bench BOTH Dodge and TVZ? Is there a reason you want one of them on the ice?

[Mastermind of Sin]

a) we need to fill the spot, because we only have enough people to bench one person
b) we just tested JDodge by benching him last period, when our offense failed to get the puck, so I think it's TVZ.

[strife220]

I'm cool with blindly following MoS's line-up. We're probably SOL with 2 players out of position anyway.
I'm cool with lynching anyone that isn't me right now. If defense has been getting switched around, then Mos and Shanba should be safe considering it doesn't sound much like our defense is sucking. TVZ, Lowell, and Zeek are probably the best choices for lynch, and MoS's line-up is reasonable

[strife220]

Wait, so how does this work again? Who's our captain?

I fully support MoS's line-up, with a lynch on TVZ (now Bogre) for our last day

[Mastermind of Sin]

Crub is the captain, so he needs to decide on the lineup.

[Bogre]

Uhm, Crub is not the captain, I am.

[Mastermind of Sin]

err, I meant Coach.