Gorrad wrote:BM! Been a while. Welcome to the game, please vote SlySly or Mirth.
Hey man. Sure has! Good to see you again though.
Sorry to say it, but i've read the game, and i'm not inclined to lynch someone solely for being an idiot. Who knows- maybe we have a Vig or something? I'm not saying Mirth and Sly havent been scummy, but i'd like to see more from the latter before we do anything with him. Mirth...well, i'm pretty torn. I'd really like to kill her, but im not sure i can do so on good reasoning. I'm far from convinced that she is scum. If it comes to a choice between her and BG, i'll gladly join the Unanimous Vote. In the meantime, i think we have better options to pursue.
My game analysis is here btw:
Natirasha is right about an early defendant claim being a good idea. I REALLY don’t like the way Mirth is jumping at shadows, and I especially hate the way in which she forces a claim out of Natirasha. Mirth herself would have me lynched for that. But then, this is Mirth we’re talking about here. It’s probably unrealistic to expect the same level of ability as you might from other players.
Chiefskye is giving me scummy vibes. Gorrad’s post on the setup confuses me a little. Tajo looks even scummier. Rofl at Post 67. It’s great to be in a game with Gorrad again
Post 76 by Cream could well be a massive slip if Babygirl is town.
Rich’s first post is pretty scummy and probably warrants suspicion. But, it’s a bit surprising to see Mirth so eager with the ‘confirm vote’.
Post 78 is equally inconsistent, as Mirth encourages Natirasha to claim for no reason, DESPITE opposing a claim from BG earlier. Why?
CS supports a claim too, and is reluctant to vote Theo. Again, feels scummy. Tajo votes for Cream. No reason given. Potential distancing? Natirasha’s claim seems genuine. One scenario I could POTENTIALLY see as being a very good play, is Mirth and Natirasha as a scumpair, setting up the whole claim thing, in an attempt to get a safeclaim of that nature into the mix. Just an idea.
Post 84 by Cream is mucho interessant. Same with Post 85, but again, I’m not exactly optimistic about getting anything useful or relevant out of Mirth this game…
Talk about TS 2.0!
CS joins the Cream-Mirth group. Humorous indeed.
He also claims to be able to back up Nat’s claim flavour wise. Would be interesting to wait for flavour counter-claims.
Matt feels town. It is a healthy mix of scummy and just plain irritating that Mirth insists on distorting the facts surrounding the Nat-claim. Jesus christ, did nobody ever teach you to take responsibility for your actions? Whether you meant it or not, you cant deny the facts. Post 99 by CS doesn’t make a whole lot of sense. If Nat had softclaimed power, and was actually relatively weak, wouldn’t it be beneficial for her to take the bullet, rather than save her own ass? That is, if you think she claimed genuinely.
Tajo tunnel-visions Cream.
Post 103 by CS is very scummy. Gorrad feels town. I’m hanging off his every word.
Malthusis suggests scum might not have NKs. Don’t understand Gorrad’s post 125 vote for Mirth. Mirth does seem to be jumping at shadows though. And I don’t think she is exactly playing to her town META.
I’m not entirely convinced by Gorrad’s case on Mirth. I mean, scum can slip inside info because they think the town might know already, or shortly know it. On the flipside, I really don’t like the way Mirth attempts to exaggerate the situation the town is in- it strikes me as if she doesn’t really have a grasp on what state the town is in. Malthusis tries to reassure Mirth. Tajo claims CS is town, for no apparent reason. Tajo is still tunnel-visioning Cream. I think a Tajo-lynch could be VERY informative at this point. Tajo also claims to be almost sure that BG is town. Not greatly impressed with Sly’s first bit of content. Nor his buddying with Mirth. Sly’s blatant fishing seems off. But I think he can wait for a bit.
Oh and for my own sake, a random checklist:
Populartajo x 3
Gorrad ??
Matt S
Cream
Mirth
CS
Go figure.
Rofl
BM
