Mini #564 - Mafia in Crubtown - Game Over

[Jenter Brolincani]

Away until Friday. Sorry guys.

[Crub]

Second Vote Count of Day 4

darkdude (1): Jenter Brolincani
No Lynch (1): darkdude

Not Voting (2) : Talitha, Pink Puppy

With 4 alive it takes 3 to lynch.

[Talitha]

I'm waiting to hear from Puppy before I vote.

[Pink Puppy]

I hadn't thought of a no-lynch. Usually I hate to no-lynch, but this may be one of the situations where it is smart to do it.

I'm trying to think about the setup from what we know of people who died, and guess how many scum we might have. I know it's not a sure-fire thing, but I think it may help a bit.

So far, we've had two power roles dead, two docs, right?

We have two killing roles/groups, and since nobody claimed vig, we can assume SK.

I also think Jenter is lying about being a rolecop. I've never seen one of those in a mini normal. If he's lying, we have no other power roles in the game, which makes a 3-man mafia group AND an SK seem unbalanced. Seems more likely we have a 2-man mafia group AND an SK.

Unless a vig or other power role is lying? I don't think it would help a power role to lie in lylo, even if that would keep them alive a bit longer. That wouldn't matter because the game could be over soon anyway.

Because of the number of power roles, I think it's likely we have 2 scum here, of different factions.

I think it's likely that DD and Jenter are the last two scum. One is an SK and one is a mafia.

I'm still trying to decide what is best to do here. Do we just no-lynch and hope the town wins through cross-kills?

[darkdude]

which makes a 3-man mafia group AND an SK seem unbalanced. Seems more likely we have a 2-man mafia group AND an SK.

I think 3 scum and one SK is more balanced due to potential crossfire. 2 scum can be killed off too easily.

[Jenter Brolincani]

Na, because there were 2 docs which reduces the crossfire proability greatly.

Please folks, let's lynch DD.

You do have reaosns to believe me, which is that firstly my predecsoor hinted at knowing VF was a killer, and secondly of course that 2 docs, no investigative roles, no killing roles, and 3 scum would be rather underpowered for town.

[darkdude]

I wonder why you didn't reveal that information yesterday then.

Obvious scum.

[Talitha]

This is doing my nut in.

But I think what I wrote in my first post is correct. If there are only 1 mafia and 1 SK left, lynching either will give an automatic win to the other.

I'm freaking out a little that there are two mafia left, but I can't think of any possible way to win from here if that's the case. Been thinking about waiting for a deadline, etc. But that would basically hand it to the scum anyway....

Bah! This sucks.

vote: no lynch

[Talitha]

unvote

[darkdude]

WTH?

It's bad for town, alright, but we can't give up yet.

[Talitha]

Sorry, that looked a bit weird.

I suddenly got worried and wanted to think a little bit more, but I was in a hurry to go out and couldn't explain.

The way darkdude seems so willing to vote for no-lynch made me wonder why.

[darkdude]

The way darkdude seems so willing to vote for no-lynch made me wonder why.

Maybe cause I'm town, and it's my best bet to win lol?

[Talitha]

It is a good piece of evidence in your favour.

Unless you are GF or SK with a night kill immunity.

How common are night kill immunities in mini games these days... anyone?

[Crub]

Third Vote Count of Day 4

darkdude (1): Jenter Brolincani
No Lynch (1): darkdude

Not Voting (2) : Talitha, Pink Puppy

With 4 alive it takes 3 to lynch.

I'm going to deadline this game if you all don't start to figure out what you're going to do. At deadline it will still take 3 to lynch, if you don't have 3 no one will be lynched.

[Pink Puppy]

How common are night kill immunities in mini games these days... anyone?

I don't think I've seen it lately, but that doesn't mean we can't have it here.

How do you feel about JB's claim of rolecop?

Not only have I never seen a rolecop in a mini, but something seems fishy about the way he gets his results. He's told a person's power, but not allignment? It seems an unusual way for that role to work, even if the role were possible.

[darkdude]

I doubt there are unkillable roles in this game.

I think Talitha and Jenter are scum. Of course, if my suspicion of 3-man mafia + SK is correct, then I'm actually the only town here.

This seems to be the case as no one is agreeing with me for a No Lynch.

[Talitha]

How do you feel about JB's claim of rolecop?

Likely BS, of course. I'm not sure why you think it's important at this stage of the game though.

dd: Huh, I could've sworn no lynch was my idea. And I'm not sure why anyone (mod included) is in a big hurry. We're entitled to take time to think and discuss in endgame.

That said, I'm just about over it, and I was only ever going to vote no-lynch today.

I'm currently guessing that Jenter & PP are SK & mafia.. Jenter wants to lynch darkdude (probably because he thinks he's mafia). PP wants to lynch Jenter (probably because she thinks he's SK). Darkdude might be scum with PP or just a townie.

Anyways

vote: no lynch

fer reals this time.

[Pink Puppy]

Well, I guess there could be 3 scum still in the game. I prefer to think it is two, just so I'm not alone, and have some chance of winning...

I think Jenter and DD are scum... The reason I was asking about JB's claim is because I want the two remaining scum to successfully kill each other, and not be confused as to who is scum. That's sort of the reason for no-lynching, I believe. To get crosskills.

Otherwise we're just handing scum the game.

vote: no lynch

[Jenter Brolincani]

Looked at it, and indeed no lynch is the only way I (and the one other townie) can win.

vote no lynch

[darkdude]

Yay for unanimous decisions!

[Crub]

End of Day Flavour

It is now Night 4, you have until 1am GMT on the 28/6 to get in your night choices.

[Crub]

End of Night Flavour.

Talitha and Dark Dude wake up at the begining of Day 5, the helpless Dark Dude stood no chance against Talitha the last representative of the Big City mafia. The Big City Mafia win.

I'm sorry this is brief I'm posting from my phone I'll be back in the next few days to post night actions and the complete setup

Thanks everyone for playing.

Setup

3 x Scum - Talitha, Jenter Brolincani, Cephrir
You are a member of the Mafia with <xxxx> and <xxxx>. You may talk with your partners at night. Each night, have one member from the group PM me the name of a player. That member will attempt to kill the named player.

You win when you gain and cannot lose a majority of the town's population.

1 x Serial Killer - Pink Puppy
You are a crazed Serial Killer. Each night, you may PM me the name of another player. You will attempt to kill that player during the night.

You win if you are one of the last two people alive, or nothing can prevent the same.

1 x Doctor - Yvonne Seer
You are one of Crubtown's doctors. Each night, you may PM me the name of another player. You will attempt to save that player from being killed during the night.

You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated.

1 x Paranoid Doctor - EmpTyger
You are one of Crubtown's doctors. Each night, you may PM me the name of another player. You will attempt to save that player from being killed during the night.

You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated.

Mod Note: Roleblocks and Protects target

6 x Vanilla Townie - Everyone Else
You are a vanilla townie. Each night, you must sit in silence and hope for the best.

You win when all threats to the town have been eliminated.

Night Actions

- I refer to the player who replaced into the role not the actual player who did the action where applicable.

Night 1

Talitha kills YvonneSeer
Pink Puppy kills YvonneSeer
YvonneSeer protects Talitha
EmpTyger protects and roleblocks Cephrir

Night 2

Jenter Brolincani kills EmpTyger
Pink Puppy kills Cephrir
EmpTyger protects and roleblocks windkirby

Night 3

Jenter Brolincani kills windkirby
Pink Puppy kills QuantumFruit

Night 4

Talitha kills Pink Puppy
Pink Puppy kills Jenter Brolincani

[Talitha]

Whew!

and Yay!

Thanks mod & all.

Obv PP killed Jenter (the other mafia) last night. And we killed PP, the dastardly serial killer!

[Cephrir]

Oh, thank goodness, I thought you guys hadn't figured out it was PP. I figured PP had killed me when I died because I didn't think anyone else would have killed me, although at the time I would have guessed Vig. Should have known nobody could make such bad arguments and still be town =P

I was planning to claim Cop D3 with one investigation being an innocent on QF; hence the buddying. I knew I wouldn't likely survive the game, but it still sucked dying to an SK I hadn't known existed =/

[windkirby]

Whoa, so it was DarkDude who was your partner? I was pretty sure it was Jent. And holy moly, which one of you dudders killed me?!

Pretty fun game, but I wish people had listened to me that DD was scum >_>