Mushroom Kingdom Mafia (Game over!)

[Riceballtail]

I'd actually be okay with a NL D1. Mindless wagoning right now is still roughly 70% likely to hit town. Even with some level of reasoning, we won't lower it too often.

UNVOTE
VOTE: NO-LYNCH

IGMEOY:Surye

I do still find it scummy, but you make a good point; I hadn't thought of it that way.

If we get close enough, I could be persuaded to lynch FL, but I'm not too anxious right now.

Mod edit:
Visible votecount:
Cream147 (6): armlx, Phoebus, Alabaska J, Gimbo, TheSweatpantsNinja, killa seven
FaerieLord (4): Surye, somestrangeflea, Rogue Shenanigans, mr. incrediball
Rogue Shenanigans (2): skitzer, farside22
TheSweatpantsNinja (1): iamausername
Alabaska J (1): populartajo
somestrangeflea (1): Dead Rikimaru

No lynch (2): malthusis, Riceballtail

Not voting (7): andersonw, Pepsidude, Cream147, FaerieLord, Celebloki, DragonsofSummer, sideney

With 24 alive it takes 13 real votes to lynch. At deadline, it takes 7 real votes to lynch.

[Gimbo]

Wait, No-Lynch doesn't make any sense because if we don't lynch, on D2, we will be stuck in the same situation that we are in now and also it gives the opportunity for scums to collect more coins for themselves.

FoS:Riceballtail

for trying to sneak in the idea of a No Lynch...maybe it's because we are catching onto one of his scumbuddies and he is just trying to divert our attention away form his scumbuddy without directly mentioning it so it won't be too obvious?

[Riceballtail]

No, Gimbo. We've already decided that we're going to end up doing some kind of mass-vig/cop tonight. At least one person should do something of town-use tonight, and I hope that it will provide more info. Sorry if it seems too weird, but I do think it would be of more use this way for now.

[andersonw]

Have read about 3/4s of this game. I agree with everyone that Gimbo is most likely confirmed.
Also, riceballtail, no lynch is generally a bad idea, because even lynching town gives us additional information, and anything could happen tonight.

I'll post something more substantial tomorrow, my other games had more priority than this one lately.

[Alabaska J]

Riceball, don't vote nolynch. Worst idea ever. Gimbo is actually 100% right for once. This isn't epicmafia.


Also, with Rogue's recent continuance of scummy behaviors started earlier, I am happy to lynch him today also, if his lynch will come about faster than Cream's. I'm thinking two scum already and we are set!

[armlx]

No Lynch = very bad in 95% of scenarios.

[Alabaska J]

No Lynch = very bad in 95% of scenarios.

If it is day one, then this percentage increases by 5%.

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

No, Gimbo. We've already decided that we're going to end up doing some kind of mass-vig/cop tonight.

Have we? If only that were the case. No lynch is obviously bad, etc. etc.

Alabaska's certainty makes me nervous.

[FaerieLord]

I did!

Yes but you have played with me in the past, and my profile on MTGS is slightly less...girlish, so to speak.

We've already decided that we're going to end up doing some kind of mass-vig/cop tonight.

Err...no we didn't

[sideney]

I think i will go with the majority, i don't have any idea from this day one. For now:

Vote Cream147

[Lawrencelot]

goborage replaces Dead Rikimaru

.

[Cream147]

I think i will go with the majority, i don't have any idea from this day one. For now:

Vote Cream147

Any decent reason that you're voting me, or are you simply voting me for going with the majority's sake.

FOS:sideney

. It's opportunistic, and it's self-admitted bandwagoning.

[armlx]

If it is day one, then this percentage increases by 5%.

QFT, give or take. Barring an interesting open set up, this is true.

[iamausername]

OK, let's get the deadline wagons rolling. Creamwagon is terrible, FL wagon is much better. Not totally against the Roguewagon either, but it's not as good or as big as FL's.

Unvote, Vote: FaerieLord

.

[goborage]

Hey I'm here. I'll just post what I think about the current page and then start from the beginning. In agreeance that No-lynch is a bad idea. I also don't like sidney's vote and justification, although I could see newb town making that post.

[farside22]

Hey I'm here. I'll just post what I think about the current page and then start from the beginning. In agreeance that No-lynch is a bad idea. I also don't like sidney's vote and justification, although I could see newb town making that post.

You know Sidney has been around longer then you. Look at the date.

FOS Goborage and Sidney

something just sounds like slight bussing do to the inaccuracy of his statement.

[goborage]

Check again. He only has 100 posts. And his sig implies that he's a bad player. There is a possibility that it is all some master plan to make himself look like a newb while not actually being one. But it seems like a lot of work for a ploy that would only work for one game (and even then would still draw scrutiny) and that could be easily deflated by any meta-ing.

And if he isn't a newb then don't you think he'd know better than to make a post like that?

[farside22]

Check again. He only has 100 posts. And his sig implies that he's a bad player. There is a possibility that it is all some master plan to make himself look like a newb while not actually being one. But it seems like a lot of work for a ploy that would only work for one game (and even then would still draw scrutiny) and that could be easily deflated by any meta-ing.

And if he isn't a newb then don't you think he'd know better than to make a post like that?

Sidney is on my short list of suspects, but seeing he is from another country may be the reason he has problems with forming opinion. I will take back my FOS on you, but still holding firm to Sidney.

[Riceballtail]

Mm, these thoughts are now going to be processed.

UNVOTE

[somestrangeflea]

No, Gimbo. We've already decided that we're going to end up doing some kind of mass-vig/cop tonight.

...since when had we decided that? It looks to me that you're not

really

paying attention to what's going on.

Maybe you don't need to.

IGMEOY: Riceballtail

I think i will go with the majority, i don't have any idea from this day one. For now:

Vote Cream147

Any decent reason that you're voting me, or are you simply voting me for going with the majority's sake.

FOS:sideney

. It's opportunistic, and it's self-admitted bandwagoning.

Absolutely.

IGMEOY: Sideney

For completeness sake,

ISGMEO Popular and Cream

.

[armlx]

IMO, sidney is pretty null ATM based on my experience with him.

[skitzer]

Hmm… Some things to note since last post:

Riceballtail is acting…strange. First he votes Surye, then No Lynch? I totally agree with Alabaska’s statement against him that this isn’t EpicMafia.

FoS: Riceballtail

I’m not a fan of pressure wagons. But I didn’t plan on switching to FaerieLord’s wagon anyway, seeing as my vote on Rogue Shenanigans is pretty much set in stone unless something amazingly scummy happens.

I, like Cream147, also would like to populartajo’s lurking, but also the weird post he made about hating Day 1. It seemed way out of the blue.

I dislike how some people are saying this game has no depth…I see bunches and bunches of depth in this game, maybe ya just gotta work hard to find it

Weird how mr. incrediball, when talking about the FaerieLord wagon, says an exact carbon copy of what Surye said earlier about the Cream147 wagon…

Gimbo made a lot of sense in the post about Riceballtail voting No-Lynch. Kudos to you.

Also, If we

were

going to do the vig cop thing tonight (which I don’t support because it’ll be a lot of randomness and could possibly hurt the town well beyond repair) we’d need a lot of planning. And I don’t see much planning going on.

[mr. incrediball]

Weird how mr. incrediball, when talking about the FaerieLord wagon, says an exact carbon copy of what Surye said earlier about the Cream147 wagon…

i liked the phrase, and stole it. sue me for plagerism.

[goborage]

I ignored much of Pg 1-6 but I do like SSF's and armlx's play.

@ everyone: Is there anything of significance in these pages that I've overlooked?

134: a post by sydeney. An early BW vote. Doesn't seem to be much thought behind it.

137: TSN - I actually don't find this suspicious seeing as how I've identified SSF as pro-town.

138: sydeney Jumps off a BW and makes his own on TSN. This post seems townish. We can see that Syd is loose with his vote (uses it for pressure) and that he is paying attention to the game rather than simply parking a vote.

147, 151: I completely agree that it is weird that TSN would make such assumptions.

149: Seems kind of townish in that TSN looks like he's trying to work out the setup.

158: farside seems townish for same reason.

205: Pheobus looks very townish for reasons I think are pretty obvious.

215: Don't like this post. For the opposite reasons of why I think many of the above are protown, I think this post screams "I don't really care what happens today and I'm going to put myself in a position where I can vote anyone."

237:

MAJOR FOS: iamausername

Do you not know why peach being kidnapped would suck? Can't believe no one pointed this out.

Surye's play certainly seems pro-town. But it could be scum trying to piggyback off of Gimbo's apparent townness. Surye's item-exchange posts are the first posts that he makes in 10 pages. He hasn't voted or scum-hunted but seems keen on looking like he's helping town. Kind of suspicious to me.

269: sideney again. I don't like this post. 131 posts between his last and this is all he has to say? Plus there's the fact that he refrained from voting which seems different from his M.O. Did he FoS simply because the people above him did? Is this simply sheep-town or something less innocent?

Pg 13-14: Inactive players making short posts. Sigh, I guess they can't all be scum.

Pg 15: mr. incrediball's posts make me happy.

Post 397: Heh Rogue seems to have forgotten where his vote was. From what I can see, RS voted for popular and then for TSN. He never voted for cream correct?

Post 544: sydeney again. Sounds like a big lie to me.

569: sydeney unvotes after realizing that no one is on the BW he created. Him sticking with his vote for so long may be a town-tell.

I'm labeling sydeney as a newb. More newb-town than newb-scum imo. I think a lot of his play can be described as newb-sheep but I like the fact that he made an original post against TSN and stuck with the vote for so long. He didn't develop a strong case but I'm thinking we shouldn't expect that from him.

I've ignored Gimbo's shenanigans seeing as how he's semi-confirmed.

Anyways I'm 99% certain I will be voting iamausername.

@ iamausername: Do you not know why peach being kidnapped would suck?

@ Rogue: Help me out, when did you vote for cream?

[Cream147]

237: MAJOR FOS: iamausername Do you not know why peach being kidnapped would suck? Can't believe no one pointed this out.

I've read the post, and I don't quite get what on earth you're talking about. The post says how a massclaim would suck for the town because it would expose Princess Peach. That's how I read it anyway. Reread it, seriously, I think you need to.