Penalty Box Mafia - Eagles. Game over. Scum wins (0-1)

[Mastermind of Sin]

Mod, can you point out to our replacements that they can start reading at page 20, because of the scum redistribution? Save them some time.

[strife220]

Read e last 16 pages. I agree with the risky flame-axe lynch. If we continue no-lynching it seems like we're guaranteed to lose.

Vote FlameAxe

[Foolster41]

Mos: Actually, I already did when I sent their role PMs.

[Bogre]

Hi guys. ATM I am still rereading Return of the Mafia (30/120 pages left), and then I will turn my attention to this. I still need to read and try and understand the exact way this works...a team is on the field and only they can vote/lynch? And we have to try and keep our team stronger than the other team while simultaneously scumhunting?

[strife220]

Mod: Why does the other team have a 'lynched' section on their first page that looks like:

Ejected: (3)
isuquinndog - Foreword Right - Backup captain
ckillor - DF Right - Prrsuader
JordanA24 - DF Left - Scum

While ours looks like:

Expelled from the game: (3)
Gatorguy91
creampuffeater
Oman

They have titles, while it doesn't even indicated the alignment of our lynched.

Sorry for nitpicking, it just stuck out to me when I started looking at their game.

[Foolster41]

Oops. Those lynched should have had their alignments said at night, but it should say in the first pos as well. Fixing.

[strife220]

Umm... didn't I just lynch Flameaxe? Or am I crazy?

[Foolster41]

Vote count
flameaxe 4 (-1) - Lowell MoS ZeekLTK Strife220
ZeekLTK 2 (-3) - Flameaxe
8 alive, 5 to lynch.

Let me know if I missed someone's vote, or if anyone needs prodding.
Deadline reinstated for 24 hours from now. (1:10am PST)

EDIT: Fixed count.
EDIT2: Yeah, 5 to lynch.

[Mastermind of Sin]

umm, if it's 4 to lynch, isn't that a lynch?

[Flameaxe]

And if it's 8 alive, isn't it 5 to lynch?

[Mastermind of Sin]

Aye, one would think so.

[Foolster41]

Fixed.

[strife220]

Hmm. Prod on Bogre perhaps so we can end the day?

[Foolster41]

I'm prodding, but I'm just going to call it a flameaxe lynch in 24 hours.

[Flameaxe]

Final game comments: -This game was a total joke, full of bullshit that we had no control over.
-I'm not scum and lynching me will probably lead to an enemy goal (Lynching defenders when no goals have gotten by, you people are smart!)
-Other than that, the only thing I can say is "you're stupid".

[Flameaxe]

Also: Anyone else realize how anxious Strife is? Just sayin'...He comes in, says he agrees, and keeps pushing a hammer for sooner and sooner, without actually giving any reasoning of his own...

And I forgot my future bah: BAILOUT!

[Foolster41]

I had thought I had explained it here, but i think it was in the other topic, I forgot to repeat it here. (Sorry.) Goal actions is judged AFTER the person is actually removed, so a person on the ice being lynched will still count as being there.

[strife220]

Also: Anyone else realize how anxious Strife is? Just sayin'...He comes in, says he agrees, and keeps pushing a hammer for sooner and sooner, without actually giving any reasoning of his own...

And I forgot my future bah: BAILOUT!

I'm the only goalie, so if I were scum we'd probably lose regardless of if I was lynched or not.

Reason for lynching you = desperation move. Zeek's reasoning already explained it

Basically what I'm saying is that because we had the exact same result for 2 days in a row, and we did this even though we switched everyone up position-wise (except Flameaxe) it basically proves that:

-TVZ and JDodge are interchangeable (aka they are both centers)
-Lowell and Zeek are interchangeable (aka they are both left wings)
-Shanba and MoS are interchangeable (aka they are both left defenders)

So the scum is one of the two who are not. I think the other team would have scored again by now if Cap was the scum, so it's gotta be Flame.

I'm voting for him when day begins.

[Foolster41]

So, it looks like Bogre is on vacation, and I'm unsure what to do. It seems kind of unfair to just call it lynch.

[Mastermind of Sin]

I don't really see this going any other way but a lynch on Flameaxe, if more people were around to vote. However, as much as it would pain me to have it happen, the only other solution I can think of would be a no lynch because we didn't reach a majority.

[Flameaxe]

I don't really see why a lynch is even necessary... I mean, the other team scored a goal before even lynching any scum. If I am truly scum as you say, keeping me on the bench would allow the team to be better. But if I'm town (like I am), and nothing changes, you don't have that risk of losing a townie.

Duh.

[Lowell]

I don't really see why a lynch is even necessary... I mean, the other team scored a goal before even lynching any scum. If I am truly scum as you say, keeping me on the bench would allow the team to be better. But if I'm town (like I am), and nothing changes, you don't have that risk of losing a townie.

Duh.

^^^^ Losing argument.

[strife220]

Didn't the other team make a decision, meaning we're deadlined? Isn't there a way of deciding what actions take place at deadline here - either no-lynch cause we didn't reach a majority, or a lynch because Flameaxe has 4 Votes while nobody else has any?

[Mastermind of Sin]

Flameaxe, if we don't lynch you, we have no idea whether or not you are scum, and we only get one more chance to find scum.

[Flameaxe]

I don't really see why a lynch is even necessary... I mean, the other team scored a goal before even lynching any scum. If I am truly scum as you say, keeping me on the bench would allow the team to be better. But if I'm town (like I am), and nothing changes, you don't have that risk of losing a townie.

Duh.

^^^^ Losing argument.

That is called logic.