Newbie 584: Mark it "done"!

[icemanE]

Guys, please unvote. Considering that only me, muffin and twiglees are left, I don't see a quickhammer any time soon, but it muddies the waters.

OK, I figured we were fairly certain we'd won, but I'll pull it until everyone is ready.

unvote: Twigs.

[muffinhead]

Muffin - I'm going to get the ball rolling here with a vote on Twigs.

vote:Twiglees

why have u all of a sudden started a vote on twigs when u urself told everyone not to vote untill we have made a decision. I havnt even explained my twigs vote properly.

Even if everyone agrees to a lynch then i might still not be ready.

[muffinhead]

still waiting for alabakska to answer.

[icemanE]

Muffin - perhaps I read too far into one of your posts, but I got the idea that you KNEW Twigs was mafia. I put the vote on Twigs because I thought we HAD come to a decision, we being you (who proposed thee lynch) Ting and myself. If you still want to wait, I guess we can do that - also tell me if you think I read too far into a post, I don't want to get into specifics.

[MeMe]

Vote Count

icemanE

(1):

Alabaska J

not voting

(4):

icemanE, muffinhead, ting =), Twiglees

Three = lynch

[Alabaska J]

I'm not alright with a Twiglees lynch but I'm not sure I want to say why.

And no I'm not admitting to being scum.

[muffinhead]

I'm not alright with a Twiglees lynch but I'm not sure I want to say why.

And no I'm not admitting to being scum.

I wonder why.

@ twiggles- if i havnt yet asked who do u think is scum out of ting,alabaska and iceman?

[muffinhead]

mod prod twiggles

there couldnt be a time we needed him to post more frequently

[icemanE]

I'm not alright with a Twiglees lynch but I'm not sure I want to say why.

And no I'm not admitting to being scum.

If I've ever seen something more blatant than this, I'd be surprised at myself. If you weren't convinced before, town, do you really need anything else?

[Alabaska J]

Thought it over, could be wrong, might as well say, don't mean to out anyone. I get a small cop read from Twiglees. This is an alternative to his lack of voting. Reread his day two posts. Gave me a gist of cop w/ innocent on SD_Reaper. I could be offbase, but I want more evidence before we lynch Twiglees in favor of icemanE.

Also, @ting =): He is more than just in agreement with you; he is leeching.

[icemanE]

Thought it over, could be wrong, might as well say, don't mean to out anyone. I get a small cop read from Twiglees. This is an alternative to his lack of voting. Reread his day two posts. Gave me a gist of cop w/ innocent on SD_Reaper. I could be offbase, but I want more evidence before we lynch Twiglees in favor of icemanE.

Also, @ting =): He is more than just in agreement with you; he is leeching.

Um... if you REALLY think Twigs is the cop, you just DID out him. This is a massive speculation, and its off base - first of all, why would his being the cop explain his inactivity and the fact that he doesn't vote? Second, if he were the cop with an inno on SD, do you think he'd say something like this:

You have 1 more reply to convince me not to hammer. This is not personal, but I feel than we are getting held up in discussion against you so we either need to lynch you or move on.

That's post 806. That's not something a cop with an inno report would say, especially since an inno report on a claimed doc would be the difference between losing the doc or keeping the doc. If Twigs were cop, he would have claimed yesterday and had SD protect him overnight, since he would essentially have VERIFICATION that SD was the doc. It doesn't add up, Alabaska.

[icemanE]

EBWOP: "loosing" = "lynching", though it makes sense either way.

[icemanE]

DOUBLE EBWOP: "Loosing" = "Losing".

[Alabaska J]

Well, I thought I would just throw out my opinion there. He doesn't have to claim or anything if he is the cop (don't by the way) but I'm just not as comfortable with his lynch for this reason without some more evidence. muffin asked me and I responded. *shrug*

[icemanE]

Muffin - everyone has weighed in, what are your thoughts?

I still say Alabaska is a better bet today, especially in light of the last few posts, but I'm just as willing to go with Twigs if my evaluation of what you've said is correct.

[Alabaska J]

If Twigs were cop, he would have claimed yesterday and had SD protect him overnight, since he would essentially have VERIFICATION that SD was the doc. It doesn't add up, Alabaska.

Dammit. :/

[icemanE]

If Twigs were cop, he would have claimed yesterday and had SD protect him overnight, since he would essentially have VERIFICATION that SD was the doc. It doesn't add up, Alabaska.

Dammit. :/

Alrighty, hopefully everyone is ready to lynch now?[/b]

[ting =)]

Haha. =)

I was reading through the page and was going to point out the cop thing, but it looks like Ice did it already. *cheers

Alabaska lynch muffin?

[Alabaska J]

That's not what I meant by dammit.

[Alabaska J]

Someone give me a heads up when I'm at L-1 so scum doesn't hammer me without me saying what I need to.

[muffinhead]

Haha. =)

I was reading through the page and was going to point out the cop thing, but it looks like Ice did it already. *cheers

Alabaska lynch muffin?

I am not ready and wont be untill I hear from twiggles.

[muffinhead]

mod

is it possible to put twiggles on auto prod where everytime he hasnt posted for 48 hours he becomes automatically proded? I would guess he has been proded at least 5-10 times and i just cant stand continously posting as its getting us no where.

I still think twigs is the lynch today and will only change my mind if twigs himself can give me a good explaination and answer my questions.

If twigs is town then he has let us down. Thats somthing to consider.

[Alabaska J]

Someone give me a heads up when I'm at L-1 so scum doesn't hammer me without me saying what I need to.

This applies to twigs too. Unfortunately, we are linked.

And no, not as scum.

[MeMe]

Twiglees has been prodded

.

[icemanE]

If twigs is town then he has let us down. Thats somthing to consider.

Muffin - please tell me you don't advocate a lynch on Twigs because he's a townie that lets us down. This is lylo - we have to make the right choice here, we can't say things like that. We have to lynch CERTAIN SCUM if we want to win, not poorly playing townies.

This applies to twigs too. Unfortunately, we are linked.

And no, not as scum.

I'm not sure how else you could possibly be linked - there are no masons in this game. We know all the potential power roles.

In fact... I would argue that, if there's a cop in this setup, he should claim, and provide all relevant info. At this stage, it's almost GUARANTEED that Alabaska and Twigs are the scum. There is no real danger for the cop at this point, because he has a decent chance of getting NK'd by mafia. However, if the cop has no useful info whatsoever, stay hidden unless you wind up on L-1.

And muffin, I'm reeeally starting to get iffy on you. Alabaska is the CLEAR choice here, and yet you seem set on Twigs - this is a worrying fact. Please explain.