Primate: 3 (DestroyerOfTheSky, Mr Stoofer, KingPin)
mneme: 2 (Johoohno, mathcam)
Mr Stoofer: 2 (The Fonz, Primate)
TheSweatpantsNinja: 1 (Massive)
Johoohno: 1 (Primate)
Additionally,
Way to dodge the question. We were discussing the likelihood of the accuracy of his claim, and it was notable that part of it didn't make sense, and I had information that potentially cleared that up. I think it would have been tremendously anti-town to not reveal that information, especially while I didn't have to reveal anything else.massive wrote: TSN: That's an impossible question to answer. You didn't reveal any information. You didn't, necessarily, contribute to the town NOT lynching Primate. It's hard to imagine what your goal was, so it's impossible to judge if you failed in that regard.
If Primate and my first choice went through, he's probably lying - Greasy Spot should have lived. If Primate and my secondary choice went through, then mneme could be scum.Primate wrote:Wrong way round, sorry, it was Emp -> Fonz, Stoof - > mneme.
EmpTyger [402] wrote:Everybody list 3 people you’d be willing to lynch. Reasons are welcome, but promptness more so.
<snip>
It's not dodging the question. You asked if I thought revealing the information was a bad idea -- I responded by saying that you didn't ACTUALLY reveal any information, nor did you "potentially clear up" the accuracy of Primate's claim. The additional fact that it makes Primate neither "more likely to be scum" nor "more likely to be town" is also unhelpful. You saying "it would have been tremendously anti-town" to keep silent is, I think, a little overboard.TheSweatpantsNinja wrote:Way to dodge the question. We were discussing the likelihood of the accuracy of his claim, and it was notable that part of it didn't make sense, and I had information that potentially cleared that up. I think it would have been tremendously anti-town to not reveal that information, especially while I didn't have to reveal anything else.
No, and no.EmpTyger wrote:Now, your lists indicate that there are only 2 people you’d be willing to lynch, out of the max 3 I asked for. Temporarily assume that Primate and Stoofer or Primate and TSN are unlynchable for whatever reason. Would you be no-lynching in that situation? If not, name a third player.