Designer Mafia 2007 - Game Over, Final Scene Posted!

[Nocmen]

I sort of remember that too ckd...I'll try to look harder if I get a chance.

I think TSS is trying to look too hard into things.

Unvote (if any), Vote: The silent speaker

[mneme]

armix, I fail to see how this is in any way an exception. Also, if LAL has fallen into disuse, it's only because a lot of people have stopped playing -- it's certainly part of -my- meta.

[Twomz]

Scum as kingmaker? Even temporarily? Probably not. Unless there is a counterclaim (who did claim to have made shanba king?) there's no real reason right now to lynch thyroid/simenon.

@ TSS: I'm at work, but if I have time tonight I'll look over your post better, if not then then tomorrow.

[curiouskarmadog]

i thought someone either claimed they made shanba's role or claimed to have made thryo's role...I cant find either now, but was certian someone did.

[The Fonz]

Scum as kingmaker? Even temporarily? Probably not.

If scum couldn't make their buddies king, it might work.

[Twomz]

Scum as kingmaker? Even temporarily? Probably not.

If scum couldn't make their buddies king, it might work.

Having a scum kingmaker, even with that restriction, defiles the role's appeal and intent. I doubt MoS would include it.

[Shanba]

Unvote vote: TSS

I should have executed you when I had the chance. Stark can wait till tomorrow.

Tss, what's .95^8?

[armlx]

I think TSS is trying to look too hard into things.

Is this what you really mean?

Mneme: You said it yourself, theres very good reason to believe he is town. There is no reason to lynch him.

[mneme]

armlx: there are, in fact, some good reasons to believe he's town. There are -also- reasons to lynch him, but I'm willing to be shouted down on this in the name of being able to play the game.

unvote

TOTALLY not feeling the TSS wagon -- it seems to be entirely based on a few forcing plays today, completely discounting his play at any point prior to today. Isn't this game about lynching scum? I forget. It also appears to be based on one post while ignoring a post a month ago where he explained the "questionable" entries on his "list".

unvote
vote: SSF352

[the silent speaker]

tss: I hope you're not treating JDodge's lynching order as at all significant -- a few people temporarily jumped the bandwagon to give time for thryroid to collect tickets.

Not so much the order as the fact that armlx is not on it, and it is not short one person, and both armlx and the mod agreed that Stark's vote (and not armlx's) hammered.

[the silent speaker]

Shanba, I get about 66%. Why do you ask?

[the silent speaker]

Also,

Mod: votecount please?

[armlx]

tss: I hope you're not treating JDodge's lynching order as at all significant -- a few people temporarily jumped the bandwagon to give time for thryroid to collect tickets.

Not so much the order as the fact that armlx is not on it, and it is not short one person, and both armlx and the mod agreed that Stark's vote (and not armlx's) hammered.

Sounds like you are trying to frame what I did as an elaborate scheme that does absolutely nothing.

[TBuG]

TOTALLY not feeling the TSS wagon -- it seems to be entirely based on a few forcing plays today, completely discounting his play at any point prior to today. Isn't this game about lynching scum? I forget. It also appears to be based on one post while ignoring a post a month ago where he explained the "questionable" entries on his "list".

My vote is based on the readthrough I've been doing in addition to his recent actions. I was actually shocked to see he had never been lynched when reading though the thread.

[TBuG]

armix, I fail to see how this is in any way an exception. Also, if LAL has fallen into disuse, it's only because a lot of people have stopped playing -- it's certainly part of -my- meta.

In my experience, it's just a hint, never something to entirely base a vote on unless it's something that makes them scum for sure. I've lied as a protown role to protect myself from being NKed.

[mneme]

PBug: Oh, it's never "town don't ever lie" -- there are times it's correct to lie as town even in an iron LAL meta. But it's a "people don't survive getting -caught- lying" meta; when I lie as town, I expect to take that secret to the end of the game with me; a lie I tell and have to go back on later is one that in other circumstances, I could have told as scum.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Sixth Vote Count of Day 4:

the silent speaker - (armlx, The Fonz, The Fonz, PBuG, Nocmen, Shanba)

ZONEACE - (Kison, Twomz)
Kison - (Thyroidectomy, the silent speaker)
stark - (Shanba)
armlx - (The Fonz)
curiouskarmadog - (KaleiÐoscøpe)
Simenon - (ZONEACE)
SSF352 - (mneme)

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.

[armlx]

No, its generally lynch all liars that hurt the town with their lie. In no way was thyroid/Simenon really hurting us with the lie.

[the silent speaker]

Speaking of liars who hurt the town:

I was the L-1 vote on Jdodge. I'm just not on the vote count b/c of an MoS error, but if you count there's only 9 names and I voted him right before the stark hammer.

This is a lie, which is what my noting the vote count was intended to prove.

Nocmen, PBuG, give me something to work with.

[armlx]

Lol. You really are trying your very hardest here to get anything through.

[Mastermind of Sin]

Ok, I'm going to step in as a mod here. I don't like intervening on gameplay, but I feel that this is a really stupid argument, and nothing in a game should be based on speculation of whether or not the mod screwed up or what his voting policies are, because those things should be transparent and not affect the game. armlx DID vote JDodge, and I DID just miss the vote. It should have been in the vote count, and it was my fault that it was not.

[Nocmen]

Speaking of liars who hurt the town:

I was the L-1 vote on Jdodge. I'm just not on the vote count b/c of an MoS error, but if you count there's only 9 names and I voted him right before the stark hammer.

This is a lie, which is what my noting the vote count was intended to prove.

Nocmen, PBuG, give me something to work with.

The votes still hot him lynched regardless, and really I dont' give a shit about voting order.

[Nocmen]

EBWOP: I also fail to see how the order of the votes and a vote that may or may not have been there affected the town negatively.

[armlx]

Nocmen: Voting order does happen to matter as those later on are more likely to be bussing last second, but TSS was really reaching there.

[curiouskarmadog]

I am willing to swing my vote back on TSS now..he is really stretching..

jedi, give a shirt to Bel...if you dont I want a hell of a good reason why.

vote TSS