Elemental Mafia- Game Over!

[armlx]

I'm not huge on the Pooky wagon to say the least.

[dahill1]

Vote Count

(8) Korlash: (Mneme, Armlx, Muerrto, Xtoxm, Pooky, Farside, Macavenger, DR)

(1) Pooky: (Kison)
(1) Mneme: (Cavebear)
(1) Elvis Knits: (Andycyca)

(4) Not voting: (DGB, Erg0, Korlash, Elvis Knits)

15 players alive, 8 votes to lynch.

This will be the VC until the lynch scene is posted. Please refrain from voting in twilight.

[Muerrto]

Lol I echoed it and I know I'm right so therefore I suspect Pooky. How exactly does that not work?

Now do YOU know? Of course not you don't have my PM.

[Korlash]

You dont have his... if your town why would it be suspicious of him saying it? Are you lying? if not why do you think he is?

[Muerrto]

Because someone can look at my posts and interactions and decipher most of my role. Saying 'I'm important don't lynch me' after lurking all game and never adding input except to join a couple wagons is a bit different, no?

[Korlash]

... i suppose so... then again i would rather have someone lurk most of the game isntead of lynching people jsut so they dont get recruted...

man i hope they never let that one go... Then maybe you'll get why I felt so bad being lynched for the mere fact I was too busy day one... man... If they had ynched me in every game I had lurked in... whew... glad they didnt...

[Muerrto]

Lol yeah well most games have ONE lynch per day and ONE scum team...

[armlx]

Lol yeah well most games have ONE lynch per day and ONE scum team...

Its more the prior than the later. This game is an extreme example of how rushing is bad for the town, but its really sad because its still optimal play. If it was 4 mafias not cults I could get slowing down but no cross kills screws everything.

[Korlash]

Yeah im a bit sad the scum are morons and didnt kill last night... Oh well still a plus for us but still kinda not all that good either... man... sucks...

[armlx]

Yeah im a bit sad the scum are morons and didnt kill last night... Oh well still a plus for us but still kinda not all that good either... man... sucks...

Not sure I agree, but further discussion about this wouldn't be optimal while the game is ongoing.

[Korlash]

I know... but I want to get as much disscussion as I can in before I am off'd... *glare at you* yeah... *sniff*...

[armlx]

You have to admit you didn't help your scenario much once things started but yeah, we have sucked hard at scum hunting this game.

[Korlash]

A bit... Still upset kabennon wasnt scum myself... Still i'll bank on Mneme... and if Im wrong about him Ill follow up with my one of you two... but i wont push those... ha ha ha ha... ahhh... funny...

[armlx]

In all fairness the majority of lynched townies were pretty scummy.

[Korlash]

I would hope all of our lynches were pretty scumy...

[dahill1]

[3] Once you are dead you may not post. Atall. No 'Bah' posts, or anything similar. No ghosts please.

I wish to remind Korlash of Rule #3. Please refrain from talking. This is the first warning, next time I'll lock the thread.

[armlx]

Sorry, I would have stopped the convo but I assumed people were still alive till their role + lynch scene was posted.

[Battle Mage]

Vote Count

(8) Korlash: (Mneme, Armlx, Muerrto, Xtoxm, Pooky, Farside, Macavenger, DR)
(1) Pooky: (Kison)
(1) Mneme: (Cavebear)
(1) Elvis Knits: (Andycyca)

(4) Not voting: (DGB, Erg0, Korlash, Elvis Knits)

15 players alive, 8 votes to lynch. Thanks Dahill for ensuring that order is upheld in my absense.

It was pretty clear by the time they murdered Korlash, that the town didnt have a clue what a cult member looked like. He was just next on the list of innocent victims of the town's enthusiasm.

Korlash - Townie, shanked, Day 2

With 4 lynches left, the town needed to get a wriggle on and find some scum. Some less optimistic members wondered whether it was already too late...

With 14 of you alive, 8 votes are still required to lynch.

BM

[armlx]

I'm honestly unsure where to go from here.

[Macavenger]

I'm honestly unsure where to go from here.

QFT. This is pretty depressing.

My enthusiasm for killing mneme is waning, since everyone else we've killed for similar stuff has come up town.

I dunno, lurker hunt? Seriously, I'm pretty lost.

Pooky might still be a good lynch. I'm having trouble reconciling his "I am the most powerful town power role, don't question me" bit with Mizzy's "So being town sucks and you want to get recruited into the winning cult right?"

[armlx]

Hmm, thoughts.

- I can see a farside Earth/Wind recruiter. Rather wait here as she's confirmed not ice/fire though.

-Default lynching DGB might be the play sadly to say.

-DR idk about, I'll have to reread when its not 3am.

-I think the joke pooky is trying to make is he's a townie. That seems about right for him, rather not lynch him just yet.

-Mneme I'm indifferent on, he's just been a -1 to lynch so far.

-Cavebear however, is the odd man out after eliminating those above and those i believe are town. Well, him and Kison, but I'll start here.

Vote Cavebear

[PookyTheMagicalBear]

Yea

cuz when Mizzy says things like "I'm recruitable" or "Townies should want to get recruited into the winning cult"

she's obviously playing from the perspective of a townie who wants to get recruited.

Yea.

that makes lots of sense.



We've been joking around for too long, as much fun as lynch the lurker is, it aint going to find us those cult leaders.

Last i checked, people who get cult recruiter pms dont end of deciding to blow off the game.

Usually these people pull out their A Game so they can get a win as a cult recruiter on their resume(honestly what could be more glorious? other than maybe a win as an SK).

Its about damn time we had more to go on than this person is lurking LYNCH THEM.

Man up boys.

[Muerrto]

And you've helped how?

[Dead Rikimaru]

I'm honestly unsure where to go from here.

I dunno, lurker hunt? Seriously, I'm pretty lost.

So how about we discuss some topics a bit before jumping from bandwagon to bandwagon?

Here are some suggestions:

I would favor lynching Pooky before DGB because:
- If you consider fame as a factor he was already famous when DGB started.
- He participated much less. Posted only three times with no content. While posting regularly over the site.
- There is no power role claiming to have protected him from cults.

That makes me think about EK's claim of roleblocker.
In a game of Suicidal Dayvigs, Density Cops and Prison Wardens a simple "roleblocker" sounds out of place, doesn't it?

Do we have more power roles than townies in this game?
It's even possible that we have already found all the Cult Recruiters and they are alive among the claimed power roles.
We should use the info we already have and check back all of them.

[Xtoxm]

I would favor lynching Pooky before DGB because:
- If you consider fame as a factor he was already famous when DGB started.
- He participated much less. Posted only three times with no content. While posting regularly over the site.
- There is no power role claiming to have protected him from cults.

Well, your first point there I think is completely null. I agree with the other 2.

That makes me think about EK's claim of roleblocker.
In a game of Suicidal Dayvigs, Density Cops and Prison Wardens a simple "roleblocker" sounds out of place, doesn't it?

I don't think it looks particularly out of place. As Kison already brought up, the Inventor was called simply "Inventor". And blocking roles I can believe there are multiple of, with 4 cults.

Do we have more power roles than townies in this game?
It's even possible that we have already found all the Cult Recruiters and they are alive among the claimed power roles.
We should use the info we already have and check back all of them.

I doubt we have more power's than townies.

No..Andy's the only claimed power i'm not liking.