Designer Mafia 2007 - Game Over, Final Scene Posted!

[TBuG]

Major FoS: the silent speaker

Just from what I've read of the past two pages.

[Twomz]

Also, I'll be suspicious of the resurected until they stop growing and/or some of them start dropping dead of their own accord. But that's a later-day question.

I'd probably be the same way, so it's cool .

[mneme]

Again, Thyroid's ability supposedly blocked all scum night actions from going through.

What makes you think Thyroid's ability activated?

Ticket buyers on day 3:

Kison
armlx
the silent speaker
mneme
Shanba

# of People alive on day 3:

17.

So unless the buys of the four people who bought tickts on previous days and did -not- buy a ticket on day 3 count, Thyroid's ability didn't trigger on night 3.

[Thyroidectomy]

Thyroid is giving off icky vibes, he claims good posts are bad and votes w/o reasoning. The tickets are weird too.

Hypothetical Vote Thyroid

Hilarious. You should be on stage.

I believe thefonz to be thoroughly town. I would switch to TSS, but I wub my wittle Kison vote so much.

[armlx]

Thyroid is giving off icky vibes, he claims good posts are bad and votes w/o reasoning. The tickets are weird too.

Hypothetical Vote Thyroid

Hilarious. You should be on stage.

I believe thefonz to be thoroughly town. I would switch to TSS, but I wub my wittle Kison vote so much.

Thyroid, he's basing this on the first 10 pages, no need to act so offended. It's not actually scummy, but you will be a better player if you didn't react like that. Its something people can and will attack in later games under false pretenses and you will get lynched for it at least once.

[ZONEACE]

Thyroid is giving off icky vibes, he claims good posts are bad and votes w/o reasoning. The tickets are weird too.

Hypothetical Vote Thyroid

Hilarious. You should be on stage.

I believe thefonz to be thoroughly town. I would switch to TSS, but I wub my wittle Kison vote so much.

Thyroid, he's basing this on the first 10 pages, no need to act so offended. It's not actually scummy, but you will be a better player if you didn't react like that. Its something people can and will attack in later games under false pretenses and you will get lynched for it at least once.

why wait for later games, this one seems like a good place to start.

[Thyroidectomy]

Thyroid is giving off icky vibes, he claims good posts are bad and votes w/o reasoning. The tickets are weird too.

Hypothetical Vote Thyroid

Hilarious. You should be on stage.

I believe thefonz to be thoroughly town. I would switch to TSS, but I wub my wittle Kison vote so much.

Thyroid, he's basing this on the first 10 pages, no need to act so offended. It's not actually scummy, but you will be a better player if you didn't react like that. Its something people can and will attack in later games under false pretenses and you will get lynched for it at least once.

why wait for later games, this one seems like a good place to start.

Have you ever considered joining PBug's troupe?

armlx: Thanks, but derision is more fun.

[armlx]

Zoneface: Did you read the part where I said it would be bad logic or are you just being a joker.

Thyroid: I prefer losing less often to derision in response to attacks. If someone says something stupendously dumb about other people that kind of response can be warranted, when you act like that in regards to any comment about you it tends to be taken poorly.

[ZONEACE]

Zoneface: Did you read the part where I said it would be bad logic or are you just being a joker.

A little bit from column A a little bit from column B.

[armlx]

Sounds about right.

[the silent speaker]

I repeat again, answer the questions from last page and stop dodging the issues.

WHAT ISSUES? I listed people who were obvtown, explaining that all of them fell into at least one of three categories (some fell into more):
1. Town by investigation.
2. Pro-town use of role.
3. Sound scumhunting with no red flags.

You and Fonz wanted me to specify who fell into which category. But you and FOnz are probably scum, so I see no reason I should help you.

On my list there were perhaps three people a reasonable person could argue are not obvtown -- note that we are not reaching whether a reasonable person could argue that they are not town, only whether they are not

obv

town. There is no reason a pro-town Fonz should have even the slightest interest in voting anyone on that list, so a pro-town Fonz gives up NOTHING. As for the notion that "my vote is essentially beholden to you" -- baloney. First of all, you are not guaranteed to have those votes, and I explicitly specified that this only applies to the extras. Second, even if you don't think too highly of me, you have your pick of eight players to follow, and if you don't like where one of them is voting, you can simply

follow one of the others

. If you don't like where six of them are voting but are also pro-town yourself, something is wrong with your brain. If our whole obvtown contingent is voting

you

when you're providing them with an extra two votes, you can bet there will be a damned good reason why.
And I made a point of NOT tying your extras to me personally, so that's a lie, too.

Sir Tornado, I know I'm pro-town and I put myself in the "sound scumhunting" category by default (since obviously I wouldn't say anything I thought was unconvincing). I think my attack on JDodge, FOS of Schism, and defenses of Nocmen and Twomz should encourage the rest of you to put me there too. Fonz is not on the list because he has not *demonstrated* pro-town use of his role and Oman rang quite a few warning bells. The recent Shanba-Fonz-armlx gangup on me has bad juju too.

[armlx]

Which one of those are you and Mneme in? 3? I don't really see that.

[Kison]

Again, Thyroid's ability supposedly blocked all scum night actions from going through.

What makes you think Thyroid's ability activated?

Again, I haven't really read too deeply into whether or not it should have, but he claims it did if I recall correctly.

[armlx]

So he claims it did but the count doesn't match.....

[Kison]

-I believe my ability went off. I assume the mod's lack of comment on it was a sign that it was a success
-I have not been informed of any red shirt.
-Still reading up

[armlx]

Meh, thats just him being stubborn/lazy/dumb.

[Thyroidectomy]

The tickets accumulate

[armlx]

???

I thought you said half the players in one day at one point....

[Kison]

Thyroid, are you certain it went off? Don't you like... you know... receive confirmation?

[armlx]

Thyroid, are you certain it went off? Don't you like... you know... receive confirmation?

He said he didn't. He should check.

[the silent speaker]

EBWOP: Fonz, while he has demonstrated the use of his role, has not used it in a way that demonstrates that he is pro-town.

[curiouskarmadog]

unvote

Jedi, why did you give Belgarion the red shirt last night? I asked you for it...seems to me that Bel would have been a good choice to test out a shirt.

[Belgarion]

I agree..for now.

unvote

Also, TSS (sorry if this is a repeat question) What are your thoughts on Jedi and his shirts and Shanba?

[armlx]

Mod, Vote Count Please?

[TBuG]

Thyroid, I posted my notes from the first 10 pages, and you were being scummy as hell. I'm guessing something significant happens that I haven't read yet.

ZONEACE, STFU.

More notes posted tomorrow.