Designer Mafia 2007 - Game Over, Final Scene Posted!

[the silent speaker]

CKD, I did answer. He's

had

a chance to claim. And he's not at L-1 or anything ridiculous, he has my vote and that's it. And if he does claim now, I will be delighted, because it means he will be POSTING.

Furthermore, especially if he turns up scum, this exchange has given me prime information on Armlx, who was already #2 on my list.

Fonz is thinking along lines much like my own. This makes me happier about Fonz.

[curiouskarmadog]

note to fonz, I am a multi voter....(both my "alts" have to be voting the same person within a 24 hour period)...this is new info I didnt supply before.

but essentially I am a multi voter.

TSS, if he is going to be replaced..you would rather lynch him before that? how is that pro-town?

[Twomz]

That's a crappy restriction makes it much harder to hide the base player. Oh well, since you're outted it doesn't matter anymore. And as I've said, I have seen the role as a SK before, no reason it can't be implemented as a nonSK role, especially in a designer game.

[armlx]

AS for Armlx: SSF wasn't on the Schiz wagon, attacked Nocmen who is fairly likely town, attacks Nocmen and Thyroid with fairly bad arguments (the first worst than the second, though note how he attacks Thyroid for promoting his tickets after having bought one himself) and subtly defends JDodge.

Definitely what I expected as reasoning. In all fairness, when I reread I was about to post something about how he was obv scum, then did a double take and realized he was me.

[the silent speaker]

TSS,

if he is going to be replaced

, you would rather lynch him before that?

How is that pro-town?

(response to bolded part) Is he about to be replaced? You know something I don't?
(response to underlined part) Um, because I think he's scum? As in, see my first post of the day, where he tops my list?

[armlx]

He will be replaced if he is inactive. Thats a fair assumption, right?

[Mastermind of Sin]

Fourth Vote Count of Day 4:

ZONACE - (Thyroidectomy, Kison, Twomz)

stark - (Shanba)
Flameaxe - (the silent speaker)
armlx - (The Fonz)
curiouskarmadog - (KaleiÐoscøpe)

With 16 alive, it takes 9 to lynch.

The following players will be prodded:

UltimaAvalon
ZONEACE
stark
Kison
Flameaxe
Thyroidectomy

The following players are close to being prodded:

Belgarion
Shanba

[Kison]

Sorry, folks. Was gone for a few days. Back now.

TSS, if someone's idling, ask for them to be replaced! Replacement > Modkilling(usually).

Zoneface, still like my vote on him. He's been "confused" all day.

[the silent speaker]

Good luck finding five replacements willing to join seventy pages of game. Replacement>modkill usually, I agree, but that "usually" makes all the difference. This is the exception.

And for the forty-seventh time, I think he's scum for reasons besides lurking, so I don't understand why people have a problem with me wanting him dead.

[curiouskarmadog]

vote TSS

[Belgarion]

why do we need 5 replacements?

why dont you want to at least see a claim first?

vote tss

[Shanba]

That's a crappy restriction :( makes it much harder to hide the base player. Oh well, since you're outted it doesn't matter anymore. And as I've said, I have seen the role as a SK before, no reason it can't be implemented as a nonSK role, especially in a designer game.

Plus we have a dead SK already.

[armlx]

why do we need 5 replacements?

why dont you want to at least see a claim first?

vote tss

I'll support this option.

Vote TSS

any reason you want people to not be able to defend themselves when being pushed to a lynch?

[Nocmen]

I keep having to remember that Belgarion does the same as CKD because they are the same person.

Goddamnit Nocmen, you are stupid.

[curiouskarmadog]

^^^interesting comment, why did you say that?

[armlx]

More important, why waste one of our stored Nocmen s to do so?

[the silent speaker]

CKD, we need five replacements because the mod is sending out five prods (six, but Kison already responded to his).

And for the kajillionth time, I would be fine with seeing a claim first IF HE WERE HERE. Since he is not, where do you expect this claim to come from? Likewise, I would dearly love for him to defend himself from the runup to a lynch that I am apparently magically contriving to do all by my lonesome. So why don't you, armlx, PM your scum buddy and TELL HIM TO GET BACK HERE AND DEFEND HIMSELF?

And CKD, does it not bother you at least a little that you are taking armlx's side? If Flameaxe has a scumbuddy, armlx is about the best candidate for it.

[armlx]

I only see 1, maybe 2 really being needed. UA, BBM, Zoneace, all active on the site still.

If he picks up the claim and still doesn't respond, then we move in, but till then there's no reason to be going "ZOMG LYNCH BBM NOW NO CLAIM DIE SCUM".

[stark]

Hey guys,

I'm really sorry I've been slacking in this game, for sure. Things have been really hectic for me.

I'm going to try to see if I can do a re-read tomorrow, unless someone wants to sum up the course of events in short.

Straight up.

[armlx]

Yay, only .5 replacements needed.

[Twomz]

That's a crappy restriction makes it much harder to hide the base player. Oh well, since you're outted it doesn't matter anymore. And as I've said, I have seen the role as a SK before, no reason it can't be implemented as a nonSK role, especially in a designer game.

Plus we have a dead SK already.

I was actually looking at Belg as the 2nd half of the SK like in the game where I first saw the role... but it didn't line up and it just so happens that CKD is the other side of Belg, so there's no connection between him and the dead SK. If there were more deaths I'd be suspicious of CKD... but it's unlikely we have another killing role, or even more than one mafia, unless there are two that kill on even/odd nights.

[ZONEACE]

So wait, being confused about a game that is more than slightly confusing makes me scum???

Ok, i admit, i was completely wrong about Jdodge. I wasn't getting the same scum vibe that everyone else was getting. My Scumdar clearly needs repairing. But I still fail to see how makes me scum. At the sake of being WIFOMy, at this point in the game, with the amount of scum that have been lynched and as of yet no indication of multiple scum groups, putting myself at risk by taking a unpopular stance with Jdodge would be idiotic were i scum. I know its not much a defense but that's the truth. I messed up my read of Jdodge, its not the first time i've mistakenly defended scum in a mafia game and it won't be the last.

[Kison]

What exactly is confusing you?

[Mastermind of Sin]

I already have a least one of a possible 3 replacements lined up. I'd appreciate it if people would stop ridiculing my ability to find replacements. I have a rather good track record when it comes to getting them in a timely fashion.

[armlx]

The issue isn't with you finding them, its with finding people in general to replace into a 70 page game.