[OLD] Open Setup Discussion and Nominations

[Adel]

Mass Claim Mafia

2 Mafia Roleblockers (Can RB and Kill in the same night)
2 Mafia Goons
6 Trackers (Gets result of "Player X didn't target anyone" if roleblocked)
2 Watchers (Gets result of "Player X was not targeted by anyone" if roleblocked)

Night Start

what about throwing in some jailkeepers?

sure, why don't you remix the setup to include some? I like a little back and forth in designing setups.

[shaft.ed]

Mass Claim Mafia

2 Mafia Roleblockers (Can RB and Kill in the same night)
2 Mafia Goons
6 Trackers (Gets result of "Player X didn't target anyone" if roleblocked)
2 Watchers (Gets result of "Player X was not targeted by anyone" if roleblocked)

Night Start

what about throwing in some jailkeepers?

sure, why don't you remix the setup to include some? I like a little back and forth in designing setups.

I'm afraid of rejection.



1 Mafia Goon
2 Mafia Roleblockers
2 Jailkeepers
3 Trackers
2 Watchers
1 Lazy Tracker (always gets no result)
1 Blind Watcher (always gets no result)

Roleblock>Jailkeep>investigation>Kill

Think this has too much going on

[Adel]

LDS Mafia

aka lynch the polygamists mafia

3 scum lovers
8 townie lovers

All players are lovers.
One set of lovers is a set of three, and is scum.
No other roles are used.
The scum do not have a nk.

(should it just be six townie lovers?)

[Adel]

1 Mafia Goon
2 Mafia Roleblockers
2 Jailkeepers
3 Trackers
2 Watchers
1 Lazy Tracker (always gets no result)
1 Blind Watcher (always gets no result)

Roleblock>Jailkeep>investigation>Kill

Think this has too much going on

I can't compute balance: too much is going on.

I guess we will just have to run it to see what happens!

[Guardian]

lol Adel.

Massclaim... scum lose...

4 scum lovers would at least be a mafia game.

[Adel]

lol at Adel as well.

I miss Kelly Chen and her standard "broken by mass claim" posts. At least Guardian is keeping her spirit alive!

LDS Mafia

aka lynch the polygamists mafia

4 scum lovers
8 townie lovers

All players are lovers.
One set of lovers is a set of

three

four

, and is scum.
No other roles are used.
The scum do not have a nk.

This would be a short game, and I think that would be its appeal.

[Guardian]

LDS Mafia

aka lynch the polygamists mafia

4 scum lovers
8 townie lovers

All players are lovers.

One set of lovers is a set of three, and is scum.

One set of lovers is a set of four. They are scum.

No other roles are used.

The scum do not have a nk.

Nightless.

This would be a short game, and I think that would be its appeal.

I approve of this setup.

[Trojan Horse]

That's basically the same as:

2 scum lovers
4 townies
Nightless

Except that with your setup, you're basically playing double-headed (two players controlling each role). Rather just play it with 6.

[ShadowLurker]

That's basically the same as:

2 scum lovers
4 townies
Nightless

Except that with your setup, you're basically playing double-headed (two players controlling each role). Rather just play it with 6.

Wrong, Adel's setup is more balanced.

Assuming the scum lovers never vote each other, in your setup, all of the town need to agree on the same person to get them lynched. In Adel's setup, all of the town minus one need to agree if the scum lovers never vote each other but with 4 people, they have to vote each other sometimes or it'll be much easier to catch.

[Adel]

SL nailed it. Plus 2 lovers does not equal polygamy.

[Trojan Horse]

And the scum don't have to "vote each other sometimes" in the 6 player version? Sounds the same to me.

[ShadowLurker]

And the scum don't have to "vote each other sometimes" in the 6 player version? Sounds the same to me.

No as a person feeling someone else is town and not voting them in a 6 player game is quite common while a group of 4 never voting each other in a 12 player game is quite rare.

[Adel]

Also in a four player scum tean chances are they will have one idiot on their team that they will have to somehow cover for. They won't be able to bus him. In the two scum version one idot wrecks the game, and no idiots makes it really hard for the town. The four-player team should yeild a less swingy game.

[shaft.ed]

Nominate LSD Mafia

Mass Claim Mafia

1 Scum Tracker
1 Scum Watcher
1 Scum Jailkeeper
2 Jailkeepers
2 Watchers
1 Tracker
4 Townies

Scum can kill and perform night action

[Adel]

the idea for a game I was originally going with for Mass Claim was for thhere to be an early Mass Claim followed by the mafia role-blockers trying to choose their targets to make a townie look like a liar.

Also, LSD Mafia? Am I tripping?

[shaft.ed]

the idea for a game I was originally going with for Mass Claim was for thhere to be an early Mass Claim followed by the mafia role-blockers trying to choose their targets to make a townie look like a liar.

Also, LSD Mafia? Am I tripping?

Yeah I think I turned it into a bastardized smalltown. Not as much fun.

The LSD was a purposeful type I think.

[Adel]

LSD Mafia

1 Mafia Busdriver
1 Mafia Roleblocker
1 Mafia Goon
1 Cop
1 Doctor
1 Roleblocker
6 Busdrivers

[Adel]

LSD Mafia

1 Mafia Busdriver
1 Mafia Roleblocker
1 Mafia Goon
3 Trackers
1 Doctor
1 Roleblocker
4 Busdrivers

[Adel]

LSD Mafia

2 Mafia Busdrivers
1 Mafia Roleblocker
3 Trackers
2 Roleblockers
5 Busdrivers

[shaft.ed]

Massclaim Mafia

2 Scum Jailkeepers
1 Scum Watcher
4 Watchers
2 Jailkeepers
3 Townies

Scum cannot kill and use night action

[Adel]

Why do you like jailkeepers?

What happens when a Jailkeeper targets a jailkeeper?

[Xylthixlm]

What happens when a Jailkeeper targets a jailkeeper?

The same thing that happens when a roleblocker targets a roleblocker.

[Adel]

Are they both protected from night kills? (which is what I was getting at)

[Claus]

LSD Mafia needs more vigs

[hasdgfas]

Are they both protected from night kills? (which is what I was getting at)

I don't think so, due to the fact that both include a roleblock.