Newbie 584: Mark it "done"!

[Metalic]

I agree you guys have been playing for a while but even if so Fast lynching ain't the best thing too do bcz with fast lynching you have more chances of killing of a Twonie rather then when you take your time view the other players posts and determine is there acting scummy or not.

So basically fast lynching is never a good thing too do and can cause the Mafia too win.

[Rishi]

Secondly, you are getting more suspicious that you would forget that i am doctor, it was not some small post, we had like a whole page. So your unvote and vote swap is just as suspicious as when iceman mistaked your name for i think muffinhead.

Yeah, I agree. How do you miss the claim? I'd like to hear answers from both Xdaamno and Metalic on this.

[SD_Reaper]

Once again metalic, if we lynch now it wont be a "fast lynch".... read my last comment more thoroughly.

[Metalic]

Rishi might me because I just skimmed trough the posts....


I'll go look back and try too find it.

[Xdaamno]

Secondly, you are getting more suspicious that you would forget that i am doctor, it was not some small post, we had like a whole page. So your unvote and vote swap is just as suspicious as when iceman mistaked your name for i think muffinhead.

Yeah, I agree. How do you miss the claim? I'd like to hear answers from both Xdaamno and Metalic on this.

I had a fuzzy memory. I remembered the doc claim talk, just forgot SD was the one it claimed. Anyway, what are you suggesting? I'm trying to pretend there was no claim, therefore confuzzling the town and winning the game as scum?

Farside and SD_Reaper are on my scumdar for the same reason; a main subconscious or conscious tactic of scum is to skim around arguments, try not to offend people and avoid the limelight, of course.

I'm looking at:

Therefore, you are no longer a suspect in my book. haha

Does no one have any other suspicions? I'm just surprised the votes are one sided.

I'm iffy on everyone else at this point.

If its not him and we let him live we wont really have gotten anywhere (as he is still top of suspect list), and we will have just wasted a day.

This first day will never end....

Vote: SD_Reaper

Can you explain why this is bad. I'm sorry the way I see this is scum may be pushing this wagon there are a few people who haven't voted or said much of anything. You vote makes no sense in regards to what you found and is based on more from my end concern about the vote then anything else. I think i was right to me looking at you. Mine was based on a hunch but this is BS if this is your reason for voting.

Vote: Xdaamno

Firstly, the quotes that are not individually explained are attributed to what I said in the top paragraph.

Secondly, your immediate vote without hearing if I had any good explanation that I didn't post at the time might suggest to me you're trying to distance yourself from the very reasons I gave.

[Rishi]

Secondly, you are getting more suspicious that you would forget that i am doctor, it was not some small post, we had like a whole page. So your unvote and vote swap is just as suspicious as when iceman mistaked your name for i think muffinhead.

Yeah, I agree. How do you miss the claim? I'd like to hear answers from both Xdaamno and Metalic on this.

I had a fuzzy memory. I remembered the doc claim talk, just forgot SD was the one it claimed. Anyway, what are you suggesting? I'm trying to pretend there was no claim, therefore confuzzling the town and winning the game as scum?

Good point. I don't know how many games you're in, but I've done this before too. But my point is that, if you are forgetting about the claim and have a "fuzzy memory" with respect to this game, then why should we put any faith in your scumdar?

[SD_Reaper]

I had a fuzzy memory. I remembered the doc claim talk, just forgot SD was the one it claimed. Anyway, what are you suggesting? I'm trying to pretend there was no claim, therefore confuzzling the town and winning the game as scum?

No, i am saying that it does not sound like someone who is pro town to remember important and crucial information. Or you could be scum and just knew i was doc all along and came up with some lame excuse to vote for me. Im not sure... just respond to this post so i can get more reads from you plz

[muffinhead]

Secondly, you are getting more suspicious that you would forget that i am doctor, it was not some small post, we had like a whole page. So your unvote and vote swap is just as suspicious as when iceman mistaked your name for i think muffinhead.

Yeah, I agree. How do you miss the claim? I'd like to hear answers from both Xdaamno and Metalic on this.

I had a fuzzy memory. I remembered the doc claim talk, just forgot SD was the one it claimed. Anyway, what are you suggesting? I'm trying to pretend there was no claim, therefore confuzzling the town and winning the game as scum?

Good point. I don't know how many games you're in, but I've done this before too. But my point is that, if you are forgetting about the claim and have a "fuzzy memory" with respect to this game, then why should we put any faith in your scumdar?

Well considering sd was on L-1 i would imagine it to be difficult to forget, however i cant imagine rishi saying such a thing if it hadnt happened to her so i would have to go with x here.

Or you could be scum and just knew i was doc all along and came up with some lame excuse to vote for me.

Even if x was scum i couldnt imagine him doing such a thing so i highly doubt it.

i must say this quote below is a good point

you are getting more suspicious that you would forget that i am doctor, it was not some small post, we had like a whole page. So your unvote and vote swap is just as suspicious as when iceman mistaked your name for i think muffinhead.

Finally i cannot believe that ice has gone 24 hours without a post lol its time for celebration.

[MeMe]

Vote Count

icemanE

(2):

SD_Reaper, Rishi

Rishi

(1):

icemanE

farside22

(1):

Xdaamno

Xdaamno

(1):

farside22

not voting

(4):

Metalic, muffinhead, ting =), Twiglees

Still five to lynch.

[Xdaamno]

Secondly, you are getting more suspicious that you would forget that i am doctor, it was not some small post, we had like a whole page. So your unvote and vote swap is just as suspicious as when iceman mistaked your name for i think muffinhead.

Yeah, I agree. How do you miss the claim? I'd like to hear answers from both Xdaamno and Metalic on this.

I had a fuzzy memory. I remembered the doc claim talk, just forgot SD was the one it claimed. Anyway, what are you suggesting? I'm trying to pretend there was no claim, therefore confuzzling the town and winning the game as scum?

Good point. I don't know how many games you're in, but I've done this before too. But my point is that, if you are forgetting about the claim and have a "fuzzy memory" with respect to this game, then why should we put any faith in your scumdar?

My scumdar is 'real-time', if you like. I write things when they become apparant to me, usually; your point would only be valid if I voted people based on what I remember, rather than what I'm quoting. And, if you say you've done that too, it could apply to you also.

[Xdaamno]

I had a fuzzy memory. I remembered the doc claim talk, just forgot SD was the one it claimed. Anyway, what are you suggesting? I'm trying to pretend there was no claim, therefore confuzzling the town and winning the game as scum?

No, i am saying that it does not sound like someone who is pro town to remember important and crucial information. Or you could be scum and just knew i was doc all along and came up with some lame excuse to vote for me. Im not sure... just respond to this post so i can get more reads from you plz

That really is craplogic. First off, how does human nature 'not sound pro-town'? And secondly, do you really think I'm dumb enough to try and get someone lynched, as scum, not only picking the target who is most confirmed but expecting the other players including the claimed player himself to not remember anything about the claim?

[farside22]

Firstly, the quotes that are not individually explained are attributed to what I said in the top paragraph.

Secondly, your immediate vote without hearing if I had any good explanation that I didn't post at the time might suggest to me you're trying to distance yourself from the very reasons I gave.

This is the second time you bring my name up with crap reasoning. The first time I asked you you said nothing in response to my question. Now you have these quotes and then vote and you want me to ask a second time for a reason? I thought your quotes were your reason. Still liking my vote where it stands.

[icemanE]

I agree you guys have been playing for a while but even if so Fast lynching ain't the best thing too do bcz with fast lynching you have more chances of killing of a Twonie rather then when you take your time view the other players posts and determine is there acting scummy or not.

So basically fast lynching is never a good thing too do and can cause the Mafia too win.

Haha, if anything I'd think this was a slow lynch, I've only been here for 3/4 of the game and it's been a damn long time. Do you have any suspicions?

[Xdaamno]

Firstly, the quotes that are not individually explained are attributed to what I said in the top paragraph.

Secondly, your immediate vote without hearing if I had any good explanation that I didn't post at the time might suggest to me you're trying to distance yourself from the very reasons I gave.

This is the second time you bring my name up with crap reasoning. The first time I asked you you said nothing in response to my question. Now you have these quotes and then vote and you want me to ask a second time for a reason? I thought your quotes were your reason. Still liking my vote where it stands.

No; I thought it was fairly obvious from your post that you didn't think the quotes were good reasoning; now you are think are satisfactory?

[muffinhead]

ok i have just reviewed this argument

Farside and SD_Reaper are on my scumdar for the same reason; a main subconscious or conscious tactic of scum is to skim around arguments, try not to offend people and avoid the limelight, of course.

X that is a really poor argument consdering that there r others here that have skimmed around and avoided trouble just as much if not more then farside and sd.
eg twiggles,ting,metalic and even me.

I'm saying that you should try and keep your eyes open to all possibilities. If iceman is lynched and is mafia, anyone could be his partner

I must have missed it when I skimmed earlier

The way i see it u are just desperate to find a reason to get rid of sd and now farside because u just remebered sd was doc. This seems to be ur only contribution recently which is totally useless anyways. U have continually voted as if u were hoping for a bandonwagon then unvoted only when people have asked u to. For this reason u seem the most desperate to lynch someone and u dont seem to care who.

U said urself u usually have found scum by now but just cant for some reason. Well i think its clear that its because u r scum.

vote xdaamno

[farside22]

Firstly, the quotes that are not individually explained are attributed to what I said in the top paragraph.

Secondly, your immediate vote without hearing if I had any good explanation that I didn't post at the time might suggest to me you're trying to distance yourself from the very reasons I gave.

This is the second time you bring my name up with crap reasoning. The first time I asked you you said nothing in response to my question. Now you have these quotes and then vote and you want me to ask a second time for a reason? I thought your quotes were your reason. Still liking my vote where it stands.

No; I thought it was fairly obvious from your post that you didn't think the quotes were good reasoning; now you are think are satisfactory?

Where did I say your quotes were good reason? I say they are crap reasoning and find you trying to strength a reason to vote anyone at this point.

[icemanE]

@ Rishi

Do you have anything to say about my post 394? You didn't acknowledge it, and it seems like something you might want to do.

[Rishi]

@ Rishi

Do you have anything to say about my post 394? You didn't acknowledge it, and it seems like something you might want to do.

Nah. I'm good.

[icemanE]

@ Rishi

Do you have anything to say about my post 394? You didn't acknowledge it, and it seems like something you might want to do.

Nah. I'm good.

OH SNAP!!! Too cool, man.

[icemanE]

That was so cool I decided to make it my signature! Does that mean you agree with what I'm saying, or are you hoping everybody will just forget about it? That seems to be what's happened so far, with X as the new whipping boy, a cause you were more than willing to further while simultaneously staying on X's good side. You're scum! I know it!

[icemanE]

I apologize for having three separate posts, but I have to say, I think this X wagon is BS. Having made a mistake earlier in the game that is very similar to the one he made in accidentally voting for SD, I can say that it has been blown way out of proportion. What could he possibly hope to gain? The same thing I could have gained by accidentally typing the wrong person's name, which is to say, nothing. Whether or not his reasoning was poor (which it was), I don't think there's much suspicious about his slip-up.

SD said:

Secondly, you are getting more suspicious that you would forget that i am doctor, it was not some small post, we had like a whole page. So your unvote and vote swap is just as suspicious as when iceman mistaked your name for i think muffinhead.

Why is it suspicious? It just doesn't click for me.

QFMFT:

X said:

That really is craplogic. First off, how does human nature 'not sound pro-town'? And secondly, do you really think I'm dumb enough to try and get someone lynched, as scum, not only picking the target who is most confirmed but expecting the other players including the claimed player himself to not remember anything about the claim?

That said, I don't agree with X's logic or reasons for his vote, its an overdrawn conclusion considering the evidence. For me, even suspecting SD at this point in the game is a little off-kilter.

[Rishi]

That was so cool I decided to make it my signature!

It would make a better signature if you also had your question quoted right above it. Give it some context.

In any case, I'm just trying to get away from the argument we've been having. I think we've terribly misunderstood each other and I think both of us are pointing fingers at the other not based on any rational explanation, but simply on emotion. If we continue down this path, there's a good chance that you would get lynched today and I would get lynched tomorrow if you turned up town. Then, it'd be two townies down and little information since we've dominated the thread a little.

Unvote

[icemanE]

That was so cool I decided to make it my signature!

It would make a better signature if you also had your question quoted right above it. Give it some context.

In any case, I'm just trying to get away from the argument we've been having. I think we've terribly misunderstood each other and I think both of us are pointing fingers at the other not based on any rational explanation, but simply on emotion. If we continue down this path, there's a good chance that you would get lynched today and I would get lynched tomorrow if you turned up town. Then, it'd be two townies down and little information since we've dominated the thread a little.

Unvote

Fair enough, truce.

unvote

[farside22]

That was so cool I decided to make it my signature!

It would make a better signature if you also had your question quoted right above it. Give it some context.

In any case, I'm just trying to get away from the argument we've been having. I think we've terribly misunderstood each other and I think both of us are pointing fingers at the other not based on any rational explanation, but simply on emotion. If we continue down this path, there's a good chance that you would get lynched today and I would get lynched tomorrow if you turned up town. Then, it'd be two townies down and little information since we've dominated the thread a little.

Unvote

What do you think about X at this point Rishi. I haven't seen anything that made sense in regards to scum hunting. His vote and comments are blah. I would suggest a read on him.

[Metalic]

I agree you guys have been playing for a while but even if so Fast lynching ain't the best thing too do bcz with fast lynching you have more chances of killing of a Twonie rather then when you take your time view the other players posts and determine is there acting scummy or not.

So basically fast lynching is never a good thing too do and can cause the Mafia too win.

Haha, if anything I'd think this was a slow lynch, I've only been here for 3/4 of the game and it's been a damn long time. Do you have any suspicions?

I'm not too sure rit now tbh.

Possibly X for his crap reasonings?