HAGGLE IV - Mafia Style - Guardian Wins

[ooba]

ooba, what of mine can I trade for lyncher? Or, what will you trade me for jester?

What'd you have guardian?

[Guardian]

Guardian
Rules 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,18,19,20
Cards Godfather(5), Goon(14), Cult Leader(3), Cult Recruit(3), Kingmaker(1), Hero(1), Doc(1), Jester(2), Lyncher(1)

Want: Rules 8 and 17, anything that isn't on my Do NOT Want list.
Give: Nothing is off the table.

Do NOT Want: Lurkers, town roles

[ooba]

Guardian
Rules 1,2,3,4,5,6,7,9,10,11,12,13,14,15,16,18,19,20
Cards Godfather(5), Goon(14), Cult Leader(3), Cult Recruit(3), Kingmaker(1), Hero(1), Doc(1), Jester(2), Lyncher(1)

Want: Rules 8 and 17, anything that isn't on my Do NOT Want list.
Give: Nothing is off the table.

Do NOT Want: Lurkers, town roles

I know you wont trade any of KM,Hero,CR,CL for the lyncher. I do not want a GF or goon. That leaves a doc.

Offer Lyncher+Goon for Guardian's Doc

[Guardian]

I'd trade cultists for the lyncher.

I'm unlikely to trade the doc, kingmaker, or hero, unless a massive trade is arranged.

[ooba]

I'd trade cultists for the lyncher.

I'm unlikely to trade the doc, kingmaker, or hero, unless a massive trade is arranged.

I worked out the points and thought what i offered was a equal trade? I really can't use the cult cards without some major reshuffling of my hand ,which i do not want to attempt so late in the game.

[Guardian]

How about

offer guardian's jester for ooba's doc and goon

You have a doc surplus. By my count, that trade nets you more points, but nets me a doc I can trade.

Your proposed trade ended with me having less points that I started with.

[ooba]

How about

offer guardian's jester for ooba's doc and goon

You have a doc surplus. By my count, that trade nets you more points, but nets me a doc I can trade.

Your proposed trade ended with me having less points that I started with.

I actually calculated it as Lyncher + points increase it brings out which you otherwise might have traded away + goon > doc.

I'm working on the doc angle here - i really do not have much else going for me at the moment.

[Greasy Spot]

Current Count

Replacements vs. Dispersement Issue
Replacements (1) (Guardian)
Dispersements (2) (Dahill1, ooba)

Deadline Change
Shorten to 25th (1) (ooba)
Extend to 30th (1) (Guardian)

[hasdgfas]

dipserse and extend is my vote

[Andycyca]

dipserse and extend is my vote

[hasdgfas]

of course, disperse being spelled right is probably also good

[dahill1]

disperse and shorten deadline

[Andycyca]

of course, disperse being spelled right is probably also good

Ehm... yeah that

[Greasy Spot]

C'mon people times a wasting and I know someone who's running away with this game. Make your trades or your gonna lose.

[Max]

Guardian by any chance?

[Andycyca]

C'mon people times a wasting and I know someone who's running away with this game. Make your trades or your gonna lose.

Exactly why I voted to disperse. Many trades are stalled.

[Greasy Spot]

Guardian by any chance?

Exactly why I voted to disperse. Many trades are stalled.

Guardian is not the only one in this game. Besides the rules he doesn't have might make him want to change his position. If I disperse (and I haven't decided) a players possessions then rules will most likely be given to all so that benefits the ones that only need those rules more than it benefits the guys needing a lot of rules.

If activity doesn't pick up I will most likely end the game early on the 25th.

[You Give Love A Bad Name]

want cops and jesters plz.
this is peg btw

[dahill1]

i'm reluctant to give up jesters but what will you offer

[pickemgenius]

i'm reluctant to give up jesters but what will you offer

anything

fair.

[dahill1]

have any GFs?

[pickemgenius]

nope.


also looking for SK's.

[Guardian]

trade offer guardian's jester(1) for Pickem's goons(2)

[pickemgenius]

suck one guardian

[dahill1]

trade offer guardian's jester(1) for Pickem's goons(2)

what will you offer for my goons