Mini 530: Guitar Hero Mafia: It's Finally Over

[Haschel Cedricson]

Found him.

Is it Thanatos? Because that would be awkward for me, especially after I publically said I believe him to be town.

[Atticus]

Been busy, failed to send prods.

[Thanatos]

I'm against an SSK lynch for one simple reason: Out of Gorrad, TSPN, ChaosOmega, Thanatos, hasghfas, and myself, at least one person is Mafia and

another person is an SK.

I know it's not me, and hasghfas looks pretty clear, so that leaves four people who are statistically better lynches today regardless of play. Unless Alabaska or SSK do something amazingly dumb, I don't think either of them is a good lynch today.

Found him.

How the heck did you figure out who the SK is?

Keep in mind that dicking around with the town is a capital offense.

[hasdgfas]

My first question: How do we know there's an SK?

[Haschel Cedricson]

I believe I said this earlier, but I believe a pro-town vig would have killed SeraphicMirth on Night 1. Obviously we have hindsight now, but at the time SM was by far the sketchiest player, and it would have been clear that Day 2 would likely result in an SM lynch. A town vig would have performed the kill on what was a likely scum target, giving the town control of another death.

SKs have no such duty to the town.

[ChaosOmega]

I can see a vig going for somebody like SilverPhoenix. Didn't post much at all day 1, especially near the end. There was pretty much no read on him. Worst case scenario, the vig kills a pro-town player not helping the town; best case scenario, he hits lurking mafia that nobody has a read on.

Granted, it could have been a SK hoping to nail a power role trying not to draw a lot of attention, but then we devolve into huge amounts of WIFOM. Just posting the other side of it.

[Alabaska J]

Yeah HC speculated about there being an SK earlier. So, nothing.

[MafiaSSK]

Mod: I'm sorry but I need a replacement

[hasdgfas]

Mod: I'm sorry but I need a replacement

[TheSweatpantsNinja]

So you were getting at HC mentioning there being an SK? I guess. . . but really, wouldn't as SK, he be just as likely to try to make us think there isn't an SK? WIFOM, I know, but I really think its a null-tell. I'm going to assume there's an SK unless someone claims vig. (And then I might assume that

they're

the SK.)

[CoheedCambria09]

In replacing MafiaSSK, I'll try and read over the game tonight, if not tomorrow.

[Gorrad]

I've seen nothing to pursuade me from TSN and HC. Waiting for contet from CC09 with baited breath.

[CoheedCambria09]

I Made it to the beginning of page 13 tonight, so ive only seen the first three kills.

From those pages I think that there is either a sk or vig, im leaning towards sk though since it was 2 towns who were killed that night, but then again, it could have just been an accident. I'll have a better analysis after reading the second half of the game, probly tomorrow or tuesday.

[Thanatos]

I Made it to the beginning of page 13 tonight, so ive only seen the first three kills.

From those pages I think that there is either a sk or vig, im leaning towards sk though since it was 2 towns who were killed that night, but then again, it could have just been an accident. I'll have a better analysis after reading the second half of the game, probly tomorrow or tuesday.

Killing Silver pheonix...it really could have gone either way. Why kill a lurker who doesn't post? Well, maybe he noticed something on him, or just wanted to kill someone.

Actually, thinking about how this game is going, if I was an SK or a Vig who didn't have someone who he wanted to kill, I would take the time to kill someone who wasn't helping the town or the game by being AWOL in a game with so many lurkers.

For HC to assume there is one is suspicious.

[hasdgfas]

I'm against an SSK lynch for one simple reason: Out of Gorrad, TSPN, ChaosOmega, Thanatos, hasghfas, and myself, at least one person is Mafia and

another person is an SK.

I know it's not me, and hasghfas looks pretty clear, so that leaves four people who are statistically better lynches today regardless of play. Unless Alabaska or SSK do something amazingly dumb, I don't think either of them is a good lynch today.

Found him.

How the heck did you figure out who the SK is?

Keep in mind that dicking around with the town is a capital offense.

The found him was for reactions, mostly from HC, but also from everyone else. I found this reaction extremely interesting, as though you're nervous about something I said, and only one role would have need to be nervous.

unvote, vote: Thanatos

[Alabaska J]

Are you serious? Thanatos is the most town out of all of us so far. :/ Are we sure hasdgfas' ability is protown?

[Gorrad]

Yes, we are

[Alabaska J]

Why?

[Gorrad]

It cannot possibly help scum, and it can help town a good deal

[hasdgfas]

Are you serious? Thanatos is the most town out of all of us so far. :/ Are we sure hasdgfas' ability is protown?

Most town in your opinion, I believe. That doesn't mean that everyone feels that way.

[CoheedCambria09]

Ok heres what I think

1. The best lynch today would be TSPN, he came off as the most scummy player to me, and I think he is the best option

2. Let Gorrad survive today. If he dies tonight then we will find out if he had the abilities he said he did. If he survives and his abilities are claimed then we keep him alive. If he survives and his abilities are not claimed then I think we should lynch him.

[CoheedCambria09]

EBWOP

I forgot to add

Unvote, Vote: TheSweatpantsNinja

[Gorrad]

I'm good with that.

Unvote, Vote: TSN

[Atticus]

A bit late on teh uptake, yes! CoheedCambria09 is replacing MafiaSSK.

[Atticus]

Vote Count

Gorrad

(1):

Haschel Cedricson

TheSweatpantsNinja

(3):

ChaosOmega, CoheedCambria09, Gorrad

Thanatos

(1):

hasdgfas

CoheedCambria09

(2):

Alabaska J, TheSweatpantsNinja

Not voting (1): Thanatos

There's always a chance that I frakked up somewhere.