Orca? This! is! Dance of the Title Fairy!

[shaft.ed]

Claus's title suggestion is bland an unimaginative. I thought name-based titles were frowned upon anyways?

Sarc's proposed title is horrible.

We can think of a much better title for Guardian, I'm sure of it.

And finally, Lawrence's title is based on a one-off conversation. I don't see why it's title-worthy.

[Thestatusquo]

Claus's title suggestion is bland an unimaginative. I thought name-based titles were frowned upon anyways?

Sarc's proposed title is horrible.

We can think of a much better title for Guardian, I'm sure of it.

And finally, Lawrence's title is based on a one-off conversation. I don't see why it's title-worthy.

[Rishi]

What about for Guardian - "Not Lynched. Mislynched."

Or simply "Mislynched"

[Mr. Flay]

Don't change MoS's yet.

The following seem like good ideas but I personally think they could use more discussion
Claus-Making a list
Sarcastro-More like SarcastPOPE
Guardian-Cross Killah
Lawrencelot-Mafia Scuum

Guardian's is good. Claus' is sorta "meh". Sarc's is lame. Where does Lawrence's come from again?

I'm not personally a fan of Self-Stoofer for Mr. Stoofer. Maybe something about how his mafia games always seem to have some sort of twist?

Stoofin' It Up

? Could be better...

[Zindaras]

Lawrencelot's comes from the vacuum thread in GD. It was an interesting thread, but I'm not sure if it warrants the title (and it would be pronounced poorly in Dutch anyway >.>). I don't like Sarcy's. Not huge fan of Claus's or Guardian's.

[Alabaska J]

I like Guardian's a lot. Don't like anyone else's, really. Claus' would be more apropos if he actually made lists a lot when he posted.

[Guardian]

I think name based titles are silly.

But "definitely naughty" appeals to me for Claus, ish.

[The Fonz]

I don't like guardian's. It's based on something he did in one game, that wasn't particularly outlandish or anything.

[Erg0]

Nominate Lawrencelot for "Endless Love", based on his herculean modding effort in Big Love mafia.

Alternatively, "Tough Love" or "Love Hurts".

[Guardian]

I don't like guardian's. It's based on something he did in one game,

that wasn't particularly outlandish or anything

.

I really like it, and beg to differ. :?.

"Mislynched" made me lol, though.

[Rishi]

I know people don't like name-based titles, but what about one based on both name and avatar?

Nominate The Fonz for "Jumped the Shark"

(Of course, I haven't noticed any decline in the quality of his play, but I still think it's funny.)

[Guardian]

I think once fonz put that as his avatar he, as a forum memeber, jumped the shark.

second?.

[Oman]

Second on that Guardian

Nominate Lawrencelot for "Endless Love", based on his herculean modding effort in Big Love mafia.

Alternatively, "Tough Love" or "Love Hurts".

Any one of these

Second

[Thestatusquo]

Nominate MoS for "lulzipop guildz."

to commemorate not just his lollipop guild status, but also his place at the forefront of hip hop culture.

[Adel]

I think name based titles are silly.

But "definitely naughty" appeals to me for Claus, ish.

if we have to go there, I think "Bad Santa" would be better.

[shaft.ed]

I think name based titles are silly.

But "definitely naughty" appeals to me for Claus, ish.

if we have to go there, I think "Bad Santa" would be better.

"I stole Jesus' Holiday"?

[Oman]

"BRING ME MUYR!"

[Thestatusquo]

This whole line of reasoning on claus is terrible.

[The Fonz]

I don't like guardian's. It's based on something he did in one game,

that wasn't particularly outlandish or anything

.

I really like it, and beg to differ. .

Well, I don't find it particularly amusing, and I don't think crosskilling is that rare an accomplishment. It happens pretty regularly. I think there are a lot of things that stand out about you as a player, and that ain't any of them. That you crosskilled K9 in one game doesn't come to mind when i think of you.

'Too active' for instance, would fit you a lot better, imho, as would the proposed 'mislynched' or 'not a tracker.'

[Adel]

I don't like guardian's. It's based on something he did in one game,

that wasn't particularly outlandish or anything

.

I really like it, and beg to differ. .

Well, I don't find it particularly amusing, and I don't think crosskilling is that rare an accomplishment. It happens pretty regularly. I think there are a lot of things that stand out about you as a player, and that ain't any of them. That you crosskilled K9 in one game doesn't come to mind when i think of you.

'Too active' for instance, would fit you a lot better, imho, as would the proposed 'mislynched' or 'not a tracker.'

He replaced into a game and made exactly one post in the game, ending it. His single post hammered an opposing scum, and his night move killed the other opposing scum.

His one post yielded two dead scum from an opposing mafia. This wasn't part of an endgame, it was day 2!

One post killed two scum. At that rate my 1900 posts could be responsible for 3800 scum deaths, instead of 9.

[gorckat]

What about "Two in one post!", sort of like the old giant-killer fairy tale where the baker hoots and hollers about killing eight flies in one blow?

[OhGodMyLife]

Still supporting Guardian getting some kind of title for what happened in Open 61

[cicero]

Re Guardian and Open 61: "One Hit Wonder"?

[Rishi]

Re Guardian and Open 61: "One Hit Wonder"?

That's awesome. Seconded.

[Alabaska J]

Thirded

@one hit wonder