Pick your Poison 3 (Game Over)

[Mellowed Man]

Vote: Roleblocker

I think you are a geek.

[Mellowed Man]

unvote, vote Godfather, Encryptor, Roleblocker


I really do not like the idea of a 2-shot vig, as it seems that he or she can easily kill two extra townspeople within the first two nights?

The encryptor is interesting, but I like the fact that it is a one-time thing, and it might not be used in time, if the player who is the encryptor does not PM in time.

Godfather and Roleblocker seem okay to me.

I do not like the idea of a rolecop either, as if the game is drawn out, he could know the roles of several players.

[Mellowed Man]

unvote, vote Godfather, Encryptor, Roleblocker

[Mellowed Man]

vote: encryptor

[Mellowed Man]

I see Sarcastro seems excited!

Vote: Ether

because she firmly voted for the two-shot vig role. BOO.

[Mellowed Man]

Vote: Incognito

[Mellowed Man]

Mellowed, why'd you vote for me specifically (out of {Coron, Ether, Marmalade, Sarcastro}) and why'd you switch?

Hey, here's something interesting: the supersaint and its hammerer are both janitorproof. (I've clarified this already.) Until the janitor's shot is out, pressured supersaints should act and claim like vanillas, and the town should vote on who should hammer each individual. (Of course, this assumes that there are supersaints.)

For example, Mellowed should hammer Incognito.

Serious suggestion.

Alright: I voted Sarcastro because I was a bit hazy on the whereabouts of the situation, and thought it was a bit like the beginning of a normal game. (random stage). I acquiesce, I did not really specifically read what people said aside from their votes on what roles to give to the mafia. Therefore, I really had no idea what Incognito had said and if it had any relevance whatsoever.

On the latter part, I lost you. What do you mean by Janitorproof? I did not see a role called Janitor, unless perhaps you mean Jack of All Trades? Anyways, if you all want me to hammer Incognito for whatever reason, I'll oblige?????

Yeah, I think I need you to explain what you mean.

[Mellowed Man]

This has

definitely

not answered my question. Why did you vote for me, as opposed to {Coron, Marmalade, Sarcastro}? What do you believe about us vig-supporters currently? What prompted you to move to Incognito?

I'm thinking some other things, but they can wait.

OK:

I voted for you, truthfully, as a random stage vote, in all seriousness. At the same time, I picked your name randomly. Yes, this is a weak argument on my behalf, but 100% relevant.

Furthermore, I think that the vig-supporters are by probability more than likely not all scum, so I don't think the votes themselves are enough to form conjectures about anything yet without further activity.

I moved to Incognito just because it was a bandwagon, AND Sarcastroid said that he made a very blunt post in the beginning. When I read that he voted and proclaimed that he thought it did not matter what the scum roles were, I concluded that putting my vote there would not do any harm.

[Mellowed Man]

Lol. An L-2 bandwagon on

page 5

of the thread for fairly ridiculous reasons while about one or two people haven't even gotten a chance to comment on anything? And only three people feel the need to question the validity of it? Yeah, I'm pretty much done posting in this game. You can either lynch me as unhelpful town or wait for the mod to find a replacement. This is bullshit.

I would like to say I HATE when people crack under pressure and ask for a replacement. It is really just inadmissible. I've already seen two games go into this extremism. As a person who has played multiple games of Mafia (I.e. on this site), you should be ashamed for abandoning a game like this, and showing such abysmal class.

There should earnestly be a rule that prevents situations like this, and this act does the moderator no favors either.

[Mellowed Man]

I'll admit that I have no clue what to make of Incognito's little outburst. Getting replaced because people vote for you is immature I think, but I have no clue whether it makes him scummy or not. I don't like this wagon anymore.

unvote: Incognito

WOW...


Why on earth are people jumping off the wagon, especially after he decides to stay and makes up some excuse along the lines of "You were having a bad day."?

[Mellowed Man]

me best guess would be that at least one scum member voted for the vig power. Rereading, incog seems like he's trying too hard to defend himself with defenses that aren't really that good of defenses. I agree- everyone has been accused of being scum when they're town- it's happened to me every game I've ever played in. I'm not quite buying his defenses.

Vote Incognito

And that was your first reason?

[Mellowed Man]

By the way, I've been really sick, so no need to prod me. Incognito, my vote on Ether was a random vote, btw. =( I nebulously see what you are going for, but it was positively what I meant.

Regardless,

unvote, vote Babygirl86

[Mellowed Man]

I don't have much time to post since I'm leaving in an hour, but I don't feel like getting lynched before I have the chance to claim while I'm away. But I'm not sure I should claim yet. But anway.... No that wasn't my only reasoning for voting incognito.. It was my reasoning for REvoting him.... My original reasoning still stands

yea it was. but as I'm on my way out the door I have a feeling I'll be lynched by the time I get back from vacation so I might as well do this now, even tho ugh odds are you won't believe me. But either way: I'm a cop.

I think this is a pathetic claim; right when she is beginning to be bandwagoned, or pointed at as suspicious, she says "I can claim, but I don't know if I should since I'm going somewhere and might not be able to post!." Then, she does indeed claim just because I say her reason for originally voting Cognate was pitiful...

Of all the things she can say.. =(

[Mellowed Man]

Mellowed Man, please answer the questions that I've asked. You haven't really fully answered them by mentioning that your Ether vote was random. I asked more specific questions than that.

You only asked why I decided to hop onto your wagon after voting Ether. I just felt like it was a worthy bandwagon to start the game, and that is that.. Honestly, I cannot fathom or conceive or perceive or what-you-would-like-to-call-it why this is such a big dilemma.

[Mellowed Man]

Unfortunately, I liked the Babygirl bandwagon, but I'd be okay with Incog too.

unvote, vote Incognito

Yeah, that is correct. I am now voting Incognito. =)

[Mellowed Man]

I'm being bandwagoned quite much!

I see people finally took Sarc's post seriously. =)

[Mellowed Man]

I do admit it is suspicious that people seemed to "oppose" with open arms the Incognito bandwagon earlier. Mine has risen to 8 in a heartbeat, while that one seemed to be a "standstill-bandwagon."


Hee Hee.

[Mellowed Man]

MORE MELLOWED VOTES ARE WELCOME

[Mellowed Man]

I refuse to claim, because I would not like to.

My reasoning is: if you all think there is enough evidence to warrant a Mellow lynch, then it is my time to go.