Here's why I voted Capricious. This is almost the same post I was going to write before the lynch, with a few changes made knowing his real alignment:
Posts 38-39:
Capricious tried to over analyze the N0 kill. Not only that, but he was implying that I should have been killed for being a strong townie (While using as an example a game on which I was scum). I also get from him the same strategy I used, as scum, in that game - "The choice is illogical, I wouldn't do that as scum".
Post 61:
Capricious answers eldarad's questions, but he's obviously avoiding real answers.
Post 98:
"Last time you voted me I was town, and I guessed right who the scum were, and no one believed me. The town will lose if you lynch me". Using emotions and completely irrelevant information as defence - Never good.
Post 103:
Admitting he used meta information, and not good info.
Post 104:
Quotes another player's suggestion for discussion (Mizzy), and leaves it as is. Just a "Look at me, you're just thinking I'm not really playing the game, but I do". That's plain-sight-lurking if you ask me.
Post 107:
Accuses hasdgfas for actually telling the town exactly that. Also he says he believes there are werewolves, but wolfsbane won't help. "I believe werewolves exist. I believe fighting werewolves won't help. Choose one". That's the same "I'm here! I'm doing things!".
Post 112:
Completely missing my point and accuses me for things I didn't say. He also contradicts what he said about wolfsbane in 107.
Post 114:
Completely contradicting his 107 by saying power-roles probably do have wolfsbane. I believed, at the time, that he either knew something, or was trying to lure some one to slip and say something about wolfsbane.
Posts 116-117:
Obviously accusing people without knowing what he's talking about.
Post 151:
Talks to eldarad and then votes for Andycyca. No reason given.
Posts 168-169:
Actually saying voting me had a good reason (It didn't). Remembers to actually say something about the Andycyca vote.
Posts 192-195:
Protecting Skruffs' irrelevant meta-gaming. Misrepresents eldarad's post. Discards Mizzy's post with no explanation.
Post 214:
"I'm stupid". Poor Capricious uses emotions again.
Post 227:
Feel is important, but he's completely dismissing everything else. That's understandable, for some one who ignores logic most of the time.
Post 262-263:
Self vote, to avoid a no-lynch (After saying we shouldn't do so in 194. Calling for an Andycyca's lynch D2.
Post 267:
Calling people pro-town. No explanation. Again.
Post 271:
Adding other people to the "good list". Same lack of reasoning.
Post 274:
"Elmo is town for defending me when I do something stupid".
Post 293:
"Town are creators, scum are concluders". Weird, I saw no real creations from Capricious.
Post 297-298:
Andycyca is no longer scum. Capricious uses the last post as an excuse to let it go. Defends the illogical statement from 274.
Post 316:
"I'm here". Doing nothing, but here.
Post 320:
Another list without real explanation. The two people he actually explains his thoughts about are me and eldarad. Both of us are "Maybe, maybe not" in his post.
Posts 364-366:
Glorifies Mizzy again. "She must be town for defending me". Of course, there's no possibility for her to be scum, getting confirmed for protecting a townie who's about to get lynched, right?
Suddenly attacks hasdgfas. Doesn't really care he's on his way to the noose.
Posts 368-370:
Attacks Zindaras too. Shooting in the dark?
Post 403:
"Everybody, just follow me".
Some meta:
Last time I played with him, he disappeared once he was about to get lynched as scum, not giving too much of a fight.
As a whole, I got the feeling that he's just trying to put suspicion on people, giving no importance to how or why. The way he accused and defended people seemed completely disconnected to the actual way those players played the game.
I played with Capricious and I know his logic might be off sometimes, and I think Skruffs is scum, so Skruffs was my better choice. When we got close to deadline and we needed a lynch, Capricious not being such a good player seemed to be much less important than all the other things he did.
As to Andycyca's hammer, I think he was just tired of the day dragging along. I actually hoped some one would do that already, since no real progression was being made. I believe it was a compulsive action. Not necessarily a good one, but not definitely a scum action. I also believe that it was obvious he'd be questioned about it, and would be the easiest target for the scum to push toward a lynch.
