to question DXdaamno wrote:Bah! My suspiscions are jumping all over the place, and I'm going to start again.muffinhead wrote:Well for me iceman hasnt come up with a single good reason to vote anyone out.
1st up was snailman cause he wasnt a kiss fan
then me for being to defense imdiatly after voting snail, also i have posted more then anyone so i dont c how i can be defensive.
Then sd for rv on page 1
and straight away in all situations has gone defensive and unvoted immidiatly.
I am really keen to get an icemane vote however he is a noob and it simply could be bad play and i need to be certain before voting.
question for icemane. y shouldnt we lynch u first up?
Vote: muffinhead
A) You're pretending iceman's kiss-based random vote was serious, which it obviously wasn't.
B) Posting isn't 100% correlated to how overdefensive you are, especially not inversly correlated.
C) You're talking about him as a n00b, in the third person, when you are yourself; false elitism. I do often think this is a scum tell.
D) You ask an impossible question of him that he can't possibly give a satisfactory answer to. If you're confident the question is fair, why shouldn't we lynchyoufirst up?
Ok this doesnt make sense to me, how did i swoop in for the kill for asking questions to icemane? I wanted to c him under pressure and how he would respond to pressure. Also how did I rephase ur comment rishi when i said 3 times more then uI don't like how SD and muffinhead swooped in for the kill after I noted some suspicions of icemanE. The worst part is that they are mostly rehashing my arguments
Now this really doesnt make sense, how come that throughout this whole game u have seen rishi as scum. Also how does defending icemanE make rishi scum. I have seen many situations where the ic wouldve voted off there noob partner in an attempt to not look sus, or at the very least ask a few more questions.FoS My suspicions that i have stood by were that Rishi and Spz were scum, ( now IcemanE). It seems scummy to me that right when IcemanE gets a little bit of pressure someone jumps to defend him, not xdaamo, not twiglees, not ting,........but Rishi..hmmmmm
Why X? This is the first I've heard of this, I think.icemanE wrote:X and SDOk so question for icemanE because i like to adress people with questions as u said lol,
anyways, who do u think now is most likely to be scum
icemanE wrote:EBWOP: Meant to say SD and Muffin, sorry.Rishi wrote:Why X? This is the first I've heard of this, I think.icemanE wrote:X and SDOk so question for icemanE because i like to adress people with questions as u said lol,
anyways, who do u think now is most likely to be scum
OK, I've reread and I'm going to post a scumchart: 1. means most scummy, whatever the lowest number is means leess scummy. A few people I can't get reads on; I will state my opinions on these people later.
1. SD_Reaper. I feel that he is contributing very little on the town. All the posts, especially his early ones, seem to be a bit suspicious. His later posts are getting better; he could be newbie townie or newbie power role. However, I feel that he is most likely to be scum due to saying thar Rishi is scum. I can't see why.
=2. IcemanE/spZ: He has rose up to become scummy in my opinion. It could be newbie town. The lynch -1 vote would not be particularly scummy on its own; however he seems to be voting even though he could be innocent. Lynch -1 should not be taken lightly unless you are very sure that this person is scum.
=2. muffinhead: My opinions on muffinhead are based on earlier events; namely stating a spZ/IcemanE-Rishi scumteam was likely. However, he seems to have asked a fairly impossible question to icemanE. The only way anyone could guarantee their innocence is a cop investigation or quoting role PM. Number 1 will not happen on day 1, number 2 is against the rules.
4. ting =): This is just because he seems to have disappeared: if he comes back, he will be lowered in this list.
I can't see scumtells off farside22, Rishi, Smailman8 or Xdaamno. They all seem town to me. Current;y I can't see anything wrong with an SD_Reaper lynch apart from the chance to a newbie power role.
How does suspecting Rishi to be scum make me most likely to be scum? Its just a suspicion that has been going mind. I dont see how suspecting Rishi of scum makes me appear scummy. Please explain to me why suspecting Rishi makes me look like mafia.However, I feel that he is most likely to be scum due to saying thar Rishi is scum.
wow can someone tell me how to possibly get x mixed up with muffin? escpically considering i asked thequestion in the first place.Xdaamno wrote:icemanE wrote:EBWOP: Meant to say SD and Muffin, sorry.Rishi wrote:Why X? This is the first I've heard of this, I think.icemanE wrote:X and SDOk so question for icemanE because i like to adress people with questions as u said lol,
anyways, who do u think now is most likely to be scum
FOS: Iceman
I know it's a mistake. It's just a mistake more likely to be made if you're making it up.
I actually somewhat agree with this. Until you know whether or not I am scum, you can't call someone scum for suspecting me. Now, if I get lynched or killed tonight and it is proven that I'm town, then the argument holds a little more weight.SD_Reaper wrote:How does suspecting Rishi to be scum make me most likely to be scum? Its just a suspicion that has been going mind. I dont see how suspecting Rishi of scum makes me appear scummy. Please explain to me why suspecting Rishi makes me look like mafia.However, I feel that he is most likely to be scum due to saying thar Rishi is scum.
If you scum, I'd guess you're more likely to be making your suspiscions up, and therefore unsure of your 'facts', which is why you may of slipped up with the names.icemanE wrote:I know it's a mistake. It's just a mistake more likely to be made if you're making it up.
Eh? Could you explain this?
Technically we are all "making our suspicions up". There are no facts, it's all opinion and evaluation. In the post where I answered muffin's question about who I thought was scum, I didn't cite anything, I simply listed two names. You can make of that what you will.If you scum, I'd guess you're more likely to be making your suspiscions up, and therefore unsure of your 'facts', which is why you may of slipped up with the names.
Iceman, this does seem really suspicious that you would mistake one person for another if you are thinking about that person and what they said in previous posts and speculations. It deffinately opens up the possibility that you could be making up some of your suspicions. Hence why you still have my vote.EBWOP: Meant to say SD and Muffin, sorry.
That's fine. I'm still very suspicious of you, as well. I don't know why you think I'd "make up my suspicions" even if I was scum, that doesn't make much sense to me.Iceman, this does seem really suspicious that you would mistake one person for another if you are thinking about that person and what they said in previous posts and speculations. It deffinately opens up the possibility that you could be making up some of your suspicions. Hence why you still have my vote.
Actually, everybody understands why you think that i am scum. That's why i didnt mention it. I think that it is kinda obvious. Now the fact you are using that weak reasoning to put me L-1 says something.The way I read that last post of yours, it seems like you're trying to distract everyone from the fact that YOU were the other person I mentioned that I was suspicious of, and that seems suspicious. That deserves a vote.
Actually, everybody understands why you think that i am scum. That's why i didnt mention it. I think that it is kinda obvious. Now the fact you are using that weak reasoning to put me L-1 says something.
Listen to your logic. You say im trying to distract everyone from the fact that "i" was the other person. Yeah i guess... if you dont mention the fact that xdaamo and muffinhead pointed it out the same thing earlier. So you are saying that i deserve to be put at L-1 because i and two other people found your post suspicious. Common, thats terrible reasoning. You are putting me at L-1 because you are too nervous cause you know you are scum and im attacking you.
