Realistic Mafia - Game Over

[armlx]

vote: armlx

This post makes our job so much easier. Thank you for digging the hole, keep the shovel in case you want to make it deeper.

As for lynching BM, I would wait a bit to see. The kill thing is very non-damning, as many things could have prevented it.

[Dasquian]

Sure, I get that a mafia kill could've been blocked while a vig kill wasn't, making the numbers add up.

What about the quote though? If you're a vig, why would you imply your kill was a scum kill? It really looks to me like he was all for playing along with the "I have no idea who killed Sarcastro but I'm glad they did" line until he was forced to make the only claim he possibly could've made.

[Crub]

Sorry I find the bringing out of WIFOM to be scummy especially when it's in relation to something that is definitely not WIFOM.

For your accusation to hold any water. Me, NabNab and CB would have to be ALL Mafia.

[Surye]

What about the quote though? If you're a vig, why would you imply your kill was a scum kill? It really looks to me like he was all for playing along with the "I have no idea who killed Sarcastro but I'm glad they did" line until he was forced to make the only claim he possibly could've made.

Honest question: Should a vig be claiming on page 1?

And what do you think he would gain from taking credit for the N0 kill, when he could have simply let it slide?

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

- Cyberbob is lynched. Votes Reset.

- Yes, you can vote to end the day.
- Prods sent

[armlx]

For your accusation to hold any water. Me, NabNab and CB would have to be ALL Mafia.

Nope, just you and Cyber.

[Crub]

What so you're claiming I went to Cyber's house with the knowledge that NabNab would be there in order to tamper with "evidence". The whole point of going in a group of 2 was to add a safeguard to make sure that didn't happen.

[armlx]

What so you're claiming I went to Cyber's house with the knowledge that NabNab would be there in order to tamper with "evidence". The whole point of going in a group of 2 was to add a safeguard to make sure that didn't happen.

No, that was the whole point of sending one.

[armlx]

EBWODP: One relatively confirmed townie I mean, instead of someone random who has done nothing and has no evidence that could clear them.

[Dasquian]

What about the quote though? If you're a vig, why would you imply your kill was a scum kill? It really looks to me like he was all for playing along with the "I have no idea who killed Sarcastro but I'm glad they did" line until he was forced to make the only claim he possibly could've made.

Honest question: Should a vig be claiming on page 1?

And what do you think he would gain from taking credit for the N0 kill, when he could have simply let it slide?

Sure, I don't think he should be claiming straight away, or giving away any hints. But what he did say seemed to be an

anti-claim

, if he really was the vig. Actually pinning that death to the mafia if he knew he did it himself is a really contradictory thing to say.

OTOH it makes sense for him to NK Sacrastro as scum because he doesn't like him, gloat about it, then back-peddle and claim vig when guns are found in his house.

[Surye]

Sure, I don't think he should be claiming straight away, or giving away any hints. But what he did say seemed to be an anti-claim, if he really was the vig. Actually pinning that death to the mafia if he knew he did it himself is a really contradictory thing to say.

I wouldn't take that as an anticlaim at all. If anything, it served to foreshadow a claim.

OTOH it makes sense for him to NK Sacrastro as scum because he doesn't like him, gloat about it, then back-peddle and claim vig when guns are found in his house.

Though I do not dismiss this possibility.

[dahill1]

see this is the good thing about multiple lynches..
right now i think crub is pretty suspicious so

vote crub

i think he should be our next lynch
also i think we should consider BM for a lynch, but first crub

[Primate]

Hang on, BM says he killed Sarc night 0?

I'd like some clarification on that, because as far as I'm aware, I killed sarc night 0.

[dahill1]

aww snap counterclaim

What the hell - you vig-killed Sarcastro on N0?

Umm yeh. Who wouldn't!?

[Primate]

No, actually I think it's plausible that both of us killed sarc night 0, or I didn't and BM did, otherwise I'd be voting him. What I want is clarification on BM's movements last night, nothing more.

[Albert B. Rampage]

Vote Primate

I'll take BM's word over yours...

[dahill1]

oh ok
well for a while he didn't say it directly, but later on he pretty much admitted to kill sarc

[Celebloki]

I'd like some clarification on that, because as far as I'm aware, I killed sarc night 0.

hmmm, how intriguing.... I was already not liking BMs claim to vig.... but idk if I like your apparent claim to it either...

[Primate]

Pretty sure scum didn't kill Sarc, fyi.

Also, not enough people voting Superfly.

*bump*

This was like my third post today.

[Albert B. Rampage]

simul-posted.

unvote

[Celebloki]

Aside: Happy birthday celebloki.

sank you good sir

[Albert B. Rampage]

So you got a buttload of guns at your house too, Primate ?

[NabakovNabakov]

It would seem to me that response PM's would be able to clear this up. If Primate and BM both targeted Sarc, one of them must have gotten something along the lines of "You go to where you expect Sarc to be but he's already dead". At this point I would be tempted to trust Primate. BM had guns; Sarc was murdered with a knife.

Cebloki: Don't tell us not to play Mafia. As far as I'm concerned, the investigation and lynch of Cyberbob was a bonus, something which happened outside of core mafia play (discussing and lynching scummy players). Towns have gotten by without night actions before on just their wits.

As for CyberBob's door. It was locked and that's that. Does somebody want to go check if its locked? Does somebody want to take the key off his corpse and look inside? I don't really care because I have nothing to hide and think that far too big a deal has been made of this.

[Primate]

I'm not a vig, just a role theoretically capable of killing, like we all are.

[Primate]

Has anyone searched CB's corpse yet?