Not it!!In post 3, Uncle Shelby wrote:Right, so who's the bad one?
VOTE: Mastina
Currently trying to get caught up in the main thread, will be back here later
Not it!!In post 3, Uncle Shelby wrote:Right, so who's the bad one?
Alignment assignment had a random element; as a result, the setup may break certain common assumptions, such as the idea that a neighborhood cannot be composed entirely of members of the same scumteam.
I will look back over Peta and get back to youIn post 9, Uncle Shelby wrote:Peta is weirding me out. I think if he was online when T3 slipped and town, he'd have been more active in the thread. If they are indeed aligned, I bet he was raging in the scum PT and managed to [mostly] restrain himself in the main thread, but I am picking up on some frustration geared towards T3. Hard to say for sure if it's just sloppy newbie condescension or "bastard ruined my team's chances" frustration.
Yeah, I got youIn post 14, Uncle Shelby wrote:MeaningIn post 12, Uncle Shelby wrote:50/50
There is
or there isn't.
Any thoughts on this post seeing that we are the monks?In post 14, morph the cat wrote:speculation: this design might be monks and masons for big kids.
Yeah, but it went on for too long imoIn post 25, Uncle Shelby wrote:Oh with the unwnd/Echo stuff? I think it's mostly shitposting.
In post 21, Lukewarm wrote:Any thoughts on this post seeing that we are the monks?In post 14, morph the cat wrote:speculation: this design might be monks and masons for big kids.
https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?ti ... _and_Monks
In post 22, Lukewarm wrote:Like, does that mean that they have to be masons for them to make that guess?
Any thoughts wrt to Morph's guess here?In post 23, Lukewarm wrote:If they flip as mafia, then that will instantly up my suspicion on both of you because that would mean that they got the monk/mason info from out pt.
If they flip werewolf, then that means that there is a werewolf in the masons.
What claims do you think would lead to that conclusion?In post 28, Uncle Shelby wrote:No, it's a fairly common open setup that goes back a long time, and there are enough hints from the OP and the various claims out in the open for anyone to make a conclusion like that.In post 22, Lukewarm wrote:Like, does that mean that they have to be masons for them to make that guess?
I guess so.In post 29, Uncle Shelby wrote:You haven't seen anything yet, with some of these combinations of players. The Ydrasse/Pooky/unwnd/[others I'm forgetting atm] crowd are notorious for shitposting in seemingly impossibly large waves.In post 26, Lukewarm wrote:Yeah, but it went on for too long imoIn post 25, Uncle Shelby wrote:Oh with the unwnd/Echo stuff? I think it's mostly shitposting.
I am pretty sure we have a werewolf miller claim and a mafia miller claimIn post 32, Uncle Shelby wrote:I'm not thinking about timeline rn, so this may not add up, but off the top of my head there's the werewolf miller claim.
In post 32, Uncle Shelby wrote:But the fact the game is explicitly multiball, if you're familiar with site meta/history, would lead most to thinking along those lines first, I should think.
In post 682, petapan wrote:just realized that based on the setup info ceph absolutely could have created a werewolf miller that is mafia-aligned, lmao
guess i have to actually read the miller claims on play, that's so annoying though
In post 1853, Lukewarm wrote:I am much less wary of you now, yes. I would say I am currently tentatively town reading you guys now.In post 1848, morph the cat wrote:Can I talk to you without contributing to waryiness now or are we still shrodinger's cat read?In post 1835, Lukewarm wrote:If that is the case, I would say that I generally believe you guys are in a hood, and lowkey assumed you were in one since post 14 lolIn post 1831, morph the cat wrote:I uh, think that was more a "Arceus Dammit you are a hood magnet" than a "Press X to Doubt"
A concern of mine has actually completely vanished recently (no, I won't be telling you what that was )
I understand the distinction there, but I guess seeing Vaxkiller's claim and Ythan's claim back to back led me to assume that our "mafia cop" was just a gunsmith this game, and so vax was functionally the mafia miller.In post 56, mastina wrote:Having a gun is a miller to a Gunsmith, which there's any number of town roles that could be.In post 53, Lukewarm wrote:Vaxkiller has claimed that they investigate as having a gun (which I took to functionally be the mafia miller, but ythan somewhat disagrees)
And my worry here is not hat he doesn't want to be the elim, because I understand not wanted to get miselimed if you are a townie, but it feels like he is trying to hide that he feels that way, which seems scummy to meIn post 63, Lukewarm wrote:And then looking at Dann, he generally feels pretty good, but I just get a vibe that he is trying really hard to come across as perfectly fine with (and even advocating) him being the day 1 elim, but then under the surface he is looking for someone else to shift the elim to.
I feel like Shelby has been out making pushes and stuff.In post 78, mastina wrote:I mean if any of us three were to get shot it'd be you--I've barely been in the game, Shelby is low-presence, you're the only one who's obvtown, so I'd be shocked if anyone among us died unless it were you.In post 74, Lukewarm wrote:Is anyone worried they are not going to make it through the night?
Sadly, I've no way to prevent a death in here or protect morph who're obviously going to die sooner rather than later.
The perspective slip that Morph accused Manatee of making was specifically when talking about Vecna, so I guess the question is whether you think it really was a perspective slip or not.In post 79, mastina wrote:I didn't get a chance to read morph's posts but I didn't understand the pairing with Vecna. I got why Manatee was scum from the case; that was self-apparent and very very obvious. I don't really get why Vecna's a partner from the case though, at least what I saw.In post 76, Lukewarm wrote:Thoughts on the accusation of Manatee being partnered with Vecna?
I think his reaction looked the most like a partner tbh.
Want to share the theory in here?In post 2883, mastina wrote:A good question that I have my theory about!In post 2881, Kakeguri Addicts wrote:So why was a mafia member bulletproof, then?In post 2879, mastina wrote:The mod's answer to this question was that bulletproof does not apply to the werewolves' factionall kill.
One which I won't share with the thread while you're alive since I'm thinking you're scum here.