(@farside 378) And what you have done works well enough for me.
Unvote: farside22
Before I forget, could you explain your reaction in farside 256?
All right, sorting some things out...
Vi: Post 168 why only SpreX or Korts?
I saw you had jumped onto the wagon as well, but for a different reason (which you brought up in a few of your other comments). Those two were the ones I saw who were driving the case on tubby OMGrolefishing.
Vi: post 320: Have yet to seen a case against me or DGB. Seems out of the blue comment with nothing backed up.
You, already covered.
DGb started blatantly useless (hence my vote) and to all appearances has stayed blatantly useless (hence why it didn't change until I pressured you).
Okay Vi you haven't brought any case against me you are just asking questions. Question do not equal suspicion at all.
I don't blithely ask whatever comes to mind (when I'm asking about the game, anyway). If I ask someone something, much more often than not I'm following up on something that could/should be perceived as scummy, and an unsatisfactory answer will have consequences.
Then again, from your end I think that would take a psychic connection to know ahead of time, so I understand where you're coming from.
Vi: You haven't given much as far as your own suspicion or reasons for who is scum. All you do is ask questions. It's something I did as scum once. I'm watching you.
*watches back* 0.0
Well, since you said something, here's where everyone stands with me after a reread. Forewarning for bluntness.
MafiaSSK
- Useless, and sketchy even with his meta. The sooner he puts out his PbPA, the sooner we can get an answer to the question of why he thinks tubby is the scummiest (and doesn't start talking about it until tubgate is over).
DoomCow
- Useless, mostly. Hung up on the post restriction thing, and reluctant to do analysis because nobody has died yet (*insert rant about NK WIFOM here*). Unfortunately, my meta on him is that "useless, mostly" is his playstyle.
Natirasha
- Artificially semi-useless. But aside from that, I see what he's doing and I don't see anything wrong with him so far.
Crazy
- Not useless. I generally agree with what he has been saying, though that isn't indicative of his alignment. That's about all I can say either way.
hasdgfas
- Not really useless. Most of his posts after replacing in are pointing out the uselessness of others, but judging from his vote DoomCow is still in the lead on his scumlist. No read either way.
farside22
- Hai~ I understand that you voted for tubby for different reasons than the others. I'm not sure what to say about tubby biting the hand that feeds him -> scumtell, although it was a horrible move on his part. Other than that, I think you check out at this point. Null read.
CoheedCambria09
- Useless. His vote in 257 is only made worse by his justification of it to ZazieR. Possibly avoiding this game; needs to exist more.
animorpherv1
- Surprisingly not the most useless person in the game upon reread, but in the running. The violent OMGUS against DoomCow stands out, but was kind of deserved. I would like some clarification about post 79. Basically, dahill1 put it right on the nose in that ani is providing color commentary more than anything (and following me, it seems...). Oh, and farside has reread; you can post now
Vi
- That one person, with the posts. Trying not to be useless.
SpyreX
- Not useless; I just disagree with him. I'm still not confident in his reread in 327, but aside from what I've already said about it I don't think I can go forward with attacking it. Intuitively, I'm leaning toward anti-Town.
dahill1
- With The Internet unplugged and dahill1 replacing him, this player slot is no longer useless. Actually, I find myself agreeing with everything dahill1 says. 'Seems Townish enough.
DrippingGoofball
- Useless, which unfortunately fits her meta juuuuuuust fine. Ignores the tubby case while it goes on and tries to chase it afterward, which is just off-putting. Trying to follow the logic (or even the humor) in her posts is bending my brain into a U-shape. I don't know what to think.
Korts
- Not useless, although he owes us a reread. The sudden flip on tubby doesn't seem kosher. I'm very interested in seeing how he re-evaluates SpyreX (for the record, in Spyre-scum's position I would definitely keep going with the tubby wagon). I also notice that he flips to CC09
before
stating that he can't pursue his case on SpyreX. Red flags sighted.
tubby216
- Not useless in the group setting at least. I (still) don't think he's automatically scum, so much as a newb/n00b in deep trouble. I would like to hear more from him in general, if possible :v
ZazieR
- Not really useless. ZazieR's way of going about these games is similar to mine. However, reading through her posts, I see what farside was talking about earlier - aside from being anti-tubby, she doesn't seem to take any stances so much as act as an argument parser. 'Worth looking into. (Also, what is your avatar from?)
@mod: Crazy and SpyreX need prods.
---~Summary~---
(italics denote people I'm unsure of)
Townish
dahill1
Natirasha
Null
farside22
hasdgfas
Crazy
tubby216
Scummish
ZazieR
Korts
SpyreX
DrippingGoofball
MafiaSSK
DoomCow
CoheedCambria09
animorpherv1
As you can see, IMO there are a lot of people who deserve votes, dayvigs, etc. However, if I had to pick one, I'll go with intuition and
Vote: SpyreX
(L-7)
Everything you say and do matters. People will respond in ways you may never see. May those responses be what you intend.