Dybeck has a vote on me...huh...Thier is a suprise. Like the time George Michael said he was actually gay.
Karen, takes this
PS
[/quote]nchingcuriouskarmadog wrote:ummm, anyone think this Karen lynch is too easy? Seems like there is a rush of voting, pushing, and bandwagoning and someone who appears to be a newbie. By my count she is at 7 votes (or -4 to lynch). WIth between 4-6 scum (2 teams of three or 2 teams of two?) This lynch will happen quickly and Day 1 will be over....Do you really want Day 1 over so fast?
unvote spag
vote davidangelsummers
I understand everyone else's vote (maybe not green day's) on Karen, but the reasons you provide are weak at best. You are voting for her because she is voting for herself..How does that help mafia? If you are voting for her and she comes up scum, does that mean you are “scum or just plain bad at this?”If you are such a pro at this game, you know a quick Day 1 does not help us.If anyone reads this post, it sounds like he already knows Karen is town. Huge Scum tell in this post town.
er ok, but im still keeping my vote till something better comes along. Stop acting like shes on the verge of being lynched. She 5 players away! (Now that shes unvoted herself!) The fact that people cant see why people are looking at Karen must be crazy. She might as well have walked in a room, got naked and sung Ive got a lovely bunch of coconut. Everything from her avatar to her posts are screaming "look at me" and I am. Get over it. If anyone seems to KNOW Karen is town its you..In fact, balls to it .I willcuriouskarmadog wrote:Everyone wants to see a better case for scum day 1(other than Karen)?...here it is. First his vote against Karen.davidangelsummers wrote:
Way off being a pro, but if karen is town then she should want town to win,right? " If shes town and gets lynched then that helps mafia, right? ....if im missing something then please fill me in
This post almost acts like he knows that Karen is town. He doesn’t even actually put a case forward against Karen. He just states that the mafia will be “rubbing their hands with glee” at her death. Why is that? Because maybe she is a town? She might be acting like the village idiot (VI), but she is could still be town.davidangelsummers wrote:Karen,If your town, how do you really think voteing yourself is going to help? Your scum or just plain bad at this...Say your proved right, will anyone respect you? No, thier just think you played badly and the scum will be rubbing thier hands in glee.VOTE KARENWhich pains me cuz your Avatar will be missed...
Someone asked, if Karen’s posts are helping the town. Yeah, I now think they are. She is an easy lynch. Just looks at everyone voting for her (like David) that doesn’t give a reason and just wants Day 1 over. Ask yourself town, who would like Day 1 over fast. Now look at David's most recent post..
“" If shes town and gets lynched then that helps mafia, right? ....if im missing something then please fill me in”
She is going to get lynched because people like you…Why are you voting for the easiest lynch here to push? I think you are scum. You still never address why you want to have a quick Day 1….All you do is say if Karen gets lynched, she is helping the mafia?..How is she helping the mafia?..because she is town?…I hope everyone see this for what it is..crap logic, being spun by someone who REALLY IS acting like scum.
curiouskarmadog wrote:ok,My problem with Karen was just that she voted for herself. I have never been a fan of such actions so I voted for her and called her bluff(Name a person that hasnt heard someone go "your regret lynching me) . I NEVER said I wanted the quick Lynch and I had not voted anyone randomly and a bit (and I mean a BIT) of pressure on a player that wants to kill herself isnt as bad as YOU make out.. Now if votes started pileing on her I would have been very suspicious, but they didnt ..I know that you want everyone to think she nearly got lynched but she was 6 away. Now please tell me how voting for her self helped? Its starting to annoy me ...(appolgies for my crap english its a Norwiegian thing)davidangelsummers wrote:curiouskarmadog wrote:
She is going to get lynched because people like you…Why are you voting for the easiest lynch here to push? I think you are scum. You still never address why you want to have a quick Day 1….All you do is say if Karen gets lynched, she is helping the mafia?..How is she helping the mafia?..because she is town?…I hope everyone see this for what it is..crap logic, being spun by someone who REALLY IS acting like scum.
and the im rubber your glue award goes to.....curiouskarmadog wrote:jesus, I am scum when I dont vote karen because I think she is an idiot town, but I am oppurntunistic when I think you are scum and vote you..Cephrir wrote:Way to be oppurtunistic, CKD. I'm done arguing with you. I don't think any amount of explanation will get you to understand a single logical thing that anyone says.
cant have it both ways.
what happened to my reply? And I think if we took a poll, your play would be voted inexperienced at best.ZONEACE wrote:
Clearly the wolves are inexperienced.
FOS anyone who's joined in last 6 months
Thats why I didnt vote just Fosed....Cephrir wrote:
There's a difference between thinking I may be wrong and thinking I'm scum. Just so you know.
That's not why your points are being dismissed, FYI.CKD wrote:well post why my points are not valid, I think they are...dont dismiss them because you dont have a valid response
Are you choosing this wagon over the Cephrir wagon or just plain voteing green day? ....(I will explain why im asking)Kison wrote:Unvote
Vote : GreenDay
I don't think the position on Karen's wagon has a lot to do with whether or not someone is going to be scum. I'd guess there were multiple scum either on the wagon or supporting it, but GreenDay
s indirect support for the wagon while trying to cover it up the next day is more bothersome to me, whether or not the Karen lynch was one I think was justified.
I was interested cuz I was looking at both wagons and some of the people on the Green where also on the Karen wagon..Those on the Cephrir where not. So I thought a town player chooseing the Green wagon out the two would look a bit scummy. Or is this just more DAS crap lodgic..its been knownkillerbob wrote:davidangelsummers wrote:Are you choosing this wagon over the Cephrir wagon or just plain voteing green day? ....(I will explain why im asking)Kison wrote:Unvote
Vote : GreenDay
I don't think the position on Karen's wagon has a lot to do with whether or not someone is going to be scum. I'd guess there were multiple scum either on the wagon or supporting it, but GreenDay
s indirect support for the wagon while trying to cover it up the next day is more bothersome to me, whether or not the Karen lynch was one I think was justified.It seems to me that david is asking for explanation from others for changing their votes or placing them in the first place when he has yet in day 2 to make a case himself. He FoSed Cephrir for voting/FoSing Karma and Dybeck but not giving reasons against those votes/FoS's. So david has moved up on my scummy list and deserves this:davidangelsummers wrote:Should you not explain why your unvoting Dybeck..? What changed your mind?WhoMe? wrote:unvote
I need to read up on Cephrir and Greenday, then I will decide where to put my vote.
FoS: davidangelsummers
I wanted to wait till he answered b4 I gave my theory and while I was waiting, I thought I would post the Dybeck question.Killer Bob
And while we are at it, I would like to see the answer Kison has to your question.
Lets break this down:curiouskarmadog wrote: Davidsummers, jumping on the Karen wagon for no reason, then attacking me for not attacking Karen, then lurking the rest of the day out.
lol....I was only meant to have this avatar up till she got back..So I got to find a new one..I wonder if people have been thinking I like pink for the last couple of months..Could explain a lot..ZONEACE wrote:Oh shit, i thought that was Pink.davidangelsummers wrote: Girlfriend back from Norway. Look at the pic ..You would not do weekends either..
Greenday, poeple are looking for a bit more content and I dont think thier going to get it..Green Day wrote:LikeDavidAngelSummerssaidThe scum are voting for me.I was interested cuz I was looking at both wagons and some of the people on the Green where also on the Karen wagon..Those on the Cephrir where not. So I thought a town player chooseing the Green wagon out the two would look a bit scummy. Or is this just more DAS crap lodgic..its been known
I Agree with you and I was going to Vote for Cephrir but you cant ignore the fact that greenday is being like a rabbit caught in the headlights.. He needs to explain him self. I dont want a quick lynch today.dybeck wrote:I think that there are several scum on Green Day's wagon.
No your 100% right I did not want to take of my vote till I get some content out of Greenday. Cuz otherwise I would be back tracking and it would have been picked up.ZONEACE wrote:he's at -3 cause Chocolate Attack unvoted (at david's request even though david didn't think he should have to unvote himself.)
Why do you think two players have not responded? Looks to me like Thorn agreed to replace and then saw his role and the arguement against him then scarpered.dybeck wrote:Lynching Green Day is slightly less idiotic than Karen, but this day is FAR from over. Let's see what happens when his replacement posts his defence. To suggest that we should lynch before a replacement is found is just likely to leave us in the dark again tomorrow.
Mod: Can we cancel this deadline please?
I wish I had listened to myself yesturday.davidangelsummers wrote:
A big part of me wants to Vote Cep cuz I want to see if Dybeck and Ckd can be right twice.
Struggling to add some content.. Are we really arguing over gut shot voteing? Shouldn’t Cephir be arguing for his life right now?dybeck wrote:Of course it's perfectly valid.
It doesn't help you to decide whether or not to vote him, and it wouldn't srtand up in a court of law. But we all need to vote the person we think it most likely to be scum. And if all we have to go on is instinct and hunches, then that's how we vote.
Your completely right, I want to go back to basics and although it looks like CKD maybe lycned ,I wanted to have another dicussion along side it. When I was looking I actully exspected it to be some-one else. I dont think that you have been that scummy, hense the no vote but it did need pointing out and your reaction was interesting..WhoMe? wrote:hmm so Im being singled out by someone who was on 2 of the mislynches himself....
I see lots of your suggestions for and against people. I even see come contradictions (“Im stupid” ) and some back tracking ( we should mass claim, ow no we shouldn’t ) What I don’t see is a vote(Yes my vote is also not in, but ive said when and why)…Why did you not put a vote on me,cicero wrote:I think DavidAngerSummers and WhoMe are both scum. What this page helps us learn is that they probably aren't scumBUDDIES.
Peers wrote:Partially. It was also partially based on my making a mistake.curiouskarmadog wrote:what is this theory based on?Peers wrote:
Theory: We have one Wolf Cop, one Mafia Cop, one Mafia Protector, and one Wolf Protector... who is dead. Sorcerer is a false claim designed to appear as useful as possible in hopes that his "I won't survive the night, wait and see!" gamble works.
maybe my claim?
I forgot -- dybeck's dead. He was the doc. The question is -- was he the Mafia-only doc? Or was he an anyone-doc?
If he was Mafia-only... then your claim actually makes a great bit of sense. If he was anyone, then yours makes a lot less sense -- in a game with faction-only docs, why include -two- anyone-docs? But if there were two faction-specific, and one anyone-but-only-every-other-day...
... dammit, it makes sense to me. Sorry, man.
Unvote
Dude your hanging yourself here. I have no idea who the scum are targeting thats why I had to go back to basics and choose the most scummy. Which I think is the guy who has lynched the most town. I am aware that some people might know too much.I am also aware now of why Cephir and Dybeck got so frustrated with the supose town. Only one way out of this-Lynch right! and if that gets me killed so be it..WhoMe? wrote:nights with fewer than 2 kills. That means that the scum team(s) have information on the other scum (or protective roles got lucky) Anyone who is a little too on the ball when hunting scum, could well be a scum of the opposing team. Just something to chew on.
Then you post this:IH wrote:So wait... there's three roles that protect against the wolves?
Wolfsbane and the two sorcerors?
If you already know that wolfbane protects against wolfs why do you need to ask the question. It could be construde as playing dumb.IH wrote:
Mod-What does a wolfsbane do?
Tarhalindur wrote:
I don't buy that claim for a second. Protection on odd nights only? Sounds like a scum falseclaim to me, especially since I'm pretty sure I know who the real sorceror is.
Vote: Curiouskarmadog
LOCK ON: Curiouskarmadog
I dont bye the claim for a seconed? hmmm that fits in with my information? Lock on then change to peers..Im not sure even you know what your on about.Tarhalindur wrote: Hmm... that fits with my information. You're probably telling the truth - and unless I'm very much mistaken about the flavor I received, you blocked the wolf NK night 2.
Unvote, Vote: Peers for much the same reason that I went after CKD.
Left my post up and grabbed a coffee...only just saw this after postooba wrote:Can't believe i missed this .. Bolding mine .. Could you explain this too?Tar wrote: I don't buy that claim for a second. Protection on odd nights only? Sounds like a scum falseclaim to me,especially since I'm pretty sure I know who the real sorceror is.
Vote: Curiouskarmadog
LOCK ON: Curiouskarmadog
I see what your saying here. I was also was not suprised that who me and Zoneace jumped on with out looking at the possibility of Tar lying. They where so sure CKD was scum. .ooba wrote:Now if your claim is true - you are a valuable pro town role .. Why would you make comments like this (bolded below) which gives away information that you are possibly a power role , as it was quite obv. CKD would have been lynched when you made that vote?Tarhalindur wrote:Okay, now that I have free time, claim time it is.
I'm a nerfed version of the Watcher (the "sees how many people target my target, including me" version). I also get flavor, giving me a clue as to what roles targeted my target (it's pretty obvious flavorwise when a scumbag attacks someone).
N1 I targeted CKD, as far as I can tell nobody targeted him besides me).
N2 I targeted CKD (again), I saw two people target CKD, one of whom was clearly a werewolf.
N3 I targeted Peers, and saw him attacked by a werewolf. CKD's claimed N3 protect was not Peers, hence my suspicion that Peers is scum - specifically mafia scum.
Note: I originally thought that the other player who targeted CKD N2 was a stronger investigative role, probably Seer (given that my role is comparatively weak), but a sorceror pair makes sense as well. I also suspect that there is a weakened Tracker somewhere in the game, but I can't be sure about that.
My own feeling is that you're scum who was just breadcrumbing your entire false claim right there for the next day .. I haven't played many games here so i can't say for sure but the flavor wise info for every person you tracked does seem a bit far fetched .. On the whole , i think you're werewolf who targeted peers on Night 3 rather than town and using this as a good chance to false claim your way to make us believe you are town ..Tar wrote:I don't buy that claim for a second. Protection on odd nights only? Sounds like a scum falseclaim to me,especially since I'm pretty sure I know who the real sorceror is.
Vote: Curiouskarmadog
LOCK ON: Curiouskarmadog
Well you being town or wolf doesn't change the fact that peers is scum ..
Unvote
Vote : Peers
How do you know he is going to mark just one person? I thought he was going to Mark them all? I would like a full list not just be fed one. The mafia will have obv had talked last night and im not going to play it thier way. The could have targeted some one last night, failed then look for a wolf or power role(could have been protected) for peers to set-up. Im happy if they hit a wolf but not so if they hit a power role. If they hit a wolf peers will try and save his ass again..if he hits a power role he will piss him self laughing.He was dead anyway. Town- please play this day right....You have let scum dominate this game.
QFT. I think we should look atleast look into the possibility of lynching the person who peers marked today - Eliminating one scum group and reducing Night kill numbers is good for town ...
lol.Another week arguement from WhoMe, suprise.. I think I played my town role well yesturday, I come back from the weekend and someone is lynched (The same person you where very quick to believe) ..This game has all been about you and your scum buddys (thier you go choose my words carefully)pushing the town around. Today wont be one of those days..WhoMe? wrote:davidangelsummers wrote: ... Town- please play this day right....You have let scum dominate this game.
hmm shouldn't that be WE have let wscum dominate.... are you not part of the town, was that a slip?
Did you even read my last posts? Liek when I said I think its funny taht you jumped on peers without even thinking Tar was Lyeing? Why? Cuz you thought he had been caught and you needed to be on a correct lynch...and thats just one point..im sure thier are others...I shall re-read..I cant lynch you without town support..I cant get town support cuz mafia will always pretend to be town..so the way I see it is this. Peers tells all and we Lynch him..If he doesnt, we Lynch him..We take the info he does or does not give us and go into the next day one mafia down...will anyone agree.....I really hope so. Who Me, you defend your self but you dont seem to argue my ideas..WhoMe? wrote:just reviewed again. Your stated case on me thus far consists solely of me being on all 3 mislynches. This would carry more weight if you yourself hadn't been on two of them....
[/quote]ooba wrote: Its not in peers best interest to lie here - He'll want another wolf dead right now .. He's not looking to set townies up when he can lynch wolves ..
If you cant see through this then your crazy...iif your town just hold off and let scum pile on..Then your have your scum list...Peers wrote:Well, then. For the reason that we targetted him last night, he failed to die, and someone else has claimed BV, and the doc should have been smart enough to stay the heck out of it...
Vote: davidangelsummers
Im Pro wolf huh?davidangelsummers wrote:Tarhalindur wrote:
I don't buy that claim for a second. Protection on odd nights only? Sounds like a scum falseclaim to me, especially since I'm pretty sure I know who the real sorceror is.
Vote: Curiouskarmadog
LOCK ON: CuriouskarmadogI dont bye the claim for a seconed? hmmm that fits in with my information? Lock on then change to peers..Im not sure even you know what your on about.Tarhalindur wrote: Hmm... that fits with my information. You're probably telling the truth - and unless I'm very much mistaken about the flavor I received, you blocked the wolf NK night 2.
Unvote, Vote: Peers for much the same reason that I went after CKD.
I really cant belive people are getting away with being sooo scummy...
Why am I not dead yet? in the fine tradition of this town, I shall vote myself..Kanaga wrote:I still think my vote on DAS is the right one. I agree with WhoMe?'s logic.