Mafia 89: Revenge (Game Over)

[-TinVision-]

Holy crap, thread is open.

Vote super random dude

. I hate that guy.

[-TinVision-]

Man, people from England really love Muse.

[-TinVision-]

Vote Wiccan Honor

. Post already, ya bum.

FOS Everyone else who hasn't posted yet. Ya bums. I'd single you out by name, but I'm too lazy.

[-TinVision-]

Massclaims only break games with bad setups. Bad setups are never written by competent moderators. Phayt is a competent moderator. Massclaim is a bad plan.

Sig'd.

Unvote, FOS Azrael001

. It's hard to even believe that you think that massclaim is a protown option. Most good setups _do not_ have both a cop and a doc, so as to explicitly not turn into games of "follow the cop". Urgh. What a terrible notion.

[-TinVision-]

"Standard Roles" to me means just the cop, doctor, townie and regular scum.

A normal game does not have to have any other roles other than Mafia and Townies. If it includes other roles, they should mostly be considered standard, such as Cop, Doctor, Vigilante, Roleblocker, Mason, Traitor, Serial Killer.

Source: https://wiki.mafiascum.net/index.php?title=Normal_Game

[-TinVision-]

That's quite the nondescript reason for a vote.

[-TinVision-]

Most good setups _do not_ have both a cop and a doc[/b], so as to explicitly not turn into games of "follow the cop". Urgh. What a terrible notion.

Huh? In my experience almost all games have a town cop and doctor, but maybe that's not the way the game is played here.

Generally, well-written games with a cop plus a doctor have a means to keep a revealed cop, live doctor from flat-out winning the game. Either, they have a scum roleblocker to block the cop, an SK or second mafia group to doublekill through the doctor's protection, or something else along those lines.


In other news, I'm still trying to sort out what I think about the KoC-Lowell-Light interaction.

[-TinVision-]

FOS MonkeyMan576 and Super Random Dude

. Their relatively quiet hopping on the Lowell bandwagon interests me.

[-TinVision-]

Well if you don't count the lurkers, this game is a ~12-man mini, in which case Lowell is at L-2. Ha.

[-TinVision-]

A team of Azrael-Lowell-Light might be too obvious, but I think two of those three are together as least.

I just read back and noticed this quote. By "two of those three are together" you mean that they are a scum team together? I'm surprised this slipped by unchallenged; it seems like an awfully big leap of deduction based on very paltry reasons. Either you're Sherlock Holmes, or you're talking a lot of nothing, or you're try to encourage a wagon on any one of the three of the people who've garnered some suspicion already. I don't trust it.

Vote BridgesAndBaloons

[-TinVision-]

Ok, my bad. Needless to say, we have a good number of people that are looking scummy(at least scummier than everyone else) at this point:

Lowell
Azrael
KoC
Light

This is a useless list, and not just because I'm on it. You picked the only four people anyone is talking about and said you think they're slightly scummier than the people no one is talking about. What are you, the narrator?

I hate to say it, but I agree with Lowell.

You should at least say what you think of these people or your post is basically fluff.

[-TinVision-]

On the whole KoC thing. I don't get it. So he pressured Azrael about some stuff he said that was highly questionable? And yes, he blew up. Seen both sides do it.

Agree. Santos's bandwagon vote, in particular, looks very opportunistic.

Unvote, FOS Santos

[-TinVision-]

@Azrael: You'd rather see KoC lynched than, say, Jebus, ahaad, aceagain, or killa, or any of the people who have literally contributed zero to this game? Interesting.

Wait, you want to drop a lynch (which will give us information) in favor of hoping that some other person will blunder. I think that the game will stagnate and we'll lose the people who are already barely playing. How long would you wait to make up your mind? When someone's alignment is known we will have a much better idea on how to proceed.

While a lynch may be better than no lynch, that doesn't mean that no one lynch is better than any other.

It's your responsibility to show us

explicitly where

he has acted in an antitown manner. If you can't produce some evidence for your case, your case ain't shit.

So, let's get some role claims off some people who we find most scummy and then see if we believe them or not.

IMO, we are starting to overanalyze and are getting away from simple basics: let's pressure someone and then see what they say.

I agree, my vote is opportunistic. Why isn't anyone else taking advantage of this so we can either lynch someone or move on to another person?

So, Santos. We should randomly pressure role claims from various people, in the process either outing power roles or thinning the herd of unknowns in which our power roles hide, allowing the mafia a lovely buffet of options for their nightkill? Sounds positively

fantastic

.

[-TinVision-]

God its so easy to lurk here. Jesus.

Yes?

Heh, I love Mel Brooks movies


Anyway, sorry for not being active, I fell behind. I'll be able to post something meaningful tonight, and if not, then in about four days time (vacation, woot).

Four days is not soon enough. You haven't participated at all. Srsly.

[-TinVision-]

I am in France for the holidays and have not had much time to read the game. I will try to catch up in the next day or so.

[-TinVision-]

Hruuuugh. French living has made me so lazy, and there's no reliable wifi in this backwards country. I'll try and catch up.