Mini 1856 - This Mafia Game is for pieguyn (Game Over)

[SirCakez]

I mean I'm obviously the one keeping scum from killing.
Why would I be nokilling here as scum?

[SirCakez]

Point taken, I didn't think of it like that

[SirCakez]

[SirCakez]

wut

[SirCakez]

Point taken, I didn't think of it like that

[SirCakez]

You STILL haven't explained your Gamma townread

[SirCakez]

Actually on that tangent you haven't explained your scumread on me either

[SirCakez]

GE's play looks very solid to me in that I literally cannot think of any compelling reason for him being scum at all. he has been trying to game-solve the entire game, he has been proactive about it, none of his reads come across as unreasonable or disingenuous to me (even if I don't necessarily agree with all of his points)

, and on top of that I really just do not think the way his claim came out D1 or his Wisdom interactions look like scum. all of this is more so the case to me when I take into account the fact that from what I've seen of GE's scum play, he is not such a great scum player and usually gets lynched very early in the game.

All of the bolded stuff applies to everyone who is alive at this point
And past that, what about how his claim came out/Wisdom interactions? I can't even remember what interactions he had with Wisdom.
And that last point is pretty terrible because anyone can have a good/bad game as scum.

Like I don't even think GE is scum but the way you're writing him off as lock town is really weird

pisskop also looks very town to me, but I also think I trust GE enough to where if I could make everyone besides GE dead I'd do it.

And this is extremely vague obviously

[SirCakez]

said it before, I'll say it again: if you have specific things you want me to focus on with him talk to me and I feel I'd be able to explain it better. it isn't me not having a reason, it's just really hard for me to explain this sort of read without going into verbose mode (and honestly I just don't want to do that when not only is he going to be dead soon enough, but the game is probably solved anyway. you've seen me in verbose mode, so I'm sure you can see my point...), so it would be much easier if you could just talk to me about whatever reason you have doubt on him and I can discuss it that way instead. and if you don't remember his Wisdom interactions, ISO them...

the easiest reason for pisskop being town is that scum-him had literally no reason not to go along with me when I pushed the same plan I'm pushing now, which leads to a win for him, at D5 start, but apart from that, I'm in the same position with him as I am with GE.

It isn't that I think Gamma's scum, it's that I think your reasoning for him being town doesn't make sense
What is the plan you're pushing now exactly? You've swapped it up a few times.

I can't even remember what interactions he had with Wisdom.

He thought Wisdom was town and then when Wisdom was all like "I dont think Varsoon's fake claiming" or whatever he sided with Wisdom and hard defended them both. Then when Varsoon flipped scum he said he thought they were softing being Masons.

This is pretty scummy, no?

[SirCakez]

^
Will respond to stuff later

[SirCakez]

What is the plan you're pushing now exactly? You've swapped it up a few times.

lynch you, Luna blocks GE. lynch GE -> Luna if no kill, lynch Luna if a kill happens.

This is pretty scummy, no?

not really?

in the first place, GE's read on Wisdom started out as what would be a hard bus if GE is scum, and he did it in a way that I don't think looks like distancing, in that I don't see it and think that it looks like someone coming up with what they think is a legitimate reason to take issue with their partner's play (especially when Wisdom would be the most competent scum player out of the three of them on that scum team), I see it and think that it looks like someone noticing Wisdom play way off from their usual perception of his play and then stumbling over it trying to firm up a read on him. but moving on, I have the opposite impression you seem to of this, don't really care that it was blatantly wrong - scum just do not overtly try to claim that they're reading two of their partners' posts as a mason soft, and no, it was not an excuse even though it's a misguided line of reasoning, he actually followed through on it D2 after Varsoon flipped with no hesitation at all instead of attempting to find some bullshit reason to get out of it.

even something like "oops, guess I was wrong about them softing masons, I still think Wisdom is town" would have been fine here had he been scum and when I was in a scenario where I was scum and I had faked role info that "confirmed" my partner as town, I would have done something similar if it had gone south (they were a motivator and motivated me N1 and the town vig N2 and I was attempting to claim that this made them confirmed town, I would have just said "WTF motivator was a scum role?" and argued my way out of it if she had been lynched). not the *exact* same situation, but the same principle would apply here, so...

/shrug

Now this is logic I understand re;GE, your earlier stuff about him didn't make any sense (at least to me).

One thing i dont get is...
Cakez keeps bouncing back to GE, when role wise i would be the most likely to be scum from his PoV, yet he called me something like confirmed town:

This seems super simple to me
I'm taking Luna as basically conftown now, so I want to lynch PK and if it's not him, have Luna block Pie again
Or she can block me if she so wishes to try to test around

(I still dont understand why but for the sake of argument let's say he believes that).
Don't you think scum him would be 1v1ing me right now? u.u

I'm bouncing around on GE to analyze Pie, not because I think GE is scum. I said that earlier.

Don't you think scum him would be 1v1ing me right now? u.u

I think he 1. probably can't come up with any convincing argument on your play, or 2. can't push you strategically because the current plan covers you anyway, so pushing you would just lead to the plan being executed and him losing.

if you read the nuance of his posts closely, though, he isn't pushing GE, he is pushing me - this, on the other hand, is something that he *would* do as scum because he has no real other option to get out of the plan I'm attempting to enact besides pushing pisskop, which he already tried to do yesterday without success.

Or I just think she's obvtown at this point
I am down to either you or PK. The fact PK has disappeared now that the pressure on him has gone away is a really obvious scumtell, but your plan has me baffled since it would leave PK, easily the scummiest player alive, alone.

What a shitty place to pagetop lol

[SirCakez]

if you feel really really strongly about it, I wouldn't be opposed to switching the plan around so that Luna blocks pisskop instead of GE and GE survives to the end. I don't think what you're saying about him "disappearing" is even true, though, and again he just doesn't look like scum to me.

go back and read starting from 3044. the reason scum-pisskop would continue to react the way he did there instead of accepting the plan where he wins is... ?

I would prefer that yes

I went back and looked at that post and I think the reason why scum!Pisskop wouldn't go along with that plan is because it conflicted with what he was pushing in thread at the time.

[SirCakez]

I mean obviously I'd rather not be lynched but other then that no

[SirCakez]

^
As much as it pains me to get mislynched for the 30th time (I shit you not, I did a count one day and it was over 20+ times) it's probably for the best

[SirCakez]

Was town, but you knew that already
Block PK tonight

[SirCakez]

Redemption for Zelda?
Fun game until I died, kinda turned into a shitshow at the end. Agree that the setup needed tinkering.