Oman's post
Post 53
- Empking votes a roleblocker, an interesting move, but doesn't come through with much.
Post 54
- Farside mentions pressure, which removes all power behind pressure, because now the pressure-ees know its only pressure. Nice.
Post 56
- If charter is scum, this post is gold. He actually notes the mafia, then votes for the SK....how interesting.
57
- Farside says one of the dumbest things in mafia "I did something scummy but you missed it therefor you're scum." Farside, your plan there sucked from either angle. And I also wonder what your intention was
59
-The first day of christmas, my true love gave to me: Cavity putting on his big boy pants. Cavity gives a good reason for a "slightly less than random" vote which he doesn't overcommit to too early. This looks like a town play to me, and puts cavity in high standing as a player with me.
60-61
- Monkeyman does this interesting thing where he doesn't say that its scummy or anything but says what he thinks it is: "dumb".
62
- cephrir's interesting post. He is obviously reading, responding to farside's post. But doesn't seem to notice the wagon on Occam. Now, I normally would welcome a fourth vote, thinking the pressure would reveal many an interesting thing. But the fact that Cephrir tried to deny it (and still does IIRC) makes it seem very scummy.
65
- Farside basically calls Gremwell out for not joining the bandwagon, specifically: "Do you think being BP is really helpful for the scum?" The interesting thing is that Gremwell didn't say this at all Gremwell said a four vote wagon was a bit rushed, which is completely legitimate and doesn't make any comment on BP in any way, only on the legitimacy of Occam-wagon. Farside seems desperate to get Occam lynched here, or just push blame onto someone. However, that is a hasty conclusion I don't want to jump to.
69
- There are many out there that would call Occam -> Farside an OMGUS vote, but I am seeing it more and more like distancing. It just screams "look while I rationalise this vote". Not to mention the "if you feel I should be voted out etc." looks like getting the wagon to build to allow someone to victimise people. Of course, on the Hanlon side of things (and I've just been rereading games I've played that makes me think that running with Hanlon is a good thing) he looks like a frustrated townie, backed up by the caps at the top.
72
- Farside's worst post to date. It's silly and takes things far further than they should be. It runs off the idea "if you disagree with me on mafia theory you must be scum." I'm almost dissapointed in farside who plays to a much higher standard than sinking to "you think it's obvious? Only scum would think of that plan...even though I did!"
76
- Occam's self vote. I must say: I've not seen a parrallel between a self vote and anlignment, it seems to be a player thing more than an alignment thing.
80
- Gremwell is correct here, you guys running for bandwagons is cool, but you need to have a point to it, and no, lynching page threeis not a justification for a D1 wagon.
82
- Monkeyman incorrectly extrapolates that Occam's self vote was designed to make us think he was town. Especially with the discussion that follows it, its hardly making him look town.
95
- Farside hits me with more of these weird extrapolations about "so cephrir wasn't random voting, that means you don't believe Occam had a knee jerk reaction" and all this. Basically I find farside is trying to push the conversation back to Occam from Cephrir. That means that Occamscum and farsidescum are now less liklely than before, because farsidescum was more likely to let Occamscum go there to go after Cephrir town. Of course Cephrir scum makes Farsidescum much more likely.
101
- Cephrir OMGUSes me. Well done.
104
- DP brings up an interesting point about the comment he made whilst choosing his role.
109
- Worst fucking post ever.
116
- Why is DP so aggressive here? The truth is, I've played with DP (and his...brother) and this is definatly a town tell for him. Huge cop out on the couplets though
125
- Farside denys knowledge of SK. So very interesting, but can go either way unfortunatly.
132
- How interesting is Drago's take here. S/he actually says that there is agreement on open bulletproof roles to the town that is trying to kill a guy for saying the same thing!
136
- EMpking is voting Cephrir but not saying much else.
142
- Is Farside really serious here. Damn, farside, you were a much much smarter woman than this.
152
- Need more information than this. What is the meta, what occured, how sure are you?
158
- Farside...C'mon, you're so much better than this!
160
- Nice appeal to authority. As much as I respect the man, Mr Flay thinking something doesn't make it the epitome of mafia theory.
176
- Farside's tunnelvision is hurting the game, because she is the most vocal she's directing too much of the conversation.
192
- Alignments aside (a dangerous idea): FUCK YEAH! This is an awesome post in a pool of wishy crap.
198
- A really strange point here. I just don't seem to get you this game farside. I don't understand where this comes from or goes to. The reason there is not much of a town quickhammer presence is twofold 1. Because scum tend to hold back their votes to wait for the quickhammer, and 2. there is a much bigger incentive for scum to quickhammer.
200
- A point I'd like to make as well. Farside tends to draw stupid conclusions.
202
- This highlights your problem farside, you're tunnelvisioned. You say twice that you will never concede on a point!
211
- Farside! I love you! "Stuff i missed during the argument" I'm so glad you posted this
224
- Cephrir here, see questions.
226
- Best line ever. Totally relevant.
Questions
Monkeyman
why would you vote someone you thought was stupid over someone you thought was town?
Cephrir
why did you unvote me in 224? There was no threat, you didn't move it anyway.
Farside
What do you think of the line "You're hunting all right, you just don't care you you shoot is the problem."
If Occam is scum I'm looking at:
Crazy needs to be podded:
Mod
: Crazy prod please. That is, a sane prod on a player named Crazy.
It's unfortunate that good oral sex excuses bad chemistry. - Korts
(I kid)