Mini #717 - Alpha Centauri Smalltown (Game Over!)

[Gremwell]

I'll take

a big fat bull's eye

doc

then I suppose

[Gremwell]

4 votes already wow, seems a bit rushed

[Gremwell]

and while we're here

Vote: Cephrir

[Gremwell]

I would think that in this setup that scum would have a very easy time working around a BP and killing off more important roles like tracker, jailer, any that could potentially out them

[Gremwell]

I'm not saying we should lynch the BP at all, I think we should be weary of Occam for the suggestion but I don't see it as particularly damning, I just thought that wagon was very fast, but it is RVS I guess

[Gremwell]

wow, a wagon this early is no good without someone asking some questions to get something from it, I mean 4 people havent even posted yet.

what needs to be understood is that we're looking at a 4 death per day/night cycle, not even counting mismason and supersaint. this game can be over real quick so we really need to make our days count.


and whats the big idea with the attempted self hammer? not liking the looks of that

[Gremwell]

The self vote is a big red flag to me, if you're town and a wagon like that ran up on you in the first 3 pages and actually went to lynch whoever had the stones to hammer you would be soundly trounced D-2.

as for the BP being more dangerous as scum it's nonsense, aside from the vig and sk who wouldn't likely target him, its worthless for scum aside from the argument that it is such an asset for the town.

[Gremwell]

alright then could you kindly explain to me how a role who's sole power is to be immune to a night kill makes it more dangerous than normal to be in the hands of the group doing the most night killing.

He's not lynch proof

He's not going to be a wasted Vig kill

in fact the worst case scenario would be a BP SK, not scum

[Gremwell]

I understand, my above post was directed at Occam in response to this.

as for the BP being more dangerous as scum it's nonsense, aside from the vig and sk who wouldn't likely target him, its worthless for scum aside from the argument that it is such an asset for the town.

You're wrong.

[Gremwell]

in fact the

worst case scenario would be a BP SK

, not scum

Plus how is a BP SK not a really really bad thing? wtf...

bolded for your convenience

[Gremwell]

Since they dominated the last few pages, and most people seem to have an opinion one way or the other, how many people think that either one of farside or occam is defiantly scum?

the reason I ask is that if we can at least agree on that much then we could lynch one and vig the other, I doubt anyone would disagree with a one for one trade

of course this hinges on one of them being definite scum, not just two townies slugging it out

its just a suggestion, as I can see this conflict clouding the rest of the game.

[Gremwell]

I will wait to comment until others weigh in

[Gremwell]

Ok I was hoping to get more people's thoughts on that but I think a day's long enough, anything more and it will get lost in the shuffle.

obviously I didn't actually want a plan like that to go through, I proposed it to get reactions, mainly on how fariside and Occam would respond in regards to the idea.

What I got is that as far as I could tell neither really that sure the other is scum, Farside criticized my plan and Occam voted me saying that he dosn't think farside is scum at all.

from the others I got a lot of FOS's, which was expected, but not much else.

In conclusion, my personal feelings on farside/Occam is right now two townies, though there is something to be said about the level of how personally they seem to be taking the argument, but that said personal shots and vendettas loose games.

[Gremwell]

and

unvote

[Gremwell]

and

unvote