Moo's claim or die post in #61 is surprising. I wonder whether he plays mafia elsewhere?
afatchic's posts 25 and 41 do appear to just be generic comments on game theory with nothing that is specific to this *actual* game.
Post 66 is also a general commentary on game theory.
It is not apparent to me how a vote is effective pressure if you state upfront that the vote is not intended to lynch.KR, post 67 wrote:I explained that I was ready to unvote if a bandwagon should form, indicating that I was pressure voting, not lynch voting.
I anticipated post 70 coming, like, a page ago.
Ooh. Post 71 is interesting too.
afatchic, post 82 wrote:im still unsure about him but in the opposite way, his remarks just sound like an agrevated newb scum to me.
afatchic, how do you reconcile these two statements?afatchic, post 86 wrote:charter i agree, i don't like it when people use the excuse that im new and im just now learning. while it may be true, its a terrible excuse because it can't be proven or countered. my suspicion is def. on moospiker, and if his play doesn't start acting more like a townie to me then i may very well put him at L-1.
So, you're saying that the newbie card is a valid defence in newbie games? I bet if we asked every IC on this site, 100% would disagree with you.afatchic, post 92 wrote:the difference is that i was at a newbie game, where i should be if i am going to play the newb card, you are at a mini game and being a "mafia scum" i have a hard time believing the newbie card.
Post 114 is another generic commentary on game theory by afatchic
Oh, that's really annoying...mod wrote:Vi replaces KrisReizer
Moo claims cop.
MM replaces in.
charter, if you don't buy the cop claim, why unvote?
I thought exactly the same thing. His words very closely echoed JD's which I found odd.Moo, post 166 wrote:Erm... is this me, or does afatchic say the same thing, just in different wording., as if he's trying to come across townish by adding fake stuff to the discussion.But he tries to make it sound as if it's not an agreement
You were answering a question, using someone else's words as your own.afatchic wrote:i was answering a question, while giving my own opinions. if everyone seems to think this, maybe its the truth. have you ever thought about that?
Given that you have given very few opinions on *this actual game* - the fact that you have used someone elses opinion to validate your own ("I think you're scum. Look, JD thinks so too!") does not impress me.
My gut reaction was that Moo plays mafia elsewhere and he was following whatever the meta there is. A second plausible reason would be that he wanted to catch the scum out in a fake-claim.charter wrote:I also figured out a pretty damn good reason to not believe Moo's claim, Anyone think it's odd that he asks for a claim when he himself claims to be a powerrole? What was he hoping to hear? Oh, I'm the doc? Not protown in the least to out the doc. Possible there's a slim chance it's a second cop, but like I said, very slim.
I would like Moo to comment further on this.
Yes, Avinyl has been replaced. Are you still suspicious? How is Avinyl's absence a scumtell now that I have replaced him?MM wrote:On the other hand, my top suspicion is still Avinyl. Mod: is Avinyl getting replaced?
I hope you have a good explanation for this.charter wrote:Waiting for avinyl to get lynched.