On D1 about the only thing he said about me was "I like what I'm seeing from Mike."
N1 he watched me. He later said "I targeted Mike because it seemed there were near universal consensus that he was town."
On D2 a paranoid cop claimed guilty on DDD. About the only thing DDD said about me was "You know what else is hysterical, how people with firm reads like Elvis and Mike on both EL and myself are suddenly so willing to reverse against their own previously held positions. Where's the confidence in your own fucking reads, don't let this liar take the easy way out", which is an appeal to me. DDD was quite vocal between the claim and his lynch but I don't think he ever so much as pointed a finger at me.
I'm not sure how charter gets "DDD was pretty much on ekim" out of any of that.
Here is the scum quicktopic from the game: http://www.quicktopic.com/43/H/THf3mGauvRZ
I never even mention DDD before his death.
The other game I've played as scum vs DDD town is http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=11906. DDD never seriously suspected me until endgame via process of elimination.
The first two nights we killed masons, the third night my partner wanted to kill DDD but I didn't.
muzzz PM to ekiM wrote:I'm thinking we should kill DDD. Mostly because I don't have a real read on his suspicions. And partly because my gut tells me he would be potentially dangerous tomorrow. At first glance, that would leave us with Santos vs Shanba and Kise vs me. Which should give us enough opportunities to win this game, I think.
ekiM PM to muzzz wrote:Current player evaluation:
Shanba suspects Santos and Kise. Was on these lynches: Sho, Raivann.
DDD's suspect died. Was on these lynches: Sho, Raivann, Exalt.
Santos suspects Shanba, said earlier he would follow Kise onto muzzz. Was on this lynch: Sho.
Kise suspects muzzz, DDD, [Santos]. Said he was uncomfortable with a Sho lynch. Thinks ekiM is town. Was on these lynches: Raivann, Exalt.
muzzz suspects Kise. Was on this lynch: Raivann.
ekiM's suspect died. Thinks DDD and Shanba(zazie) are town. Was on these lynches: Sho, Exalt.
Kill options:
Shanba suspects people other than us and is suspected by some. If he's dead, Kise and Santos will go for you? Not the kill I think.
DDD has been on every townie lynch and left himself sitting pretty to vote whomever today. Looks pretty scummy, no?
Santos has been off most of the lynches, and kind of vaguely obv-lazy-town. Shanba might go for him though. He is against you. Maybe...
Kise has suspected you, but also other players, and was against the Sho lynch. I like this kill a bit I think.
I haven't decided what I think is best yet, what do you make of the above observations?
later ekiM PM to muzzz wrote:I sent the kill order on Kise. I dunno if we can change before deadline if we want or not.
I wanted that kill because: it leaves both of us with no recent suspicions, so we can do whatever is most advantageous, it kills a contentious person, it means there isn't an anti-muzzz kise/santos axis.
I respect DDD as a player but his record reading me as scum isn't phenomenal. He wouldn't be my first choice to kill out of that player list (charter and KK would definitely be higher priority).
I don't understand charter's explanation for his vote, or why he didn't provide it right away, or why he didn't provide some documentary evidence of DDD clocking me as scum.
This post is too long.