Okay so I talked in private with Wes and figured out more where he was trying to drive this. It was more who do I think I have a shot to beat at the end.
I'll do a summary with everything breaking it out juror to juror.
Peter-I do not think I had a good enough relationship with Peter to really sell myself as someone he will vote for. I think he is much more likely to vote for Madame or Richie over me, but I'm not counting him out. He was such a wild card in game, that maybe I have a shot at him?
Buckley-I think if Madame is at the end she gets his vote, I think if I am at the end without Madame I get his vote. I don't think Richie is in play for this vote.
Young Writer-I think I fucked this one up too bad to really get a shot at his vote. I think he hands down votes Richie or Madame over me. I'll do my best to talk to him and I have a plan to try to get his vote, but I don't think realistically it works. I'm not going to assume I get this one.
Herman-I think Herman is much more likely to vote Richie. If Richie isn't there, then I think he would probably vote me over Madame? They just didn't really have much of a relationship, however I might have bungled this vote too much to realistically be in play for this.
Duke-I get Duke's vote over either I think. That's what I have to believe at this point.
Royal-Like Writer, I think I bungled any chance I had at Royal's vote. I have a plan to attempt to appeal to him and see if it lands, but I know he wasn't really my fan before he left, I doubt he's my fan on the jury. I think Madame gets his vote regardless of who else is there, and if it's me and Richie that he would be Richie leaning. I don't realistically expect this vote.
Margot-I think Margot is actually solidly on Richie. If it were me and Madame I think I might get a spite vote from Margot not happy at Madame. I don't think she votes for Madame in that scenario.
Suzy-I think I solidly get Suzy's vote here.
Madame (hypothetical)-If Madame is the final juror, I think I might be in play for her vote, though I would need to explain some things that may or may not go over well with her. I think I am more likely to get her vote than Richie is, but I could be reading that wrong.
Richie (hypothetical and unlikely)-If Richie is the final juror, I think he hands down votes for Madame to win over me, but I guess I shouldn't count him out as a potential vote for me? I'm not sure. Either way I would think Madame is more likely to vote me than him.
To recap:
Peter: Madame>Richie>Me
Buckley: Madame>Me>Richie
Young Writer: Richie>Madame>Me
Herman: Richie>Me>Madame
Duke: Me>Madame>Richie
Royal: Madame>Richie>Me
Margot: Richie>Me(?)>Madame(?)
Suzy: Me>Madame>Richie
So without taking the last juror into consideration and assuming Gustave gets no votes like I think he won't...
if I am against Madame:
She automatically gets 4 votes without question: Peter, Buckley, Writer, Royal
I think I automatically get 2 votes: Duke and Suzy
That would leave Richie, Margot and Herman in play. I think I get Herman's vote for a total of 3, and I think she gets Richie for a total of 5. However, this assumes Herman isn't livid with me about the round he went home, in which case I think he would be more likely to vote Madame. Margot entirely depends on how pissed at Madame she is or not.
On paper it might seem like 5-4 but in reality I think it breaks down more like 6-3 or 7-2 depending on if Margot is mad at her or not.
Against Richie:
He automatically gets 4 votes: Peter, Herman, Writer and Margot
I automatically get 3 votes: Buckley, Duke and Suzy
That leaves Royal and Madame as the deciding votes.
I think Royal doesn't vote me and therefore 5 votes go to Richie and he wins.
Madame...might vote for me? So I think I get 4 votes.
The result therefore ends up at 5-4 and I don't think that needle shifts unless I can possibly convince Peter, Margot or Herman to consider voting for me. My move at f6 with Suzy might just be the move that seals the deal to get one of their votes.
On paper I just don't think I stand a shot against Madame, I think she's just too nice and charming whereas Richie might have pissed some people off and I might have a better shot at spite votes?
It's all very much up in the air where I think I have a solid 2-3 votes no matter which way I go for 2nd place, but as far as who wins I think Madame and Richie both are more likely to sweep votes, and I think Madame is just better at explaining her game than I would be if I keep her instead of taking the opportunity to get her out here.
I hope that explains why I feel pretty low about this no matter which way the wind blows. I think I'm leading to a loss here.