So an update, it seems like our ragtag alliance of Scruff, Grouch, Leon, and I are voting for Pikachu tonight. I feel like Grouch is 100% locked into it and I don't think Scruff will act without him, so I'm going to be asking him closer to deadline if I'm in danger so I can make a "shot in the dark" arrest. Based on Grouch and I's shared info (if he is telling the truth), we have it narrowed down to 18 right now and that's before Grouch uses his clue. If he says I need to do it, then I will play my idol instead.