A - Both made the merge, but they were never on a pre-merge tribe together
Poirot
B - Made a post with the word “Congratulations”, in the “Congratulations!” thread
Leon
C - Answered Question 1 correctly in Challenge 7: A Mob Has Formed
Lance
D - Voted out in the second tribal council they attended
Hannah
E - Made identical posts in Challenge 2: Target Practice, except for the capitalization of one letter
Kate
F - Voted out in a Tribal Council at which an item was played
Pikachu
G - Made more than one post in the Challenge 1: Fresh Prints thread
Jenny
H - Highest scorer for their tribe in Challenge 2: Target Practice
Paul
I - Described themselves as “Reliable” in Challenge 3: Profiler? I Hardly Know 'Er! (Paul, Jake, Kate)
Rust
J - Were paired together in Challenge 12: Bomb Squad
Lennie
K - Attended 7 pre-merge tribal councils
Cheddar
L - The character is a dog
Chase
M - Posted in the All-Points Bulletin Board
Nick
N - Voted out in the first tribal council they attended
Ace
O - Did not make any posts in the “Working the Beat” board
Chan
P - Lowest Scorer for their Tribe in Challenge 2: Target Practice (Chan, Leon, Grouch)
Grouch
Q - Sat out in a tribe immunity challenge
Lucifer
R - Won immunity (tribal or individual) at least 8 times (Penelope, Lucifer, Rust, Nick)
Penelope
S - Has posted an image or gif in a Mafiascum’s Finest tribal council thread (Penelope, Jake, Lucifer, Grouch)
Jake
T - Their first name is four letters long
Judy
U - Participated as a witness in Challenge 8: Can I Get A Witness
Scruff