Xyl's Relative Chaos - Game over!

[DrippingGoofball]

has, why did you pardon CC?

His claim that he now has an alignment seems particularly far fetched - even more than his claim of squashed banana.

I was thinking that maybe,

maybe

, he needed to be lynched to gain an alignment. Turns out that this theory is rubbish. CC is just plain scum. How can you not see that? I can't believe you held on to governor powers all this time just to waste it on what is more likely than not a scumbag. You may have lost us the game. What has CC done to deserve a pardon??? It's not like he's a useful power role! At best he's a survivor, at worst he's a SK, or fakeclaiming scum! What were you thinking?

Why on earth would he need to be lynched, AND pardoned, and then get is alignment???

THIS MAKES NO SENSE WHATSOEVER

.

And I don't know where the Nat-hate comes from. Nat has caught scum from what appears to be two different factions. And he's not counterclaimed. There is NO WAY Nat is scum. No way. Think about it.

More and more I think that has is scum. Maybe CC is your buddy and has lynch immunity. As far-fetched as this may be,

it's not as crazy as 'squashed banana' that needs to be lynched to gain an alignment, but that would be in fact dead unless he was pardoned.

I'm willing and eager to re-lynch CC.

[DrippingGoofball]

I'm willing to lynch CC or hasdagas.

But I'll wait for tubby's claim.

[hasdgfas]

has, why did you pardon CC?

Nat's hammer. Simple as that. It looked exactly like a scum quickhammer to me.

His claim that he now has an alignment seems particularly far fetched - even more than his claim of squashed banana.

I agree with that

I can't believe you held on to governor powers all this time just to waste it on what is more likely than not a scumbag.

I didn't say it was one-shot pardon.

You may have lost us the game. What has CC done to deserve a pardon??? It's not like he's a useful power role! At best he's a survivor, at worst he's a SK, or fakeclaiming scum! What were you thinking?

I'm getting a huge gut check telling me we should lynch Nat. Sure, it might be wrong and I may have made a really stupid mistake in pardoning CC, but my gut told me to, and I'm learning to listen to it more.

And I don't know where the Nat-hate comes from. Nat has caught scum from what appears to be two different factions. And he's not counterclaimed. There is NO WAY Nat is scum. No way. Think about it.

I disagree. As I seem to remember it, there was "no way" I was scum after bussing CKD in Thespival. We saw how that worked out, didn't we? I could see Nat bussing a buddy to seem confirmed town to people.

I'm willing and eager to re-lynch CC.

You need a darn good reason to do that or I'll just pardon him again.

I also may know a reason for the no-death last night, but that doesn't need to come out right now.

DGB, what is more likely?
1) Nat is a lying scumbag who bussed his buddy
2) CC made a horrible claim, is a scumbag who has lynch immunity, and I am his buddy who fake-claimed governor

[tubby216]

i am a dirty lil cheater,,

each nite i get pm'd the role of someone else, but i do not learn who has it,

i did get a role pm of scum wich told me that person had two partners

the other one i got was ballot theif wich told me he had no partners,

and the last one i got was the unriquieted lover,

and thats pretty much about it

[hasdgfas]

there were 4 nights, why did you only get 3 roles?

Also, for the scum one, was the rolename "mafioso"?

[tubby216]

sorry i forgot one the 4th was coward but it was a on shot ability,, and yes it said mafiaso,, sorry i was trying to paraphrase i am not sure how much of the roles i can reveal in the game with suffering from mod kill,,, so please understand i am dancing a fine line here

its my idea that crazy and spyrex were partners,, while zazier worked on her own,

[tubby216]

it really sux cause all of the roles are also listed on the front page so yah it looks like i could be makin it all up but i promise i am not

[Natirasha]

_lr_ght. _ _nv_st_g_t_d CC09 l_st n_ght. H_ _s _nn_c_nt.

_f th_ _th_r tw_, r_r__d_ng th_ n_ght fl_v_r _g__n, _ _m w_ll_ng t_ s_y th_t h_sdsf_s _s th_ g_v_rn_r. Th_t l__ds m_ t_ b_l__v_ th_t t_bby _s th_ l_st sc_m.

_n why _ h_mm_r_d. _ n_v_r d_n't h_mm_r.

[DrippingGoofball]

Alright. investigated CC09 last night. H_ _s innocent.

If the other two, r_r__ding the night flavor again, i am willing to say that hasdsfas is the governor. That leads me to believe that tubby is the last scum.

On why I hammered. I never don't hammer.

^^^^partial vowel fill in

========================

Nat. Have you considered the possibility of a Godfather?

I'd still be willing to lynch CC. His story makes no sense whatsoever.

I'm not sure I trust hasdagas. Governor is a town role. But I am wary of his distrust of Nat. VERY wary.

[tubby216]

but why does that make me the last scum?

[DrippingGoofball]

I'd be surprised if you're the last scum, tubby.

I'm way way more worried about Coheed's crazy story that makes absolutely no sense at all. And there's something not quite right about hasdagas. I'm willing to lynch either.

I believe that tubby, Nat and myself are the remaining townies. Coheed and hadagas as some kind of scum.

There is no way, no way that Coheed has a town role. I'm not sure what the mechanics are behind his surviving the lynch yesterday. But I wouldn't be surprised if hasdagas is not a Governor at all. What he might be instead, I haven't a clue. But too many things don't add up with Coheed's role.

He is not town and he must die.

vote: CoheedCambria09

[tubby216]

hmm i am not sure,, and did you claim dgb??

[DrippingGoofball]

I'm the doctor, and I've been protecting Nat.

Tubby, you haven't picked up a role for governor or squashed banana. Or for cop or doctor, for that matter.

But given what we know of the role names, and what you've seen of the roles, is that they are pretty conventional, aren't they.

So do you believe the squashed-banana-turned-townie-if-resurrected story???

And what do you think of the fact that hasdagas buys this cockamamie squashed-banana-turned-townie-if-resurrected role, but does not believe a cop that has proven himself correct twice for two different scum groups?

If the scumgroup consists of only two people, and one mafioso is dead, there may be only one left. A group of two is pretty small for a game this size.

I can think of a few admittedly remote possibilities.

Perhaps the squashed banana is recruited to the scum pair if lynched. That's a very long shot.

Perphaps one of the mafiosos gets an extra life if lynched if they are only two. That would be more likely than my first idea.

But we have NO VIG, and recently, we had at least two kills (one was a lover-type death). SO WE HAVE TWO KILLERS LEFT.

I wouldn't be surprised if hasdagas OPPORTUNISTICALLY claimed governor when he saw that CoheedBanana survived his lynch.

I think the remaining scum are CC, and hasdagas.

If I'm correct, hasdagas will not be able to 'pardon' CC if CC only has a one-shot lynch survival ability.

Our best bet is to lynch CC again. And see whether hasdagas can fake a pardon again.

[tubby216]

ok i believe you

vote cc9

[Xylthixlm]

Vote Count

CoheedCambria09 -

2

(DrippingGoofball, tubby216)

Not voting: Natirasha, hasdgfas, CoheedCambria09

With 5 alive, it will take 3 to lynch.

[Natirasha]

_ th_nk th_t th_r_ m_ght b_ a g_df_th_r _n th_s s_t_p. _ th_nk th_t th_ sc_m r_m__n_ng _s/_r_ t_bby _nd/_r DGB. H_w_v_r, _n th_ s_k_ th_t _ h_ve _ _nn_c_nt _n DGB(_nd s_nc_ _ d_n't w_nt t_ k_ll my d_c _f h_ _s t_ll_ng th_ tr_th), _ w_ll try _nd

Vote: tubby

f_rst.

[Xylthixlm]

Vote Count

CoheedCambria09 -

2

(DrippingGoofball, tubby216)

Not voting: Natirasha, hasdgfas, CoheedCambria09

With 5 alive, it will take 3 to lynch.

[hasdgfas]

Question: Do people want me to pardon whoever we lynch so I can prove my ability?

[Natirasha]

Question: Do people want me to pardon whoever we lynch so I can prove my ability?

S_r_.

[Natirasha]

W__t, n_. D_n't, _f w_ _r_ _n LyL_, th_n w_ _ss_nt__lly thr_w th_ g_m_ t_ th_ sc_m.

[hasdgfas]

DGB, I have a couple questions for you:
1) Why would scum get any ability to stop a lynch, whether lynch-immune or governor?
2) Do you remember the timing of Nat's guilty on crazy?

[DrippingGoofball]

Question: Do people want me to pardon whoever we lynch so I can prove my ability?

I do - in a way. I'm pretty darn sure that CC is scum so I want his dead. And I'd like you to prove your power, too. I'm torn.

Yes, I remember the timing of Nat's guilty. What are you supposing?

[DrippingGoofball]

1) Why would scum get any ability to stop a lynch, whether lynch-immune or governor?

Maybe. Or maybe CC had a free lynch and you're pretending to be governor.

There's something EXTREMELY weird with CC finding out his alignment AFTER he's been lynched. PLEASE COMMENT ON THIS.

[DrippingGoofball]

Wait, no. Don't, if we are in LyLO, then we essentially throw the game to the scum.

We have two anti-town killing factions since no one claimed vig.

CC HAS TO BE ONE.

If he's working alone he may have investigation immunity of sorts.

[CoheedCambria09]

DGB, y is it that you dont beleive Nat now that he says I'm innocent. I don't know why I was told my alignment after I was lynched, or pardoned or whatever happened last night. I'm not a killing role nor am I scum. I am a plain townie, no abilities.

please stop tunnel visioning me. The cop has even said I'm innocent.

I don't like tubby's claim nor do I like how he is sooo eager to go along with you DGB to lynch me again

vote:Tubby