Mini 698 - Georgetown Mafia - Game over

[MacavityLock]

Does anyone really think that we were going to get quicklynch on page 3? Don't you think if we did, we'd have in-the-bag scum for day 2?

In fact, I think that people who don't see that are jumping on the easier Ceph-bandwagon. The first semi-suspicious thing that happens in this game, and you don't want to reason it through? Also, I'm not following on Gorillaz-scum at all. So, yeah, I'm going to

unvote

him.

FoS: StrangerCoug and MiteyMouse

. In fact,

Vote: MiteyMouse

. StrangerCoug at least is saying original things. MM is just following the trail SC is blazing.

[Primate]

Primate: Do you have a posting restriction?

=

jumping on a bandwagon

and going for a quicklynch

=


=

Vote StrangerCoug

[MacavityLock]

Wow, that's crazy awesome, Primate. Could you find a way to shrink those pictures so that the board doesn't blow up every time you post?

[Primate]

[MacavityLock]

Too expensive. /em is a grad student.

[Primate]

Too expensive. /em is a grad student.

=

[Corvuus]

huh.

I check in and interesting things are going on.

First of all, I don't think there is a post restriction. At least, no one enforced by the mod. Primate can just be doing it on his own for kicks.

That being said, if it become unhelpful/anti-town I would ask Primate to stop it and actually speak(post) instead of communicating by pics or smilies.

As for the bandwagoners, I would give them a finger of suspicion and let them answer why they are doing 'anti-town/scum' actions.

...

I have heard that people would rather you vote instead of just FoSing (so as to gain information based on it) but I don't want a possiblity of quicklynch so i will just say Cephrir would be the one whose vote needs to be explained and quickly.

Corvuus

[Primate]

First of all, I don't think there is a post restriction. At least, no one enforced by the mod. Primate can just be doing it on his own for kicks.

[StrangerCoug]

So somehow or other, accord to Primate, I am a convenience store robber. And this is relevant to a game of Mafia because?

[StrangerCoug]

EBWOP:

So somehow or other, accord

ing

to Primate, I am a convenience store robber.

Fixed.

[Atlas]

Unvote: Primate, Vote: Zeppo

for this comment:

Cephir jumping on a bandwagon and

going for a quicklynch

is suspicious and I'd like to hear the reasoning behind his vote.

Primate summed it up nicely; it's silly to say that Cephir actually tried to quick-lynch a player on Page 3 based on...

nothing

. Your bandwagon accusation is accurate and I agree with it, but the red bit grasps at a very unlikely scenario.

My next two are Mitey and StrangerCoug, though they are a bit farther down. StangerCoug for reaching on EvilGorillaz as well. The vote on Cephir is warranted but I don't see what's so scummy, rather than anti-town, about his vote. I'm more suspicious of Mitey because it is usually the scum that blindly follow promising attacks, especially without voting. These two players are up in the air because Cephir's vote

does

justify some question.

I honestly wish we were [out of the RVS].

What made you think that we weren't?

[Cephrir]

So, please explain to us what is in your magic bag Cephir.

As I'm fairly certain Primate has figured out, I was just 1) getting us out of the random voting stage and 2) getting reactions. I seem to have succeeded on both counts.

Also, I assumed Primate was just screwing around to see how long he could keep that up before someone atacked him for it. If that is actually a post restriction, well, that would be weird.

Unvote, FoS StrangerCoug

for flipping out. Although he did play scummily as town in the other game I've played with him.

[StrangerCoug]

I honestly wish we were [out of the RVS].

What made you think that we weren't?

The fact that very few people seemed to care to scumhunt yet. I'm looking at Primate right now.

Unvote: Cephrir

[Evilgorrilaz]

The fact that very few people seemed to care to scumhunt yet. I'm looking at Primate right now.

o_O

FoS: StrangerCoug

Bad vibes.

Also, I assumed Primate was just screwing around to see how long he could keep that up before someone atacked him for it. If that is actually a post restriction, well, that would be weird.

Truth.

[StrangerCoug]

The fact that very few people seemed to care to scumhunt yet. I'm looking at Primate right now.

o_O

FoS: StrangerCoug

Bad vibes.

One of the people I was talking about there was you.

[Zeppo007]

Unvote: Primate, Vote: Zeppo for this comment:

Cephir jumping on a bandwagon and

going for a quicklynch

is suspicious and I'd like to hear the reasoning behind his vote.

Primate summed it up nicely; it's silly to say that Cephir actually tried to quick-lynch a player on Page 3 based on...

nothing

. Your bandwagon accusation is accurate and I agree with it, but the red bit grasps at a very unlikely scenario.

OK, yeah I jumped the gun with the quick-lynch comment. I meant to point out the bandwagoning only and got a little overambitious.

[StrangerCoug]

I meant to point out the bandwagoning only and got a little overambitious.

Be very careful with that. That doesn't usually bode well.

[Evilgorrilaz]

One of the people I was talking about there was you.

Pointing out the obvious is scumhunting?

[StrangerCoug]

One of the people I was talking about there was you.

Pointing out the obvious is scumhunting?

I was referring to your #37 and #39, which were the reasons for my first serious vote. The only two things your next post, #59, do are call MiteyMouse a copycat and vote him, though I do see somewhat of a case on him. I don't know what you're referencing.

[Primate]

So somehow or other, accord to Primate, I am a convenience store robber. And this is relevant to a game of Mafia because?

to leave behind you the corruption of a city ruled by criminal gangs

[Corvuus]

huh. where is that quote of "Mod wrote" from?


....

Oh, the initial story flavor.

...


So I guess you want us to interpret things you say and you will "clap", smiley or otherwise signal approve without words.

It seems like an interesting way to get us (or perhaps me in this instance) to say things instead of you. I get the blame in a way.

It seems like you want me to say that the criminal gangs flavor implies different mafia groups or some variation thereof?

I don't think it helps us to speculate on setup and such until after we get a few dead bodies to see what role/flavor there really is. Otherwise it is a mod WIFOM isn't it?

Corvuus

[Atlas]

Different mafia groups? What the heck? I think you're looking way too deep into the picture. He's just saying that StrangerCoug is scum...

[StrangerCoug]

I don't think it helps us to speculate on setup and such until after we get a few dead bodies to see what role/flavor there really is. Otherwise it is a mod WIFOM isn't it?

I agree with you here. We have to wait until Night 1 to get a idea of how many groups we're dealing with.

Assuming we have no doctors or roleblockers:
One person dies Night 1 = just the one Mafia
Two people die Night 1 = Mafia/Mafia, Mafia/SK, or Mafia/Vig
Three people die Night 1 = Most likely Mafia/SK/Vig, though Mafia/Mafia/Vig isn't too far-fetched an idea. Mafia/Mafia/SK is unlikely in a mini normal.

Simply speaking, we don't know what groups we're dealing with simply because we're all alive. We shouldn't be outguessing the mod, and anybody already trying to do so on page four should be viewed as suspicious for knowing more about the setup than the town should.

I agree with what Atlas is saying as well.

[Cephrir]

SC... you just quoted Corvuus saying speculation was useless, agreed, then basically speculated on the setup based on what hasn't even happened yet. How about we work it out when it happens.

[Corvuus]

just to keep things rolling in a slightly silly way,

FoS: StrangerCoug for trying to agree with me and Atlas and yet speculating anyways!

Don't try to please everyone or else you will make Primate unhappy!

Corv