Well on our way to having another 40 page D1 in a three week deadline game it seems. Hell I confirm and come back from classes to see it on page 3.
Xtoxm wrote:Yes, I am an SK, however I will play as a vig, and I believe Porochaz is some kind of Mafia investigative role.
Is this actually serious? It comes off as a joke in context of the post but seems to be being actively followed up on. I dont understand how it makes poro scum too, since it seemed to be a joke that he called you an SK. If you are an SK though I really think that you shouldnt be around too long, or at least be kept under wraps for your NKs. Anti-town is anti-town. We cant really trust an SK to not deviate from a town plan if it serves in their best intrest (ie creation of prisoners dillema).
I think that wolf jumping as he has with setting up poro for a lynch if xtoxm is a SK is the most scummy thing we have.
Xtoxm wrote:Hopefully people i've played with before like Llama/Kloud will know this.
Well considering the only games I have played with you, you 1) self-hammered as an IC and 2) tried to get me lynched for being voteless town.
I want to talk more before we lynch anyone, but I dont think keeping a claimed SK around (for long at least) is a good move. The longer we go without a scum lynch the more of a liability you become as the ammount of mislynches decreases. It makes sense to get rid of you as fast as possible using that logic.
This whole claim really is something I have never seen before. The closest I have encountered is an SK claiming at L-1 on D2. Also you need to realize that using logic, you wont get NKed by mafia, not even roleblocked. With two kills happening a night, we could be at lylo as early as D2 if there are three scum.
There is too much along the lines of claiming in this game already, both character (which is a null tell at best) and powers (which again can be null, not as often though). Dont like that much activity in either of those two categories.
I dont like the claim and would be ok with a lynch of him today if I could get all the little nagging gremlins out of my head. Now regardless of what we do, quicklynch should not be occuring. It basically gives scum a free kill, and gets rid of a threat to them (town as well) in the process.
Anyways, this is a first in my about 15 games to see a SK claim page 2.
vote wolf
I dont like the setting up lynches with saying "poro must be scum rolecop". While some roles are inherantly town, I have never seen a role (apart from GF and traitor) that can be exclusively a scum role. I have seen town RBers, I can understand a town rolecop in this setup. That is something I would actually give town too as a mod since I dont like conventional investigative roles.
Lets not forget last farside game I was a random JOAT who had no vote initally, so odd roles are not out of the question in the leastbit. Also how would poro of gotten a result already? We havent had a night cycle yet.
