I'll probably be able to sort Ari and Klick a lot better as game goes on so I'm not too worried about trying to get reads on them.
I kind of just read thread and see it as noise and I'm not really good at reading too deeply into that kind of stuff
one thing I will say tho is I don't get what kind of real thought Ari is expecting Klick to genuinely have on page 1?
Idunno that whole thing kind of really doesn't make sense to me.
RH9's only made 2 posts but I do think WIM may be AI for him? I don't think I've ever actually played with scum RH9 but I think he dislikes playing scum
Pedit: Yeahhh the noise is a lot and I'm not super confident in my assessment of it at this point, guess we'll see
I kinda just want more from some lower activity slots here
Pepedit: That's fair, although I feel like Cakez gets significantly easier to read over time cause as town he'll do some towny things at some point that'll shine through, and as scum he'll just have an entire ISO of ??? posts
Pepepedit: Yeah... that was a bit odd. Klick's wording there might've given the wrong impression but I feel like it got clear relatively quickly that it wasn't meant to be that strong of a push? Ari reacted very strongly to it, I think she justified it by saying she didn't wanna let scum get away with doing the same thing again? Which I kind of buy
If there is a way to get Cakez and RH9 dancing together so we can eliminate both I would like to do that.
I don't have any easy way for me to access setup information so like
In post 17, Alisae wrote:
I think 1 of {Cakez, Ari, Klick, RH9} probably yields mafia at least?
I disagree tbh
Cakez and Klick as town here who just had an approach to the game seen as odd is fairly likely
Ari's response to them doesn't really guarantee that there's scum in it because meta + odd playstyles is an easy way for townies to misread other townies (esp since she seems to feel strongly about not letting meta repeat itself)
and RH9 hasn't really done anything
I don't really look at that group and feel like there has to be scum in it
also when I think of players who haven't really done much of anything, I usually keep those in my suspect pool until they do something that makes me want to take them out of the suspect pool.
I would probably flip the player who isn't doing anything > questioning if there is a wolf in my townreads and looking for that.
The former is also just easier than the ladder. If someone is in that category its because they haven't rly done anything that stands out as town and I'm usually pretty good at trying to find innocence in the smallest of things
In post 20, Alisae wrote:
it is a guess and considering we don't really have much to go off of it is better than nothing
In post 21, Alisae wrote:
guesses like that for me are good for getting into things
No I get it that's fair, I like pools like those as a way to solve, that one just didn't click with me
In post 22, Alisae wrote:
also when I think of players who haven't really done much of anything, I usually keep those in my suspect pool until they do something that makes me want to take them out of the suspect pool.
In post 23, Alisae wrote:
I would probably flip the player who isn't doing anything > questioning if there is a wolf in my townreads and looking for that.
The former is also just easier than the ladder. If someone is in that category its because they haven't rly done anything that stands out as town and I'm usually pretty good at trying to find innocence in the smallest of things
I mean true, which I would agree on regarding RH9 here if most or almost all players had posted some stuff I liked at least a little, but Ausuka, Drew, Ydrasse, yessiree? I can't recall any of them doing anything I felt strongly about so far
