ehobanohar is over

[Assmaster]

under that plan, if there are scum in the people who haven't shot then they just have to sit tight and stay alive until the end of the game. town loses even if only one scum is left alive after all town have taken their shot.

Scum who haven't shot are a different proposition. They need to be caught the traiditional (well, you know what I mean) way. This is just a stress free way of catching scum who have already used their bullet, and I think it's a worthwhile use of even a townies bullet to kill a scum without one. Obviously, it could just as easily be a scum who has to use their bullet as well, so it's not like we can guarantee for it to be a scum, either.

The Townies without bullets, from a game mechanic point of view, are completely useless at this point, whilst the scum without bullets are a threat. Removing the Bulletless guys from the game means that we eliminate one of the threats for the cost of some irrelevant townies and a couple of bullets.

[Empking]

This game is awesome but I agree with no more random kills.

[Verbal]

The random kills haven't helped a lot. There was little motive behind most of the kills, so it's hard to pick out scummy behaviour - a lot of players were just shooting because they could.
Similarly, it's not going to be easy to scumhunt those who still have their shots left; because we don't have any vote mechanic, the only scummy thing to do is shoot somebody. And if there are scum refusing to use their shot so that they can use it to finish off the town once they've picked each other off, that removes the only real action that can be seen as scummy.

The Townies without bullets, from a game mechanic point of view, are completely useless at this point, whilst the scum without bullets are a threat. Removing the Bulletless guys from the game means that we eliminate one of the threats for the cost of some irrelevant townies and a couple of bullets.

This is a good point, and we need to remember that the remaining scum can win the game without firing a shot anyway. I can't see that the town has anything to lose if players who've used their shot get themselves killed - it actually benefits the town, as it means we won't waste our remaining kills.

It's going to be an interesting game
But try to lay off random kills now.

[Lord Gurgi]

This is my last post in this game, townies who have used their bullets should STOP POSTING AND BE KILLED BY INACTIVITY.

Any who continue to post and do not die after a week are scum or stupid.

Townies who still have their bullets should NOT WASTE THEM ON THOSE WHO HAVE ALREADY USED THEIR BULLET.

That's all I have to say, I can only hope you'll listen.

[Empking]

What if you vote who we want shot and who we want to shoot.

[Untitled]

under that plan, if there are scum in the people who haven't shot then they just have to sit tight and stay alive until the end of the game. town loses even if only one scum is left alive after all town have taken their shot.

Scum who haven't shot are a different proposition. They need to be caught the traiditional (well, you know what I mean) way. This is just a stress free way of catching scum who have already used their bullet, and I think it's a worthwhile use of even a townies bullet to kill a scum without one. Obviously, it could just as easily be a scum who has to use their bullet as well, so it's not like we can guarantee for it to be a scum, either.

The Townies without bullets, from a game mechanic point of view, are completely useless at this point, whilst the scum without bullets are a threat. Removing the Bulletless guys from the game means that we eliminate one of the threats for the cost of some irrelevant townies and a couple of bullets.

ok, fair point. a slow, quiet death it is then.

[bird1111]

This game is awesome but I agree with no more random kills.

As great as that would be, I wish you luck with that.

[dalt54321]

wow that sucked. i hate random kills... ug why me! see you guys some other game.

[PokerFace]

Stop posting. You are dead dalt. Get over it.

[Bogre]

I think the thing to do now is to wait until all those who have used their kill are either modkilled or post, revealing that they are scum.

Perhaps we could have those at the top of the list with bullets shoot the scum revealed in that manner. We could then do the same thing: wait until the townies without bullets self-destruct and the scum do something to save themselves, then have the next in line shoot them, then wait. So on and so forth.

This would:
A: Force scum among those who haven't lost their bullets to shoot.
B: Possibly out scum if they hesitated to shoot, if one of their scum buddies was up to be killed by them.

Regardless, right now we need to let the townies who've used their bullets self-destruct, and then shoot the scum left.

[Assmaster]

I think the thing to do now is to wait until all those who have used their kill are either modkilled or post, revealing that they are scum.

Perhaps we could have those at the top of the list with bullets shoot the scum revealed in that manner. We could then do the same thing: wait until the townies without bullets self-destruct and the scum do something to save themselves, then have the next in line shoot them, then wait. So on and so forth.

This would:
A: Force scum among those who haven't lost their bullets to shoot.
B: Possibly out scum if they hesitated to shoot, if one of their scum buddies was up to be killed by them.

Regardless, right now we need to let the townies who've used their bullets self-destruct, and then shoot the scum left.

I was debating just flat out /dice random, but I think Empkings suggestion is probably the better one. From the tops ok in a sense in that it's good at knocking out confusion, but I don't think it's better than the other two, especially Emps. His is weak from the point of view it punishes bad town play, but I can live with losing cause I played badly.

[Cybele]

But we limit the amount town shoots to almost guaranteed scum (refusing to suicide). Less waste.

[Cybele]

Ignore that. It was in response to the last post on the last page.

[Luigi Gangsta]

Lol this game is rediculous

[Empking]

Lol this game is rediculous

Is that active lurking?

[Erratus Apathos]

Lol this game is rediculous

Is that active lurking?

As an expert on active lurking, I can confirm that it is.

[Erratus Apathos]

...but seriously, The Pope's Tiara was replaced in a number of games recently, so shooting him would be pointless since he'll probably be killed anyways. It'd be a good idea to look at the player list for more inactives not to waste bullets on. Or at least if you're going to shoot, shoot someone you know isn't inactive.

Also what's with roles not listed on the player list? This game is no-reveal for lazy people.

[lifeofpie]

So, anyone have any opinions on the remaining people?

[Vamparific]

0.o

[Elmo]

Dead

Town (12)

50. Niv - DEAD, see post 18, DrippingGoofball
17. The Jester - DEAD, see post 20, roffman
41. ZONEACE - DEAD, see post 27, Nocmen
33. iamausername - DEAD, see post 30, remussaidow
2. killa seven - DEAD, see post 77, Riceballtail
24. roffman - DEAD, see post 77, Vamparific
18. Raging Rabbit - DEAD, see post 77, Samruc
8. Skitzer - DEAD, see post 77, M4yhem
1. M4yhem - DEAD, see post 77, PokerFace
35. ralder8169 - DEAD, see post 77, elvis_knits
22. UnofficialRulerOfEveryone - DEAD, see post 77, cris150
36. PokerFace - DEAD, see post 87, pacman281292

Scum (14)

Trolls (4)

11. SleepyPanda - DEAD, see post 4, Crazy
48. Nocmen - DEAD, see post 77, Caboose
19. Charter - DEAD, see post 77, Lord Gurgi
47. cr3t1n - DEAD, see post 77, Tovarish

Werewolves (4)

52. Battle Mage - DEAD, see post 4, The Jester
6. DrippingGoofball - DEAD, see post 27, ZONEACE
15. Snaps_the_Pirate - DEAD, see post 77, raider8169
44. Tovarish - DEAD, see post 77, Jebus

Cows (4)

49. dalt54321 - DEAD, see post 6, SensFan
40. curiouskarmadog - DEAD, see post 18, Tarhalindur
32. Crazy - DEAD, see post 18, Niv
20. riceballtail - DEAD, see post 83, Kmd4390

Emo Kid (2)

45. Gimbosarian37 - DEAD, see post 27, Untitled
14. forbiddanlight - DEAD, see post 77, cr3t1n

Living, Loaded (17)

9. Cybele
10. Tombolo
21. imaginality
25. Klebian
27. Natirasha
31. Assmaster
34. lifeofpie
37. The Pope's Tiara
38. vir4030
39. Iron Man
42. Erratus Apathos
43. bird1111
46. Luigi Gangsta
51. Empking
53. Bogre
55. Verbal
56. Elmo

Living, Empty (13)

3. Lord Gurgi
4. Jebus
5. pacman281292
7. Samruc
12. remussaidow
13. elvis_knits
16. Vamparific
23. SensFan
26. Kmd4390
28. Caboose
29. Tarhalinder
30. Untitled
54. cris150

That was fun! Looks like we're down to average large game numbers already. Huh. There are slightly more dead scum than town - scum heavy game or luck? You decide!

[Iron Man]

It looks like even some of the loaded might get modkilled due to inactivity. I dont think that Caboose, SensFan, Jebus, and even others have posted in a while. Give em a couple more days, and a modkill is at their door.

[Natirasha]

No random killing. I'll get something resembling an actual post tomorrow. I'm busy right now.

[Vamparific]

i shouldnt have wasted my shot

[Bogre]

Vampirific: Why are you posting?

[Empking]

Vamparific, that better be your last post.