Jahudo wrote:Adel: If you thought Emp and I were partners, why did you switch your vote?
I was confident about you being scum, it was a matter of identifying who was scum with you so I could base my defense around what would convince the two remaining townies.
EmpT had such a hard-on for me, I figured that switching my vote to him would expose his alignment. I had a townie read on Mane and no read at all on jultub, so it was a matter of picking between jultub and EmpT, and I lacked the townie cred to pressure jultub.
Re: a possible fake-claim, I'm not sure. It would all depend upon the quality of your fakeclaim, and the timing of it.
I honestly feel that hammering PEG was the correct move. He had lurked through day 1 and day 2, and had a single-minded voting record that is almost invulnerable to voting analysis. If he was scum the chance to hammer him wouldn't have lasted very long, so I had to make a risky call.
EmpT's single-minded determination to work against me during day 3 was very counterproductive. Townie tunnel-vision invariably leads to a townie loss. I don't apologize for playing in a way he doesn't seem to understand... much of my day 3 behavior was a direct reaction to his relentless attacks against me.
jultub wrote:Well, I never really needed a signal for when I should log in, since that time was already set long ago ^^ And Adel seemed annoyingly arrogant throughout the game, seems to me that she never questions her own words. Maybe it works when you got something to go on. But considering that I did have time when I first joined the game, and had several personalities set up and chose which one I should take by the roll of a dice you shouldn't rely so heavily on previous play from a person, as PEG proved, someone can go straightly against their meta at any time.
PEG proving to be town in this game only proves that PEG was town in this game. Based off of the evidence I was looking at, I would make the same decision again. Mafia, as I play it, is a game of percentages. Killing PEG when he is playing like that is the correct decision
before
lynch or lose.
Some of you seem to be under the impression that I was lazy and didn't read the game before I hammered PEG. I did read the game, but not as carefully and as fully (taking notes, ect) as I often do. I spent quite a bit of time simply focused on PEG. Either I could determine that he was town, or that he was likely scum, and then I could base the rest of my analysis of this game off of that. Determining PEG's alignment was the key to figuring out the rest of the game. Once I concluded that he had a rather greater than average chance of being scum, I felt that I had to hammer him before his wagon disappeared.
But good game, and well played, scum. I started actually feeling strongly about jultub in the end, but alas, it was too late, for I was dead. Should've taken a stand when I was alive. But it had to be Zid...
