In post 1322, skitter30 wrote:- dwlee figuring out the implications in real time (i.e. i didnt grt the sense that they had already thought thru the implications, like i imagined they would have if scum anc this was planned out)
I figured some things out in real time as well... and DArby didn't really figure them out at all. Surely this counts against a me/DArby team at least as much as it counts against Dwlee being scum?
- while dwlee was coming to the conclusiont that iv is town, iv is coming to the conclusion that dwlee is scum -> this is what i mean by uncoordinated, if they're partners with a corroborated story why do their conclusions feel so disjointed and unplanned?
I mean, Dwlee
had
to come to the conclusion IV was town. Given that, it makes total sense to me why IV would not want to do likewise as that makes them look very heavily aligned. In my opinion, IV laid it on too thick and town-him actually should have been more trusting of Dwlee, but he was afraid of looking too aligned.
- like 954 dwlee has to tell iv the implications of the result -> wouldnt that have been discussed already as scum?
954 isn't necessarily Dwlee explaining anything to IV... it's not like IV would never have made the vote he did if he knew that. It's just Dwlee explaining why that vote is bad from Dwlee's POV, which doesn't seem that hard to fake to me?
- dwlee seemed to have been planning the use of their action since iv claimed, to which dwlee's reaction made you think they didnt know scum had a freeclaim. They cant be scum together and plotted the fakeclaim while dwlee didnt know they had a fakeclaim ...
Well obviously I misjudged whether that was a fake townslip. I really should have realized the caveat about them both being scum, because as I said it makes sense for Dwlee to fake-shade IV for the wrong reason (to distance from the real reason which is that IV was deliberately stalling, something he admitted to by the way!).
- why did iv claim like that to begin ...
Either to discuss with Dwlee if the doctor claim was actually wise, or to see if the wagon would go away on its own. He admitted the latter was true, at least, in
1033.