Really Bad Idea Mafia - Game Over

[M4yhem]

Whoops. Rearranging the format of the forum clock shows that I was actually 26 seconds early myself.

Kill: Grimmy

Wait, so I could have shot Xtoxm?

Just incase...

Kill:Xtoxm

[Xtoxm]

Guys, why didn't you shoot M4?

[M4yhem]

M4? Please, I'm not a motorway.

Maybe it's because I'm obvious pro-town and your case is pure omgus?

[Xtoxm]

Uh, right, whatever.

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

Grimmy, a townie, shot by somestrangeflea during Day 17

Night 17

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

forbiddanlight, a townie, shot to hell during Night 17

Day 18

[Grimmy]

!HAB

Grimmy
someone buried me backwards

[M4yhem]

Sooo...kill Xtoxm then?

Chensi, Erratus, are you planning to kill anyone today?

[somestrangeflea]

I bet you people were all wondering "What happens if X shoots Y?" Well, I worked it out!

• If the scum gets killed, hoorah! It's about freakin' time!
• If town gets killed, then there are a number of possibilities, depending on just who was shot, and who did the shooting.
  • If a 24 shoots a 24...
    • ...and the scum is the last 24, he'll NK a 48 and win the game.
    • ...and the scum is a 48, he'll...
      • ...kill the final 24 and force a three way shootout between Xtoxm, myself and today's shooter, in which the two Townies are trying to shoot first
        and
        shoot scum.
      • ...kill a 48, and leave the endgame choice to the last 24 alive.
  • If a 24 shoots a 48...
    • ...and the scum is a 24, he'll NK the other 24 and win the game.
    • ...and the scum is a 48, he'll NK one of the 24s and leave the endgame choice to the other 24.

Bear in mind that a 24 becomes a 48 immediately after shooting, and I've assumed that a 24 will shoot today.

As may have been apparent already, if town shoots town today, and scum has only shot once, it's game over. In short, if one of {M4yhem, chenhsi, EA} is scum, they

must

shoot or, preferably, be shot, or else they win...

M4yhem and EA have both expressed the desire to see a dead Xtoxm, but chenhsi doesn't seem to have shown any strong suspicions. This concerns me somewhat. So much so that, for now, I think chenhsi should be the shooter.

Mod: If the game's outcome becomes certain, will the game be ended?

[M4yhem]

Who do you think should be the shootee, Flea?

^_____It would be nice to have everyone answer this question actually.

Who shoots who? You have 24 hours.

[Xtoxm]

Chen is the one I am most confident is town, I urge you to keep your bullet...

I'd like EA to kill M4, personally.

[Xtoxm]

Sooo...kill Xtoxm then?

Chensi, Erratus, are you planning to kill anyone today?

If you are indeed scum by all means shoot me a townie will get you tomorrow.

If you really are a townie, then think about what you're doing before handing the game to scum.

[Xtoxm]

M4yhem and EA have both expressed the desire to see a dead Xtoxm, but chenhsi doesn't seem to have shown any strong suspicions. This concerns me somewhat. So much so that, for now, I think chenhsi should be the shooter.

I stongly disagree. I think the final scum is in M4 and EA.

[M4yhem]

I am townie.

Your narrow focus on me is a tactic I often use myself as scum; keeping pushing at one target often emough and people start to listen.

For this reason I can't help but think you're scum.

But assuming you're not; why are you so certain I'm scum?

What makes you sure enough that Chensi is town that you'd give the game to him if you are wrong?

[Xtoxm]

Because you're acting horribly scummy imo...

I have found Chen to look very pro-town, I believe he is. And there are 3 of you with 24 hours. So we have to trust atleast one.

So yes, you could say that.

I would advise you to shoot EA.

[M4yhem]

I find your opinions lack detail...

I will shoot someone if the whole town prefers me to be the shooter. However, I'd rather EA or Chensi be the shooter, simply because I trust both of them less than I trust myself.

[Xtoxm]

Well the bottom 3 are one's i'm really finding townie...

FL is cleared imo, as she shot while the original GF was alive, so a back up goon gaining powers couldn't have done this.

I've just found Chen to look really pro town.

With Grimmy, he doesn't seem to be giving the game much attention...I just can't see him being the mastermind being these nightkills. Unless he's actually following the game closely and just not posting.

I have mentioned why are my No. 1.

With EA, you and him are the one's I can see offing Query last night. He looked like he wasn't for my no brain killing today, and could have potentially put a spanner in the works. Looks like Chen did this anyway though He clearly had the intent for me to die today.

With SSF I guess it's just the last one left, but I didn't like his backpedaling accusation. But I think he probably is town...He's probably more of a nuetral read of mine.

I explained my opinions with this yesterday. It still stands.

I was actually really hoping Grimmy's kill would count.

[Xtoxm]

You and EA are still my top suspects. And you both have 24 hours. So Chen be shooter/shootee is a problem for me.

[chenhsi]

Well, thanks for the support...

While I don't think the game will last that long, I will be gone for a summer camp 8/4 to 8/16.

[KaleiÐoscøpe]

Mod: If the game's outcome becomes certain, will the game be ended?

No

[M4yhem]

Chen- Since you aren't gone yet, how do you feel about shooting somebody?

And who do you think we should kill? Need your input, asap.

[somestrangeflea]

Who shoots who?

I'm a fan of "chenhsi shoots Xtoxm" on the grounds that chenhsi has been unsettlingly fence-sitty, and nothing has changed WRT Xtoxm

BUT

I've just realised that EA completely missed D17 (and hasn't posted in here since Monday despite being relatively active on-site).

Mod: Can we get a prod on EA please?

If EA does not post ve'y ve'y soon, I also support a "chenhsi shoots EA" situation on the grounds of "Don't want a lurker alive at endgame".

[Xtoxm]

I'm a fan of "chenhsi shoots Xtoxm" on the grounds that chenhsi has been unsettlingly fence-sitty, and nothing has changed WRT Xtoxm

What, and leave M4 and EA on 24 hours, so if one is scum they kill the other for the win? Seriosuly?

[Xtoxm]

You say nothing has changed WRT to me.

Why do you even find me scummy?

[Xtoxm]

It looks like you guys just want me dead as policy. Which this late in the game can't be done.