I mean the later not the former (and yeah that's opinion based). I have neither done a meta read of him nor played in the same game with him before. I usually like meta reads, but I've had the luxury of playing with several people from previous games in the ones I've played (and yeah it's only 4 games). I haven't had to read up on a lot of new players previously, at least all at the same time (hello, replacements). Course now I have 1 person I've previously played with and frankly I don't have the time to read up on all of you.dcorbe wrote: When you say "off the wall" do you mean by his standards (which would be based on meta reads) or by accepted best practices for conducting one's self in a mafia game.
I'm not sure what to make of this, but its a contradiction which jumped out at me.LaptopGun wrote:armlx. I thought it odd.You should know from Open 60 that I am given to flights of fancy when I see odd things.Regardless I thought my point was worth saying. All that it seems to have done is stoke some actual serious questioning, which is what the town want to begin with. Whatever. Random voting certainly gives plenty of info and I'm always curious if voting isn't so random.
I mean the later not the former (and yeah that's opinion based). I have neither done a meta read of himdcorbe wrote: When you say "off the wall" do you mean by his standards (which would be based on meta reads) or by accepted best practices for conducting one's self in a mafia game.nor played in the same game with him before.I usually like meta reads, but I've had the luxury of playing with several people from previous games in the ones I've played (and yeah it's only 4 games). I haven't had to read up on a lot of new players previously, at least all at the same time (hello, replacements). Course now I have 1 person I've previously played with and frankly I don't have the time to read up on all of you.
Really, then share what you've found so far, coz I must be missing it....LaptopGun wrote:Random voting certainly gives plenty of info and I'm always curious if voting isn't so random.
No, people get tagged when they refuse to random vote because there is no point (assuming they have played before) and when they try to use the random votes to push something on D1.So, people get tagged as scum when they say the "random vote" phase is random, and when they say it "isn't so random."
This is true. Those that attack people for things that are going on during the random voting phase are therefore making baseless attacks.anyways, i dont understand how anything done during the random vote stage could possible be scum-tells, that's why its called RANDOM-voting stage, enlighten me please. ;]
, so it's random. 