i actually laughed at thisIn post 49, Battle Mage wrote:this is the sorta thing i'd expect scum to sayIn post 42, dsjstr wrote:3 scum?In post 38, beeboy wrote:Elsa is a cheery high energy individual and I hate how they haven't posted yet.
Raya is my only town read her thoughts come from town even if they aren't right I think the aggro is townie. dsjstr is townie for his energy.
Maybe votato but the weakest of the 3 scum would let this game stall and stay dead but votato strikes me as someone to want cred to take charge
I am leaning town because I still think doing this as scum is a mistake.
vote: Elsa
Did the rules say how many scum there were?
VOTE: dsjstr
oopsIn post 77, votato wrote:Raya you said you townread me right? Your vote is on me
Someone's a bit rattled by a page 1 vote, I'd say.
well explain what you were thinking then. why ddid you think there was a neighborhood? why would you think im in it? who would the other members be?In post 80, beeboy wrote:Add a comma after 3, votato is town along with my other reads. That sentence makes sense with the comma
I wish I could take that dumb tell but I don't think I can in good faith.
I can't in good faith fake a reaction for the sake of the gameIn post 63, Raya36 wrote:Why can't you take the reads seriously? Rvs is an important phase to start a game offIn post 37, beeboy wrote:I mean last game I was both NU and had a public mechanic to talk about. Not to mention I could debate those stances with the people who wanted to fight me on it.
This game I have... whatever this is?
And these reads on me for not RVSing which I can't take seriously lol
She still isn't playing but I'll believe her site wide break statementIn post 82, Raya36 wrote:Do you still scumread Elsa?
I said that???In post 81, votato wrote:well explain what you were thinking then. why ddid you think there was a neighborhood? why would you think im in it? who would the other members be?In post 80, beeboy wrote:Add a comma after 3, votato is town along with my other reads. That sentence makes sense with the comma
I wish I could take that dumb tell but I don't think I can in good faith.
oh no, it was someone else who brought up a neighborhood re what you said. your post makes sense. dunno where that neighborhood thought came from from the other personIn post 85, beeboy wrote:I said that???In post 81, votato wrote:well explain what you were thinking then. why ddid you think there was a neighborhood? why would you think im in it? who would the other members be?In post 80, beeboy wrote:Add a comma after 3, votato is town along with my other reads. That sentence makes sense with the comma
I wish I could take that dumb tell but I don't think I can in good faith.
Eh. I think Beeboy jumped on the gone slot too soon, particularly as someone who didn't see my VLA message or status, and probably also knows I really like playing scum.In post 91, Raya36 wrote:Do you have any reads or thoughts Elsa?
I like those RVS please vote me posts, I won't hold that read all game but I also am fine with it on page 4.In post 88, Raya36 wrote:What is it you like about that post? I didnt find it particularly AI
I hate altsIn post 94, Yukino wrote:I like those RVS please vote me posts, I won't hold that read all game but I also am fine with it on page 4.In post 88, Raya36 wrote:What is it you like about that post? I didnt find it particularly AI
I disagree since I don't see why scum can't easily do that. I still stand by it being NAiIn post 94, Yukino wrote:I like those RVS please vote me posts, I won't hold that read all game but I also am fine with it on page 4.In post 88, Raya36 wrote:What is it you like about that post? I didnt find it particularly AI
The point is I don't see the need to justify yourself after getting confronted or questioned which comes of as unnecessarily defensive. As if anyone writes anything substantial on page 1, so I would have just shrugged it of. I don't think max's reason is necessarily great (not even sure he himself originally really had a reason besides provoking a reaction), but it's an approach I can agree with with testing you. And you seemed pretty upset by it, more concerned about yourself than figuring others out, even in this post above you are fingerpointing like why you and not Elsa, BM or me.In post 50, dsjstr wrote: What does your comment have to do with my "apology"? Which was me just reflecting on my own gameplay. Max's comment is complete bullshit, elsa has not even spoken and BM has only questioned why no one voted for him. It was not a response to
Max he has already been questioned about the legitimacy of his claim by someone else. I will ask what you think of his reasoning which when he had switched votes was while you had also left a refrence to the vroom comment and BM had not spoken
I think it's vice versa as micros usually tend to have 2 scum otherwise the normal queue can bite me. So coming up with 3 in a micro can be seen as an unconsciously townslip as scum knows the exact number. But as others pointed out beeboy seems too smart for something like that, so... :shrug:In post 61, dsjstr wrote:Town were never informed how many scum there are mafia would know. If they accidentally said how many scum there are it would be a scum slip not a town slip.
I've been thinking that there could be a neighborhood with 3 people which would be way too town sided if there were no mafia in it, and they were saying that votato would not be mafia out of the three.
If I go by the context of some comments you and votato seem to be familiar with beeboy and he is mechanically too smart for such a dumbtell, then why would he drop as scum such a thing in a game with people who apparently see right through it?In post 65, Raya36 wrote:Actually to add to why I think this is possible they didn't even need to say how many scum to get their point across. The "3 scum" was added in without necessity.In post 43, votato wrote:its an 8-player, so 3 seems excessive, even if town has a lot of power. seems like a dumbtell. which might suggest beeboy is scum? or just not paying any attention?