Scummies 2008 Nominations! (Deadline: 1/15)

[petroleumjelly]

I had accidentally included the Empking "QFT" as seconding the Ythill nomination for Best Individual Play (Scum) for The Neighborhood. I'm supposing "Neighborhood" (i.e. the Hood) = "Gangland" in my mind.

Updating shaft.ed. I didn't drop anything from Guardian's list because I didn't use his list (since he was missing the nomination of Assassins in the Palace II, despite the fact that his own alt account had done the nominating, so I didn't really trust his list at all).

Edit: Also, when you reference

anything

(even a nominating post that was forgotten),

please give a link

. Compiling all that took probably four hours, by the end of which time I had very little patience to bother finding links for things that were not linked to for me.

[Thestatusquo]

Shyguy is oman?

O.o!

[petroleumjelly]

Yes. Because I was clearly talking about Oman's list.

[Thestatusquo]

I meant guardian. Equally shocking. I don't know why oman popped out of my fingers.

[BridgesAndBaloons]

Whoops, I thought a nomination I made was missed, but it wasn't.

PJ is awesome.

[Mr. Flay]

Alright, second post is accurate as of PJ's post 619, Dec 09, 2008 11:48 pm edit. I did some minor cleanup, so we can probably go forward without full quotation...

[PokerFace]

Alright, second post is accurate as of PJ's post 619, Dec 09, 2008 11:48 pm edit. I did some minor cleanup, so we can probably go forward without full quotation...

a no

[*]

Best Role Claim

- "Johnny Cochrane" Award...
[*]

Funniest Role Claim

- "George W Bush" Award...
...
[*]

Best Performance by an Individual (Pro-Town)

- "Oscar" Award

• Pokerface in Satin Doll Showdown – nominated by Elmo

I technically believe Elmo is pointing out the bizarre claim/gambit I made since my general play in that game was not that good. That claim was the only thing good I did in that game. Here is the link to my claim of

Obnoxious Drunk

(Super Saint)

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopi ... 69#1212869

PM elmo for more details in case he didn't see this but I believe that's what he meant since my overall play in Satin doll was subpar

talked to elmo and it was for claim not overall play

[Mr. Flay]

I didn't say it was accurate, I said it was accurate as of PJ's post. I'll try to integrate stuff since then today.

Meanwhile, I still don't know if Elmo wants Best Role Claim or Funniest Role Claim. Get him in the thread to clarify...

[Elmo]

I really didn't (and don't) know what it should come under, I was thinking of "best gambit" or similar, but "best role claim" fits quite well, I think.

[Tarhalindur]

Second Pokerface for Best Role Claim for Mini 594

Probably cost me a win, he did.

[Kinetic]

Nom: Tar

for

Best Contribution to Mafia Discussion

Most specifically for his introduction of a new game mechanic which he used in two of his latest games that I believe has huge potential to change the way mafia games are made and played. The mechanic I am referring to is the

Punisher Roles

(his name) that he created in B5 and Mind Screw 2.

I feel that this is more than just a "Best Role" nomination mainly because the roles themselves are not what I'm targeting. Its the idea BEHIND the roles which I feel should be recognized.

Mind Screw 2 had one punisher role:
Role: Tarhaliander, played by Nat in MS2

B5 had two:
Soul Hunter, played by Vis Major and
Lorien, played by Darox

[Guardian]

I meant guardian. Equally shocking. I don't know why oman popped out of my fingers.

lies.

[Lord Gurgi]

Nom: Tar

for

Best Contribution to Mafia Discussion

Most specifically for his introduction of a new game mechanic which he used in two of his latest games that I believe has huge potential to change the way mafia games are made and played. The mechanic I am referring to is the

Punisher Roles

(his name) that he created in B5 and Mind Screw 2.

I feel that this is more than just a "Best Role" nomination mainly because the roles themselves are not what I'm targeting. Its the idea BEHIND the roles which I feel should be recognized.

Mind Screw 2 had one punisher role:
Role: Tarhaliander, played by Nat in MS2

B5 had two:
Soul Hunter, played by Vis Major and
Lorien, played by Darox

This should be "Best Role" because you are talking about the Roles. This is not really a contribution to Mafia

Discussion

.

[Guardian]

Nominate Skruffs for best flavor text in Contagion Mafia.

Second Skruffs for best setup in Contagion Mafia.

A game I wish I had played in.



Third shaft.ed for most cunning manipulator; his performance in Adel's nightmare is representative.
Second Kison for most cunning manipulator; his performance in iPick is representative.

[Stef]

Third PF for best role claim in mini 594

[forbiddanlight]

Nom: Tar

for

Best Contribution to Mafia Discussion

Most specifically for his introduction of a new game mechanic which he used in two of his latest games that I believe has huge potential to change the way mafia games are made and played. The mechanic I am referring to is the

Punisher Roles

(his name) that he created in B5 and Mind Screw 2.

I feel that this is more than just a "Best Role" nomination mainly because the roles themselves are not what I'm targeting. Its the idea BEHIND the roles which I feel should be recognized.

Mind Screw 2 had one punisher role:
Role: Tarhaliander, played by Nat in MS2

B5 had two:
Soul Hunter, played by Vis Major and
Lorien, played by Darox

Maybe there should be an award for best contribution to the meta?

[Tarhalindur]

Why am I starting to get the feeling that the Best Role Scummy probably has my name on it?

[Lord Gurgi]

Why am I starting to get the feeling that the Best Role Scummy probably has my name on it?

Well now it doesn't.

[forbiddanlight]

Why am I starting to get the feeling that the Best Role Scummy probably has my name on it?

I still say Lain deserves it. (Also, I might be borrowing that role for an offsite game if possible)

[curiouskarmadog]

would like to

3rd Rhinox for best new person

(if it is needed)

was going to nominate him for this but saw someone already did...good player provides ton of content...good addition to the family.

he has completed a couple other games since the nomination...he is demostrating the ability to learn and adapt...and I bet he will still be around next year to get the award.

[farside22]

Just one thing I found wrong:

Elmo, farside22, destructor in AoaDa – nominated by Incognito, seconded for Elmo by destructor (???), thirded by farside22

I forgot who did the nom for this, but I stated Elmo deserved the award by himself.

[Lord Gurgi]

Can anyone tell me why there are no nominations for Paragon of Mafia Hunters? Someone has to apply. Same goes for Best IC.

[pickemgenius]

Can anyone tell me why there are no nominations for Paragon of Mafia Hunters? Someone has to apply. Same goes for Best IC.

ok ok. ya got me.

I accept.

[Glork]

Can anyone tell me why there are no nominations for Paragon of Mafia Hunters?

Sup.

[Lord Gurgi]

Can anyone tell me why there are no nominations for Paragon of Mafia Hunters?

Sup.

Yeahreally. But no one wants to nominate Glork.

Nominate Ether for Paragon of Mafia Hunters for use of Glork arm

.