Scummies 2008 Nominations! (Deadline: 1/15)

[Thestatusquo]

Nominate YThill both for

most enjoyable game, mini

as well as

best flavor text

For gangland mafia

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=8923

[Stef]

Third VRK for behind the scenes

[Max]

morph, I think it should be done as well, but I agree with K9, it should not be a part of the scummies

[animorpherv1]

morph, I think it should be done as well, but I agree with K9, it should not be a part of the scummies

I doubt that mods are gonna do "mashies", so this would technically go under the Non-Game.

[Max]

The mods don't really do anything, some judges are picked, general members then mith posts the results. The mashies would have to be organised by a regular "Masher"

[animorpherv1]

The mods don't really do anything, some judges are picked, general members then mith posts the results. The mashies would have to be organised by a regular "Masher"

:p I know what your thinking.... the answer is it would take too much out of me, with what I'm currently doing there.

[Max]

You don't have to judge, mith doesn't judge, create a thread for next year, get some ideas for mish mash awards then in Nov next year delegate some judges and then post the results

[animorpherv1]

You don't have to judge, mith doesn't judge, create a thread for next year, get some ideas for mish mash awards then in Nov next year delegate some judges and then post the results

After a certain thing finishes, I will.

[Ythill]

Nominate:

vollkan and SCAM (a tsq alt)

Award:

Best Performance by a Team

Game:

Gangland Mafia

Summary:

Though these two were not masons in this mason-heavy game, they worked together to expose all of the scum by D2, leading to a town win by the end of D4.

Nominate:

Ythill (self-nominated)

Award:

Best Mafia Catcher

Game:

The Kingmaker's Revolt

Summary:

Playing the survivor-kingmaker, I decided that a quick town win was my best option for survival. I accidentally made a scum king D1, but cornered him into bussing his buddy. Then I talked the new king into hanging him on D2. I died that night (NKed by both scum groups) but not before naming the remaining three scum. Meaning that I'd found all five scum by D2! Read the post-game for the reactions of the mod and other players.

[animorpherv1]

Nominate:

vollkan and SCAM (a tsq alt)

Award:

Best Performance by a Team

Game:

Gangland Mafia

Summary:

Though these two were not masons in this mason-heavy game, they worked together to expose all of the scum by D2, leading to a town win by the end of D4.

second

self noms-poop

[Yosarian2]

Yeah; self nominating is against the rules, Ythill.

[Ythill]

Sorry, I saw a lot of self-noms in the second post, so I thought it was okay.

[Porochaz]

As much as I hate to for his extrememly (deliberate) terrible play in my game, abr lead the town to victory and deserves the nomination

second the MoS nomination for ABR - best town performance - MAFIA 72

[MafiaSSK]

Nominate: Natirasha and the Cultists

Award: Best Performance By a Team

Game: Time Abuse Mafia

Quicklynch'd town at lylo and won.

[Grandfather Time]

Nominate: Natirasha and the Cultists

Award: Best Performance By a Team

Game: Time Abuse Mafia

Quicklynch'd town at lylo and won.

That whole

game

was nuts, and awesome.

[forbiddanlight]

Nominate: Natirasha and the Cultists

Award: Best Performance By a Team

Game: Time Abuse Mafia

Quicklynch'd town at lylo and won.

I'd say more best by an individual (cult), with Nat, but I'll

Second this

[Lord Gurgi]

Nominate: Natirasha and the Cultists

Award: Best Performance By a Team

Game: Time Abuse Mafia

Quicklynch'd town at lylo and won.

I'd say more best by an individual (cult), with Nat, but I'll

Second this

Frankly, the cult buddies won by virtue of being picked, they did nothing. MafiaSSK voted for the quicklynch before he knew he was cult. Then proceeded to win it as a result.

[Thestatusquo]

That doesn't really sound scummy worthy to me.

[Vi]

That doesn't really sound scummy worthy to me.

I agree with this disagreement.

[gorckat]

Nominate: Ythill

for

Best Performance: Mafia

in Mini 659: The Neighborhood.

He snowed the town pretty much from the get go.

[crywolf20084]

Nominate: Ythill

for

Best Performance: Mafia

in Mini 659: The Neighborhood.

He snowed the town pretty much from the get go.

Second

[Empking]

Nominate YThill both for

most enjoyable game, mini

as well as

best flavor text

For gangland mafia

http://www.mafiascum.net/forum/viewtopic.php?t=8923

QFT

[Ythill]

Sweet. Thanks for the seconds.

I'm going to nominate a competitor for one of those categories however, and I know he deserves the scummy more than I...

Nominate:

gorkat

Award:

most enjoyable game, mini

Game:

The Neighborhood

Summary:

The set-up included a GF and a miller but no cop, a note-writing mafia spy, and a nosy neighbor. The balance was perfect... skill seemed to play a part at every turn. And the game was high-tension from start to finish. I've played a few very good minis, but this one was the best by far.

[Caboose]

I nominate

PetroleumJelly

for

Best Setup

.
Game: Read Your Role Mafia

Suggestion for new type of award:

Best Vigilante

- "The Punisher" Award

[Kinetic]

I nominate

PetroleumJelly

for

Best Setup

.
Game: Read Your Role Mafia

second