Mafiascum.net

No offense but I don't see much of a reason to follow your reads when it doesn't seem like you're putting all that much effort into this

Meh, I'm still learning how to read people and build a case against them. My wagon is almost certainly scum motivated in an easy mislynch.

In post 1074, ThinkBig wrote:Final scum reads: Hans, kop, and/or desperado are probably the last of the scum. I will be back around 11 PM EST.

Good luck town!

Like I don't understand where this comes from?

In post 1066, ThinkBig wrote:

Realeo wrote:
I feel that ThinkBig is plagiarizing his read list. He just collect what people think, snap into a read list and call it "ThinkBig's readlist"

This accusation is false and highly offensive.

Well, prove me that I am wrong.

It comes from scum who gave up like a week ago but we keep dragging our feet so he is compelled to produce something. It's not surprising that his "content" has been lacking.

My thoughts are...

I hope in d3, our Inactive Child would become Innocent Child.

Guys, I hacked into algebra's account and I checked his role PM!

Hello again, algebra.

Your role is now

Inactive Child

, you are still aligned with Town.

During the day you may

not

post in the game thread and

vote to lynch any living player

. I will confirm you as town publicly at the beginning of the game. You win when all threats to the Town are dead and at least one Town-aligned player is still alive.

Game thread is here.

meh

We don't need Algebra to lynch scum.

Algebra is a fucking normie.

In post 1076, ThinkBig wrote:Meh, I'm still learning how to read people and build a case against them. My wagon is almost certainly scum motivated in an easy mislynch.

If you are Town, nothing that you say is remotely helpful in catching the real scum. Scum are on my wagon, 'I find this comment offensive', baseless reads.

Also you still haven't got round to rebutting Desperados case against you by trying to explain your sketchy behaviour D1.

In post 1074, ThinkBig wrote:Final scum reads: Hans, kop, and/or desperado are probably the last of the scum. I will be back around 11 PM EST.

Good luck town!

Why?

I am shocked--SHOCKED--that he never came back btw.










































Shocked.

(Desperado, Alisae, davesaz, Realeo)
(Kop)
(Dunnstral)
(ThinkBig)

(algebra, Superhans, Gamma Emerald)

Hey everyone! Been a little while seen I've actually played a game here. I'll be catching up with the thread in the next few hours. If there's a particular section you want me to focus on more let me know as soon as possible.

Will say I found the "Inactive Child" section on this very page quite amusing.

You had pretty good dead thread analysis in the dance game

By the way, nobody can answer who's scum in tb is town. Nobody is even attempting to find scum. Even if tb is scum there's still another one you know

I'll let you know what I think about TB when I'm through the thread, the crickets about to finish so I'll be able to actually start it very soon. If there's any other role claims (Other than it being revealed I'm an IC) that I should know about let me know. Oh and I saw you mentioned that you've played this setup as scum before, you got a link to the game thread / your mafia QT there?

In post 1091, Dunnstral wrote:You had pretty good dead thread analysis in the dance game

Thanks I guess? I didn't start following the game until around the time of Pies suicide though and at that point it was fairly apparent you were scum already, I didn't have the Scout/SAD pair correct, knew there was scum in there but thought it was probably Scout over SAD until the last few days of the game where it became obvious you and SAD were setting up for the win and that you had it fairly secured. You both played a fairly impressive game.

gamma claimed goon cop day 2 - realeo not goon

Lol are people seriously voting ThinkBig, the fuck is going on.

I'm only at page 14 and only read Antihumans first replace in post (Post 329) but that post alone means that ThinkBig is probably town given the fact that Antihuman flipped traitor; for ThinkBig to be mafia you'd have to believe that Anti's first move when replaing in was hard bussing a a partner as a traitor, it's far more likely he tries to push a mslynch there. My mind could change given there's still ~30 more pages to read but there better be a really strong case on ThinkBig being mafia to disregard that post.

Almost fully up to date, currently at page 32. Would be very amusing if the scum team was Kop/SuperHands given Post 388.

Will have my thoughts on all players up in the thread in the next two hours. Would be nice if someone could be online around then to bounce some thoughts with.

Realeos early town read on TB in Post 65 as well as the elaborated reasoning in Post 70, Post 72 and Post 78 comes across as very genuine, I disagree with the logic behind it but I think he believes what he's saying and I like that he nullifies his read upon finding out it's something that TB has done before in Post 121. I find his paranoia / pocketing conversation with Dunn in the early game much more likely to come from a town mindset around ~Post 93. I also find his stance on AH in Post 361 to lack scum motivation; scum would be considering AH as a regular townie at the time and thus considering him and Hans as potential mslynch bait, to rule that out by calling the concerns playstyle "awkward" related limits scum. I think his discussion about his excel sheet and his read on Kop in Post 504 and Post 551 come across as town and think the quick unvote in Post 553 fits a town mentality of being unsure of themselves rather than scum being waffly, also think the activity around the deadline in Post 557 - Post 561 lacks scum motivation, he'd given himself an out to lurk for a bit as scum but the want to instantly jump back in this has a gamesolving attitude behind it. I think his tin foil theory behind his town read on Desperado & Alisae in Post 1041 is one that comes from town far more than scum and the massive amounts of detail in hunting via AH's ISO is a fairly big town tell here. Gammas "Not Goon" result on him also increases the odds of him being town from that alone. All up though I'm pretty confident to bet the game on Releao being town regardless of Gammas legitimacy or however many number of power roles we have in this game. So yeah, Reaelo is always town here.

Will probably out my reads on everyone in sections, normally I make a fancy coloured wall but I'm feeling slightly lazy and rather get these individual reads into the thread asap.

In post 1088, grapes wrote:

DAY 2 VC 005

ThinkBig ( 4 ) -

(Desperado, Alisae, davesaz, Realeo)

Gamma Emerald ( 1 ) -

(Kop)

Alisae ( 1 ) -

(Dunnstral)

Desperado ( 1 ) -

(ThinkBig)

Not Voting ( 3 ) -

(algebra, Superhans, Gamma Emerald)

Six to lynch.
(expired on 2017-01-21 05:24:02) remain until deadline.

Seeking replacement for algebra.